Release List Reviews Price Search Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise
DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk TV
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns



DVD SAVANT

To Have and Have Not


To Have and Have Not
Warner Home Video
1944 / B&W / 1:37 flat full frame / 100 min. / Street Date November 4, 2003 / 19.98
Starring Humphrey Bogart, Lauren Bacall, Walter Brennan, Hoagy Carmichael,Dolores Moran, Sheldon Leonard, Walter Szurovy, Marcel Dalio, Walter Sande, Dan Seymour
Cinematography
Sid Hickox
Art Direction Charles Novi
Film Editor Christian Nyby
Original Music Hoagy Carmichael, William Lava, Franz Waxman
Written by Jules Furthman, William Faulkner from the novel by Ernest Hemingway
Produced by Howard Hawks, Jack L. Warner
Directed by Howard Hawks

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

This is the legendary Bogart picture that never fades, thanks to our knowledge that Bogey and Bacall's romantic sparring is being echoed off camera in their real lives. Hollywood fantasies get crimped a bit when we find out that Clark Gable and Vivien Leigh or Bogie and Bergman were really just professionals feigning all the love stuff; but here we can imagine the depth of glossy romance behind the surface of the story.

Howard Hawks makes To Have and Have Not one of his classier pictures, again sketching a man's world where a laconic pro can stack his wits against dangerous personalities and politics and seldom bat an eye. There's a lovable sidekick, colorful bit players with lovable nicknames and surly villains that talk big put are really pushovers for our charismatic hero. And don't forget the Hawksian singalongs! Here we have Hoagy Carmichael, a real pro to make the Hollywood slickery go down even smoother.

Synopsis:

Adventurous fishing boat operator Harry Morgan (Humphrey Bogart) is stiffed for his pay when Vichy-Gaullist gunfire breaks out in a cafe in Martinique, killing his client. But two new interests have come into his life: helping the Gaullist freedom fighters led by cafe owner Gerard (Marcel Dalio), and chasing lost adventuress and slinky, husky-voiced saloon hustler Marie Browning, otherwise known as 'Slim' (Lauren Bacall).

Everyone went to Ricks, but we still keep coming back to To Have and Have Not to watch Bogie hike his pants up like a tough guy (he almost makes us think he isn't a creampuff) and Bacall slink around with a trampy-but-classy swagger that hasn't dated in 60 years. Bogart is the star but it's really her picture. The nervy teenage model from New York got a new name (bye bye Betty Jean Perske) and a ticket to immortality by having the perfect look and the perfect voice and a sexy attitude. Older femme fatale types like Marlene Dietrich suddenly looked like your Aunt Bessie.

Bacall's 19 year-old thin face was a collection of outsized features, with lips and a mouth that seemed bigger than her jaw. When the cartoons lampooned her she was difficult to exaggerate, but it all looked terrific. She doesn't date because she combines an aura of class with a knowing, experience-filled look in her eyes -- that can change instantly to confess her real age and honesty. Part of the fun of watching To Have and Have Not is seeing the teenager peek through the vamp act at regular intervals. Her screen persona has a transparency that reveals a person we like.

To Have and Have Not has all of Howard Hawks' strengths as a story-teller. The even flow of scenes downplays structure to emphasize his pleasant mood of adventure and manly-man camaraderie. Harry Morgan's little fishing boat is not exactly glamorous, but his loyalty to his alcoholic sidekick Eddie (one of the defining roles for Walter Brennan) makes us side with Morgan unconditionally. Now of course, we think he'd be a better pal by helping Eddie dry out, but in Hawks' world, a man has to decide for himself when to get on the wagon and reestablish his dignity. There must have been a lot more ignorant drunks back then.

Hawks downplays the moral and political issues and lets Morgan's loyalties slide to where they'll naturally come to rest anyway. Morgan doesn't lose sleep deciding to help the good guys, that's just that kind of self-sacrificing guy he is. Again, Hawks' manly-man world is a fantasy that's too attractive not to like.

Audiences adored the atmosphere of saloons and cigarette smoke where attractive types like Bogie and Bacall stayed witty and sexy no matter how much they drank. Bogie's Morgan is a professional who respects Slim's status as a pro player in her own league -- she's an orphan in the woods who gets by by playing the barroom tout for drinks and favors. What little character tension exists comes when Morgan accepts her independent Hays-Code-tamed promiscuity for what it is. She would rather he get jealous or possessive. The Hawks world of female equality hides his repeated assertion that modern woman's posture of independence is yet another clever bid to hook her man.

It's a fantasy. It works well, and makes plot a secondary concern. The best thing to be said for Howard Hawks movies is that they work as movies and not literature with themes to promote. The lumpy To Have and Have Not seems a lot longer than its 100 minutes, but it's a relaxing and entertaining ride.

Better than that, it's a key Hawks movie that breaks ground instead of repeating themes as he did later in his career. So called 'classics' from Rio Bravo on recycle bits and ideas as if the director had nothing more to give. For that matter, Hawks was prone to repeat himself even earlier -- compare Bogie's hand-shaking after a gundown ("See how close you came?") to Montgomery Clift's, Ricky Nelson's and even James Caan's identical schtick in much later films. These older pictures are sometimes considered fossils, but when Hawks really cooked, titles like Only Angels Have Wings and Air Force seemed the height of masculinity for the generation that preceded us.


Warner's DVD of To Have and Have Not is a sensibly scaled, excellent reissue of a studio tentpeg classic. The transfer is a huge improvement over the 90s laser disc, with a punchy picture and great audio: Bacall's (or her singing double's) voice no longer distorts on the deep notes.  1

Frankly, I'm not ready to wade through hours of special edition material for every title, and this release is given a refreshingly brief overview featurette on the basic facts of To Have and Have Not and the whirlwind romance that pried Bogart from his wife and into the arms of Betty Joan. Also on board is a radio reprise of the story, that speeds things up considerably. The original trailer sells the movie as an action blockbuster, carefully choosing every gunshot, punch, push, shove and twitchy body movement in the movie to make its case. It also sells Bacall and the forgotten Dolores Moran with equal emphasis; I wonder what Moran thought when she realized her big opportunity was to be steamrolled into oblivion by the collision of the Hollywood galaxies that were Bogie and Bacall. That's the breaks, kid.

Was Hollywood more aware and respectful of Val Lewton than I thought they were? Actors Sir Lancelot, Chef Milani and Marguerita Sylva are all transplanted from Lewton's The Seventh Victim and I Walked with a Zombie for bits in To Have and Have Not.

Hemingway's basic story has been done several times. 1950's excellent The Breaking Point makes the Morgan character a working stiff up against economic problems, and seems a critique of America that didn't help star John Garfield's political problems. 1976's Islands in the Stream is a soggy ode to Hemingway with George C Scott. The useless rummy character in that one is played by David Hemmings, who proves his mettle by saving Scott's kids -- shooting a killer shark with a Browning B.A.R. rifle. It not only explains Scott's loyalty to the drunkard, but provides a nice coda to the Jaws phenomenon: take that, Bruce.


On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, To Have and Have Not rates:
Movie: Excellent
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: Theatrical trailer, featurette A Love Story: The Story of To Have and To Have Not, cartoon Bacall to Arms, Lux Radio Theatre production starring Humphrey Bogart & Lauren Bacall
Packaging: Snapper case
Reviewed: November 3, 2003


Footnotes

1. Help from the Web, 11 05 03:

Know who dubbed Betty Perske's singing voice? A 13 year old Andy Williams. -- Dick Dinman
Return

A contradiction from the web, 11 08 03:

Pauline Kael was among the first to spread the myth that it's young Andy Williams dubbing for Lauren Bacall, and though Kael was made aware of the error, she never corrected it in later editions of 5001 Nights at the Movies. Those who still insist it's Andy Williams singing will not appreciate Todd McCarthy's thoroughly researched biography of Howard Hawks (page 377 of 756!):

"To find a singer who would match up plausibly with Bacall's husky tones was not easy, and quite a few were tried, including the deep-voiced black singer Lillian Randolph, Dolores Hope, and the teenaged Andy Williams. Williams finally prevailed, and it was his voice that emanated from the playback machine on May 1 [1944] when Hawks at last came to filming "How Little We Know." As was customary, Bacall sang along while Carmichael tinkered away on the silent keyboard, and as she did, Hawks liked what he heard and told her to keep going. When she was done, he decided to record her again singing the song, so, despite the legend that has come down over the years that Andy Williams's voice was dubbed over Bacall's (a legend so generally accepted that it became a correct answer on Jeopardy), the truth is that Bacall sang her own numbers in To Have and Have Not."

Williams was not thirteen at the time he recorded for Hawks. He was born in December, 1927. - Bill Blackwell




DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2007 Glenn Erickson

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © DVDTalk.com All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

Release List Reviews Price Search Shop SUBSCRIBE Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise