DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns



DVD SAVANT

Spartacus
50th Anniversary Edition
Savant Blu-ray Review


Spartacus
Blu-ray
Universal
1960 / Color / 2.35 widescreen / Street Date May 25, 2010 / 26.98
Starring
Kirk Douglas, Laurence Olivier, Charles Laughton, Jean Simmons, Peter Ustinov, Tony Curtis, John Gavin, Nina Foch, Herbert Lom, Charles McGraw, John Ireland, Nick Dennis.
Music by
Alex North
Edited by Robert Lawrence
Produced by Kirk Douglas and Edward Lewis
Based on the novel by Howard Fast
Directed by Stanley Kubrick

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

I've reviewed videodiscs of Spartacus twice now. In 2000 I covered the flat-letterboxed Universal Disc with a review essay on the behind-the-scenes struggle of the making of the movie between the studio, producer-star Kirk Douglas and the outspoken but blacklist-closeted writer Dalton Trumbo. I recommend that essay -- it's one of the better Savant pieces from the early years of this site. I also reviewed the 2001 Criterion Disc, mostly covering that release's exhaustive extras. So I now feel liberated to expound freely for this review of Universal's new Spartacus Blu-ray. I'll indulge some brief rambling about the film's reputation twenty years after its impressive 1991 65mm restoration, followed by a quick look at its image quality and impact in Blu-ray.

Yep, fifty years have passed since this one came out. I never saw it new and first learned about in a Dell comic book, which I read in a neighbor kid's tree house. I think my first miserable experience seeing the film was on TV, shown over two afternoons and chopped into innumerable nine-minute pieces. By the time I caught up with a revival theater print in the late 1970s, I was surprised to see how battered a movie could look: scratches, lots of splices and big gaps in the story. The audience reacted like viewers at a prizefight, going "Oh!" each time another chunk of movie went missing. It was a Technicolor print, or at least what remained of one. No doubt Robert A. Harris had an uphill battle restoring this one.

The 1991 65mm restoration qualified as a major family outing. I built the experience up for my kids, then aged twelve down to six. Spartacus looked fantastic. It's obvious that waiting only a few years would have made such a restoration much more difficult, if not impossible.  1

Considered by some a political football when it was new, the movie shows 'liberal' Hollywood at its peak. Producer-star Kirk Douglas had won critical success with Paths of Glory, an anti-war movie that Came Right Out with the news that WW1 was an inhumane activity led by degenerates. Of course, Douglas chose the rather safe target of the French Army -- nobody ever faced a charge of anti-Americanism by slamming anything French. Paths of Glory was great moviemaking by the creative, resourceful intellectual Stanley Kubrick, but it of course reserves a huge show-off role for its producer-star. War may be futile but it's a hell of an opportunity for grandstanding oratory. Could the Red-baiting patriot Adolph Menjou have known he was being set up as a villain beyond the context of the movie?

Douglas starred in Richard Fleischer's lavish The Vikings, an intelligent costume epic that was seemingly restrained from aspiring to greater things. That film's producer Jerry Bresler would later try to "simplify" a film by a less cooperative director, Sam Peckinpah, with disastrous results. Actor Douglas realized that to stay at the top of his industry he needed to make and control an enormous epic. He courted quality and controversy, hiring a legendary cast of English stars and setting up blacklisted writer Dalton Trumbo to secretly adapt Howard Fast's ardently leftist novel. Kirk Douglas hired the esteemed director Anthony Mann, only to run into creative differences early in the shooting -- both men clearly intended Spartacus to be a personal film. After Mann's departure Douglas turned the directing reins over to Stanley Kubrick, who used the massive epic as his steppingstone from low-budget United Artists work to the pinnacle of the profession. Kubrick kept his producer-star patron happy and concentrated on being the best ever director for hire. Naturally, the script invents plenty of dynamite scenes for Kirk: Spartacus revels in his new-found freedom, rallies his unwashed masses to defy the might of Rome, and finishes up with speeches basically saying, "Hey, I guess we tried, and if we should, heh heh, all get massacred by the Romans, well, someday somebody will make a great movie about us".

Aside from a moment or two of screeching ("All we wanna do is get OUT of this damn country!") this is Kirk Douglas's most iconic role. Now in his nineties, the actor has his physical infirmities but still impresses as a focused survivor, and is definitely not hiding away from the public. He must be intensely proud to see his youthful beauty (yep) preserved in Spartacus. He's in his prime here, past his rather pulpy years as a stage softie and before a decline spent sending up his own image. Spartacus is a lean 'n' mean physical specimen, an endorsement for the starvation and abuse of the slave lifestyle. The Thracian slave is Abraham Lincoln and Audie Murphy rolled into one, but also an intensely likeable guy adored by his men and loved by the incredibly attractive Jean Simmons.

Douglas was also no slouch in the producing department. Competing with fellow independent Otto Preminger in pushing the outside of the censorship envelope, Douglas slips in as much adult content and near-nudity as he dares. Roman femmes Nina Foch and Joanna Barnes snicker as they choose gladiators on the basis of which ones sexually excite them. Scenes of undisguised homosexual content (restored) and battle gore (one arm amputation restored for fun) originally got no further than a preview screening or two. But there's still the spectacle of Varinia (Jean Simmons) bobbing in a pond, the kind of "did you see that?" brinksmanship not attempted since the Pre-code days of Claudette Colbert in Sign of the Cross.

Stanley Kubrick's detractors are quick to mention that, when it came time for the production to figure out whom to officially list for the film's script, Kubrick volunteered to accept that credit! As it turned out Kirk Douglas somehow convinced Universal to let Dalton Trumbo, who had not had his name on a Hollywood picture in years, take the writing credit.  2 In fairness, Spartacus crackles with Stanley Kubrick's unsentimental touches. The power politics in Rome are presented with an objectivity that brings all the venality, stupidity and arrogance to the surface. Gracchus is an amused hedonist and Crassus a power-mad control freak. Most of the relationships have a component of sexual tyranny, emphasized in Kubrick's direction. The film's most lovable character is Peter Ustinov's Lentulus Batiatus, a self-avowed opportunist and coward. Kubrick creates little family units out of various groups of freed slaves in Spartacus' army, and then coldly shows them wiped out when the Roman Empire strikes back.

Who knows if these particular touches are Kubrick's? They display his flair for appalling clarity. The final conflict is a fairly standard violent melee, but the long preamble that leads up to it is a unique spectacle. The Romans are an organized machine designed to systematically mow down opposing foot soldiers. The camera lingers on Crassus' vast legions arranging themselves on the field of battle. The maneuvers make the battlefield look like a chessboard, and Kubrick was a chess enthusiast. Spartacus's horde of well-intentioned fighters hasn't a chance fighting this juggernaut on its own terms. The director's unflinching views of the coordinated Roman troops show us that the rebels' battle is well lost even before it is begun.

The film's unforgettable conclusion also seems to benefit from Stanley Kubrick's unsentimental graphic clarity. Spartacus is crucified on the Appian Way with hundreds of his comrades taken prisoner in the last battle. Given a last look at her dying husband, Varinia delivers a typically defiant Trumbo-eque speech: instead of mourning her doomed man, she proudly holds her baby aloft and swears to keep Spartacus's ideals alive. The scene has everything -- the appalling barbarity of the Romans and the love of a righteous woman for her fallen mate. Kubrick's twin rows of crucified men reaching to the vanishing point resembles one of his later symmetrical compositions. It's an undeniably powerful finish to a movie that defies many of the censor pitfalls and political compromises of its time.  3


Universal's Blu-ray of Spartacus has been dealt an early thumbs-down vote by restorer Robert A. Harris, who has written that he finds the HD transfer deficient. Harris claims that it's soft, that over-used digital tools have blown away significant detail. He mentions 'halo'-ing around objects.

I looked at Spartacus, and this is how I felt about what I saw. The only scenes that looked noticeably off to me were the underground shots in the gladiator school, which seemed too bright. Everything else looked sharp and detailed, maybe not at as sharp as the eye-popping UK disc of Zulu but far sharper than a normal DVD. On my 67" Samsung rear-projection DLP LED (I think I got that description right) I noticed no halo-ing as described by Mr. Harris. Perhaps I'll be told that I'm not looking at the BD on an approved monitor?

My intention is not to contradict anyone but just to report my personal experience. I'm not defending Universal in any way, as they are actually on my gripe list this month for their extras-challenged DVD insult to the movie Matinee. But the general buzz on the web at this particular moment is that the Universal Spartacus Blu-ray is no good. I don't agree, and I recommend this release.  4

For exhaustive, informative, educational extras on this title, the 2001 Criterion Disc is the way to go. This new Blu-ray carries over some of the extras from that edition that were presumably sourced from Universal elements: publicity interviews with Peter Ustinov and Jean Simmons, some behind-the-scenes footage (in excellent condition) of Kirk Douglas and Woody Strode (and director #1 Anthony Mann) prepping in the gladiator school, several newsreels and galleries of design art and production stills etc. A deleted scenes extra offers the 1967 truncated alternate ending mentioned in  footnote # 3, along with a censored UK version of Varinia's conjugal visit to Spartacus's slave cell, and an audio tag for the end of Charles Laughton's final scene.


On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, Spartacus Blu-ray rates:
Movie: Excellent
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: deleted scenes, interview selects, gladiator school BTS footage, newsreels, image galleries.
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: May 15, 2010

Footnotes:

1. This is a wholly personal footnote. I remember seeing Spartacus in 1991 as if it happened yesterday. I prepped my kids with a lot of talk about the Blacklist and the Romans and how a great civilization can also be unjust. It also enabled me to talk about the evil of slavery. I remember being a bit depressed on the way home because none of the kids were leaping up to discuss the movie -- I thought maybe they didn't like it. It just so happened that that particular Sunday Los Angeles held an Iraq War 1 "victory rally" on Hollywood Boulevard, complete with low-level fly-bys of vintage aircraft and new jets to celebrate. The TV had plenty of footage of soldiers riding tanks and acting like drunken seniors who just won the big football game -- "We're badass mothers!", that kind of thing. So that was a downer, too.

As it turned out, my kids were deeply impressed by the movie. My 12 year-old daughter took a phone call in the kitchen that evening and I got to listen to her side of a conversation with a girl friend. She stated that the movie was awesome, especially the endless line of crucified rebels at the conclusion. So the movie had made a dent after all. I know this footnote may be an inappropriate autobiographical tangent to a Spartacus review, but I think how we make use of movies is important.
Return

2. It's also possible that Universal, in the process of being bought by MCA, just didn't have the power to tell the producer what to do, and Douglas used that opening to finish the movie his way and officially break the blacklist by crediting Trumbo.
Return

3. An alternate ending prepared for a 1967 reissue (included in this disc's extras) looks like a TV cut-down version. The scene has been trimmed uncomfortably short. Varinia hugs Spartacus' sandal and holds his son up but only says one or two lines. Shots of the rows of crucified men are shortened, although a new angle appears when the cart rolls away. Even more impressive is the deletion of all close-ups of Kirk Douglas on the cross. The dropping of those shots may have been to satisfy Network standards of good taste -- Spartacus looks like a pre-Christ, Christ figure. The chopped-up scene makes us shudder, as it represents what Universal and the censors could have done to the original theatrical cut of Spartacus, had the studio's power in 1960 not been so weakened. This last thought is unsubstantiated conjecture.

But the scene without the cuts of Douglas is fascinating ... it looks as if the original might have played better without them. Varinia talks upwards to Spartacus out of frame and we don't know if he's alive or dead -- as her words are an oath, she could very well be delivering them to a corpse. We all know that producer-star Kirk Douglas would never rob himself of a prominent presence in the final scene ... doing so would be Oscar-nomination suicide. Kubrick stated that he was never personally enamored of the project for its own sake, but we have to think that if he had the final say, Spartacus might very well end without showing its hero's face on the cross.

I'm pretty sure that the beat-up print I saw in a theater in 1977 was this version -- I recall not seeing any shots of Douglas.
Return

4. When an authority like Mr. Harris speaks, I listen: he knows his business. And the last thing I need is another web 'controversy' about a video transfer crime. I reported on Disney's color redesign on a DVD of Peter Pan. The hysterical emails I got from self-appointed Disney fan police convinced me to stay clear of catfights that surround DVD and Blu-ray quality arguments. You know it's not worth arguing with someone ranting that Touch of Evil is supposed to be 1.37:1 full frame, when every reference guide and a cursory look at the film itself proves that its correct ratio is 1.85:1. All I can do is call 'em as I see them.

For the record, I really enjoy DVD Beaver's analyses of various releases. It's not what I do. Reviewing transfer quality only makes sense to me in broad strokes -- will I feel cheated by a particular Blu-ray? Is it an unqualified disaster? Is it worse than a DVD we already have?
Return

Reader responses:

May 17, 2010

Having read your review I will now buy the Blu-ray of Spartacus. I was waffling because of negative comments about the picture quality. You've covered all the really good points about the film... the only negatives for me are that it drags somewhat in the middle with long scenes of marching hither and yon and doesn't really pick up again until the last quarter. Also, the amazing shots of the legions getting into formation is let down by the fact that we never see those masses engaged in battle once the flaming logs are rolled down the hill. Everything from that point seems to have been filmed on Universal's backlot with a handful of extras. It's always been a letdown for me because the buildup preps you for the greatest battle in film history. Also I suspect Yakima Cannutt may have had some input on the pre-battle formations. I've always thought he would have made a good military strategist... you can see it in all his big action set pieces, and an action director Kubrick was not. Have a great week -- John Maxwell Taylor


May 19, 2010

Hi Glenn, I saw Spartacus in 70mm a number of times at the McVickers theatre in Chicago when it first opened. The bits with the chopped off hand and the spurt of blood on Laurence Olivier's face when he stabs Woody Strode weren't cut until a few weeks into its run. There was one other change, the last time I saw the movie in 70mm, the break for the intermission had been moved to a different spot - why I don't know.

My Blu-ray hasn't arrived yet, with any luck it won't be a total disappointment. Maybe Universal should use the facilities over at Warner Brothers next time they decide to do a Blu-ray release of a major classic. They did a beautiful job of restoring The African Queen for Paramount. And because they're professionals who love movies and respect the intent of the original filmmakers - the cleaned up version still looks like a movie. - Jon Lidolt

May 18, 2010

Dear Mr. Erickson, now that Spartacus is coming out on Blu-ray, you and your readers may be interested in the current state of scholarship on the film's production history (cuts, censorship, etc.) as detailed in the first chapter of Spartacus: Film and History, a book on which I served as editor and contributor. Chapter 1 is by Duncan Cooper, whose work on Spartacus has for many years been the only detailed source on the film's genesis that has been available (in articles published in the journal Cineaste). For the book chapter he has thoroughly expanded, revised, and updated his previous investigations, which this chapter now supersedes. The chapter also includes a proposal for a kind of restored director's cut (as far as such is still possible) with a few brief but crucial moments added, a version that goes beyond the current restoration as done by Robert Harris.

Information about the book may be found at this link, and, with a Table of Contents, at this link; or at this page. Sincerely, Martin Winkler



DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2010 Glenn Erickson

See more exclusive reviews on the Savant Main Page.
Reviews on the Savant main site have additional credits information and are often updated and annotated with reader input and graphics.
Also, don't forget the 2010 Savant Wish List.
T'was Ever Thus.

Return to Top of Page

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © DVDTalk.com All rights reserved | Privacy Policy

Subscribe to DVDTalk's Newsletters

Email Address

DVD Talk Newsletter (Sample)
DVD Savant Newsletter (Sample)

Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise