DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
HD DVD/Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns



DVD SAVANT

Many Wars Ago
(Uomini Contro)
Savant Blu-ray Review


Many Wars Ago
Blu-ray
Rarovideo /Kino Lorber
1970 / Color / 1:33 open matte full frame (should be widescreen) / 101 min. / Uomini Contro / Street Date January 7, 2014 / 34.95
Starring Mark Frechette, Alain Cuny, Gian Maria Volonté, Giampiero Albertini, Pier Paolo Capponi, Franco Graziosi, Mario Feliciani, Alberto Mastino.
Cinematography
Pasqualino De Santis
Film Editor Ruggero Mastroianni
Original Music Piero Piccioni
Written by Tonino Guerra, Raffaele La Capria, Francesco Rosi from a novel by Emilio Lussu
Produced by Marina Cicogna, Luciano Perugia, Francesco Rosi
Directed by Francesco Rosi

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson



Anybody remember Mark Frechette, the non-actor star of Michelangelo Antonioni's Zabriskie Point, who gave his salary to a commune, robbed a bank and then died in prison? Well, Frechette's association with Antonioni won him a couple more Italian movie roles. 1970's Many Wars Ago (Uomini Contro) had its Rome premiere just a few months after Zabriskie but never got an American release. It's a grim WW1 drama about an army mutiny that bears comparison with Stanley Kubrick's Paths of Glory. Controversial director Francesco Rosi (Salvatore Giuliano, Hands Over the City) can't match Kubrick for cinematic genius, but his story is adapted from Un anno sull'altipiano by Emilio Lussu, a noted anti-Fascist writer with firsthand experience in the trenches of WW1. The insanity of war on the front lines is beautifully expressed in Rosi's film, which also features another fine performance from the politically-minded actor Gian Maria Volonté.

Hill territory in Yugoslavia stands in for the Asiago Plateau, as Italians face off against Austrians in 1916. Other officers can't believe that the young Lt. Sassu (Mark Frechette) asks for combat duty, as the trench warfare exacts a murderous toll on officers and soldiers alike. Sassu soon discovers that his division commander General Leone (Alain Cuny of La dolce vita) is an incompetent who squanders the lives of his troops on outdated, foolish strategies. Leone lectures Sassu on military decorum and privilege. He takes advantage of any and all opportunities to execute his own men, to enforce his twisted ideas of morale. The charismatic Lt. Ottolenghi (Gian Maria Volonté) must be sneaky to disobey insane orders, as when Leone orders a man shot for shouting the wrong thing in combat. Leone insists on ordering hundreds of men to charge enemy machine guns in broad daylight; the spectacle is so awful that the Austrians stop shooting and beg the Italians to return to their trenches. In response, Leone orders his own gunners to fire on the men from behind. The murderous, maniacal actions of Leone and his Major Malchiodi (Franco Graziosi) lead to a disorganized mutiny, which has disastrous consequences.

Director Rosi, actor Volonté and writer Tonino Guerra made Uomini contro ("Men Against") as a leftist statement. The story's real fight is not between countries but between classes. The ruling nobles and elites expend most of their effort punishing the poor Southern Italians that make up the bulk of their fighting force. The socialist Ottolenghi is a man of the people who understands that the (often illiterate) regulars have no idea what they're fighting for, and know only that their lives mean nothing to their superior officers. As for General Leone, he behaves as if feudal privilege and brutality were still the norm in the 20th century. Lt. Sassu is from the same social stratum as his commander, and feels compelled to obey commands no matter how insane they become. When he loses his equilibrium and commits a sensible act of murder under fire, Sassu is the first to condemn his actions.

Director Rosi conveys the atmosphere of the battlefield in this hilly, often foggy terrain where the men are always cold. His shots and compositions are never lazy, but the movie is not particularly distinguished along these lines; a zoom lens gets plenty of use. Some of the battle scenes, particularly a night assault, are quite striking. The film presents appallingly inhuman scenes of injustice and cruelty, which sometimes seem as absurd as something from Catch-22. In one grotesque episode Leone sends a squad of men out wearing pathetic 'experimental' armor. They look like robots from a Republic serial. Not only are their legs and arms exposed, but any metal capable of repelling machine gun bullets would be far too heavy: the poor men are massacred like guinea pigs in tinfoil. Leone reacts to the slaughter as if it were an annoying inconvenience.

Many Wars Ago is both more courageous and morally honest than Kubrick's Paths of Glory, which frequently devolves into an acting showcase for the grandstanding Kirk Douglas. Douglas's Colonel Dax floats heroically above the hypocrisy around him, and is given the luxury of screaming his outrage at the faces of his villainous superiors: "I think you are a degenerate!" Francesco Rosi's film critiques the militarism of his own country, a stance that did not amuse conservative audiences. Douglas's film is an American production filmed in Germany that slams the French Army, as if that country had a corner in heinous military practices. Had Douglas and Kubrick filmed a book smearing the reputation of the U.S. Expeditionary Forces, right-wingers would have run them out of Hollywood.

Mark Frechette is presumably dubbed in Italian but communicates well his character's misplaced idealism. Alain Cuny epitomizes the loony, contemptuous man of authority who thinks that human lives are his to squander at will. Fresh from his triumph in Elio Petri's Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion, Gian Maria Volont&e; gives a refreshingly understated performance as the one officer who is truly the soldier's friend. In a brief bit as a nurse tending to Lt. Sussu we find none other than Daria Nicolodi, in what the IMDB lists as her first film appearance.


Kino Lorber and Rarovideo's Blu-ray of Many Wars Ago is a handsome transfer of this obscure color feature, with excellent audio (in Italian with removable subtitles). Although clearly intended for widescreen matting, at at least 1.66:1, the transfer is full frame. This choice leaves dead space above and below the relevant action, and compromises the compositions of the famous Pasqualino De Santis, the cameraman responsible for Rosi's The Moment of Truth, Visconti's Death in Venice and Zeffirelli's Romeo and Juliet. Francesco Rosi approved the transfer so may have preferred the non-theatrical aspect ratio.

The melancholy music score is by Piero Piccioni. The dubbing for Mark Frechette is remarkably good.

Francesco Rosi appears in a relaxed half-hour interview, and a before & after restoration comparison is offered. An illustrated twenty-page booklet contains liner notes by Lorenzo Codelli, writings by director Rosi and a number of critical responses to the film, among them Tullio Kezich, Alberto Moravia, Michel Ciment, Gene Moskowitz, Gary Crowdus, Piero Piccioni, Tonino Guerra and Gian Maria Volonté.

A cover blurb tells us that the restoration is a "New HD Transfer from Original 35mm Negative Print." Unless film terminology has changed, the line would seem to be self-contradictory.


On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, Many Wars Ago Blu-ray rates:
Movie: Very Good
Video: Acceptable; would be Excellent if its aspect ratio were correct.
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: Interview with Francesco Rosi, restoration demo, insert booklet with essays and critical reactions.
Deaf and Hearing-impaired Friendly? YES; Subtitles: English
Packaging: Keep case in card sleeve
Reviewed: January 5, 2014




DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2014 Glenn Erickson

See more exclusive reviews on the Savant Main Page.
The version of this review on the Savant main site has additional images, footnotes and credits information, and may be updated and annotated with reader input and graphics.

Return to Top of Page

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © DVDTalk.com All rights reserved | Privacy Policy

Subscribe to DVDTalk's Newsletters

Email Address

DVD Talk Newsletter (Sample)
DVD Savant Newsletter (Sample)

Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise