Release List Reviews Price Search Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise
DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk TV
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns



DVD SAVANT

Miss Julie


Miss Julie
Criterion 416
1951 / B&W / 1:33 flat full frame / 90 min. / Fröken Julie / Street Date January 22, 2008 / 39.95
Starring Anita Björk, Ulf Palme, Märta Dorff, Lissi Alandh, Anders Henrikson, Inga Gill, Kurt-Olof Sundström, Max von Sydow
Cinematography Göran Strindberg
Art Direction Bibi Lindström
Film Editor Lennart Wallén
Original Music Dag Wirén
Written by Alf Sjöberg from the play by August Strindberg
Produced by Rune Waldekranz
Directed by Alf Sjöberg

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

The 1951 Miss Julie will be an eye-opener for film fans that think Swedish cinema began and ended with Ingmar Bergman. Director Alf Sjöberg reworks August Strindberg's stage play in cinematic terms. Nature becomes a major character in a midsummer gala under the midnight sun, and dark stories from the past come to vivid life in stylized flashback sequences. This superb play adaptation won the grand prize at Cannes, sharing the honor with De Sica's Miracle in Milan.

Synopsis:

Count Carl (Anders Henrikson) doesn't attend the all-night servant's party held on his estate because he's busy trying to patch up the broken engagement of his willful, capricious daughter, Miss Julie (Anita Björk) to a wealthy neighbor (Kurt-Olof Sundström). Julie makes a spectacle of herself at the servant's party, flirting dangerously with head butler Jean (Ulf Palme). Jean is more or less engaged to Kristen, the cook (Märta Dorff), who goes to sleep unaware that Jean and Julie are spending the night together. The lovers tell each other of their backgrounds. Jean's dream is to break free of his servitude and take Miss Julie for his own. Julie spent a strange childhood under an unbalanced, rebellious mother, who refused to marry the Count and tried to raise Julie as a boy. As the dawn approaches Jean convinces Julie to steal money from her father and run away with him.

The 1888 play Miss Julie has become one of the world's most performed and respected stage works. Banned in Sweden for almost twenty years, the tale of class conflict and sexual abandon had been filmed numerous times from the silent era onward. Alf Sjöberg's 1951 version is considered the most successful adaptation to date.

The stage original of Miss Julie takes place entirely in one set, the kitchen of a manor house. Alf Sjöberg allows his characters to roam the grounds of the estate while he interprets the play in cinematic terms. The film begins with farm workers raising a Maypole in celebration; Miss Julie is introduced dancing with her servants, who gossip about her scandalous behavior. Much of the drama still takes place in the manor kitchen but Julie and the brooding Jean now wander through the property while reminiscing about their childhood experiences. The sensual twilight of the Swedish summer night takes on an active role, encouraging the lovers to forget their social positions and break the rules of propriety.

Alf Sjöberg's expressive visual ideas enlarge the play in other ways as well. To avoid the accusing eyes of the partygoers, Julie and Jean row down a misty stream, escaping into an illusion of freedom. Sjöberg renders Jean and Julie's contrasting dreams via special effects similar to those in Henry Hathaway's surrealist Peter Ibbetson (1934. As Julie speaks of her dreams of degradation, we see her plunging downward in free fall. When Jean's dream alludes to his desire for Julie, a corresponding ghostly visual pictures him climbing high into a tree for forbidden fruit.

The lead actors make strong, sympathetic impressions as characters warped by a rigid class system. Ulf Palme's Jean is a potential ladies' man frustrated by his subservient position; he has promised himself to the plain but practical cook Kristen yet cannot resist his irrational urge to run away with a woman above his station. The strikingly beautiful Anita Björk breathes life into the brazenly self-destructive Miss Julie. Sjöberg uses flashbacks to illuminate Julie's recent past. She alienates her fiancé by whipping him with a riding crop, as if he were one of her dogs.

The flashbacks to Julie and Jean's deeper past are even more stylized. For some transitions the camera pans from the present to the past in one unbroken take, indicating a psychological causality at work. Jean has humiliating childhood memories of being punished for daring to enter the manor house. The flashbacks delineating Julie's family history have the dreamlike quality of a horror tale. The indulgent Count loses his friends when his independent-minded paramour Berta (Lissi Alandh) refuses to submit to a formal marriage. Berta gives birth to a daughter, laughing because the Count has been denied a son; she mocks her husband by raising Julie in boy's clothing. The unfaithful woman eventually attempts to burn down the manor house, with Julie in it. The image of Countess Berta laughing amid the flames isn't much different from a Barbara Steele Eurohorror classic, or one of Roger Corman's Edgar Allan Poe films.

With this background it's no wonder that Julie is confused and rebellious. She steals her father's money but cannot carry out Jean's hopeless escape plan. As the dawn approaches Julie's world has become a chaos, that Sjöberg expresses in visual terms. Miss Julie is an emotional workout and an elegant cinematic experience.

Director Sjöberg's fame was eventually eclipsed by that of the younger Ingmar Bergman; at this point in time the directors were sharing some of the same personnel. To play the newly-written minor character of a drunken groom, Sjöberg used young actor Max von Sydow, in only his second film. The groom repeatedly pops up to discover Miss Julie and Jean in compromising situations.


Criterion presents Miss Julie in beautifully restored condition. The B&W transfer shows only a couple of instances of momentary instability. Once again, Criterion's extras provide an extended understanding of a worthy classic. In place of a commentary, film historian Peter Cowie narrates an insightful and well-organized extended video essay. An older TV interview records director Sjöberg discussing his work.

Even more impressive is a feature-length 2006 Swedish television documentary on the controversial playwright August Strindberg and the history of Miss Julie on stage and film. The play and Strindberg are analyzed at length, with at least one outspoken critic rejecting Strindberg's psychological approach as a male writer's sexist fantasy. A new stage presentation is observed from rehearsals to opening night. Its 'new' Julie is greeted backstage by Anita Björk and Bibi Andersson, who performed the play on television. All three 'Julies' talk about the role in interview footage.

An original American trailer contains no Swedish dialogue, concentrating instead on cameraman Göran Strindberg's beautiful images. Peter Matthews and Birgitta Steene contribute essays to an insert booklet. Criterion's disc producer is Debra McClutchy.


On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, Miss Julie rates:
Movie: Excellent
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: Video Essay by Peter Cowie, trailer, interview with director Sjöberg, 2006 Swedish TV production on the play and August Strindberg.
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: January 23, 2008

Republished by permission of Turner Classic Movies.



DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2008 Glenn Erickson

Go BACK to the Savant Main Page.
Reviews on the Savant main site have additional credits information and are more likely to be updated and annotated with reader input and graphics.

Return to Top of Page

Release List Reviews Price Search Shop SUBSCRIBE Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise