Release List Reviews Price Search Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise
DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk TV
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns



DVD SAVANT

Black and White in Color
and
THE SKY ABOVE, THE MUD BELOW


Black and White in Color
Home Vision Entertainment
1976 / color / 1:78 anamorphic 16:9 / 90 min. / Noirs et blancs en couleur / Street Date June 24, 2003 / 29.95
Starring Jean Carmet, Jean Dufilho, Catherine Rouvel, Jacques Spiesser, Maurice Barrier, Benjamin Memel Atchory, Peter Berling, Marius Beugre Boignan, Claude Legros, Dora Doll
Cinematography Claude Agostini
Production Designer
Set decoration Max Douy
Film Editor Francoise Bonnot
Original Music Pierre Bachelet
Written by Jean-Jacques Annaud and Georges Conchon
Produced by Arthur Cohn, Jacques Perrin, Giorgio Silagni
Directed by Jean-Jacques Annaud

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

Jean-Jacques Annaud's first feature is a delightfully warped black comedy about colonial hijinks in French Equatorial Africa, circa 1915. It not only deflates all the usual clichés about whites lording it over the 'natives', but deftly creates a universal critique of all things colonial: arrogance, racism, folly.

It's actually shot and staged very straight; the events are an amalgam of separate similar incidents that happened all over Africa when World War One broke out. It isn't The African Queen, that's for sure.

Synopsis:

1915. The half-dozen white, French inhabitants of a provincial village in a French African colony are shocked to read that they've already been at war for months. The priests and merchants are immediately inspired to gather a motley group of natives, march the few miles across the border to the German outpost, and wipe it out. The only military representative, Sergeant Bosselet (Jean Carmet) reluctantly agrees to lead the party, and when a young botanist objects to the preemptive strike, he's dismissed and ostracized.
The Germans are actually prepared, and the Frenchmen's picnic war turns out to be a slaughter. Running back in disarray, the French cower and hope the Germans will be kind when they retaliate. But the supposedly timid botanist steps in, takes control, and organizes a defense by entreating the local tribal chief into kidnapping soldiers from other tribes to replace the natives that have been left to die on the field. Assuming a superior social position, the botanist now high-hands his compatriots, takes a native concubine and prepares for all-out war.

The tone is hilariously set (in what sounds like a grim tale) when we see a group of natives transporting the lazy whites in homemade Palanquins. The natives sing one of those hearty native work-songs as they carry their 'superiors', but the subtitles translate exactly what they're singing: "The fool we carry is fat as a pig", "But our guy's feet smell like dung".

The colonials are mostly obnoxious clods who would be ignored back in France. They consider the civilized, agreeable and tolerant natives to be animals, redubbing them with good French names at will. The corrupt priests teach them condescending lessons, saying that no black can be as good as a white, but can better himself by imitating the white man. Then they get a half-dozen natives killed, and wonder why no more volunteer for service.

The equally crooked merchants start hoarding food as soon as they're threatened, and bully the poor sergeant into demeaning, foolish actions. They're the ones who demand that the Germans be expunged, not an hour after greeting them at their store as friends. As for the young, cleanliness-obsessed botanist, he seems like a good pacifist alternative, until he smells power. Organizing more doom for more natives (who do all the suffering in the picture), he sets up trench warfare outside the German fortress.

It's hard to describe the peculiarly funny tone of the show. The actors are all compelling, but there is certainly no single hero. The village is more of a microcosm of French folly, or perhaps Colonial folly in general. The Germans are more organized, and at least willing to fight with their native troops. And the English we see (a regiment of natives led by a jolly-good Indian Gurkha) are even more ruthlessly set on grabbing new territory for their Queen.

Annaud and his co-writer Georges Conchon respect their characters, even the French, too sufficiently to call Black and White in Color a simple lampoon. Everything is amusing, if only because the selfish, jingoistic and cowardly attitudes of the bourgeoisie abroad seem such a universal statement. Less lavish than Annaud's later films (The Bear, The Lover, Quest for Fire). Black and White in Color is a bawdy comedy of colonial manners with an acidic touch.


Home Vision Entertainment's DVD of Black and White in Color is a stunningly handsome 16:9 transfer of a prime element in fine condition. The audio is clear and the subtitles easy to read and well-timed to make the frequent jokes work without getting in the way.

The film is accompanied by two interviews from the director and producer Arthur Cohn explaining how the crazy film came to be (Annaud became fascinated by these mini-wars that paralleled the Great War being fought back home). It was apparently considered an unreleaseable fiasco until a second editor was brought in for a recut (hope they're being fair to the first editor). Annaud's interview is done right in the middle of an African village where he's shooting something unidentified. An essay by Ronald Falzone adds an third perspective to the makers' opinions.

Black and White in Color is certainly long enough to stand alone on the disc, but HVe has included as a separate extra, an entire additional feature (88 minutes), 1961's The Sky Above, the Mud Below. It won an Oscar that year for best documentary and is an account of a trek into central New Guinea to seek out primitive headhunters. They find them, and record reels of primitive rituals, but don't have much meaningful communication. It's in color and stresses the dangers and risks taken by the explorers, even though they rely on natives to do most of the hard work, and radio for supplies and assistance at every turn. The sales pitch originally had an almost 'Mondo' appeal - it reportedly cleaned up in theaters, as explained by producer Arthur Cohn.

The quality on the second feature is quite good. It is the Embassy pictures English-language version, which is perhaps why it isn't being given a disc of its own, but the only dialogue is the voiceover. Not bad for a 'throwaway' extra.


On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, Black and White in Color rates:
Movie: Excellent
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: Extra feature film: The Sky Above, the Mud Below; interview with director and producer, separate producer conversation, filmographies, essay by film historian Ronald Falzone
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: June 17, 2003





DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2007 Glenn Erickson

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © DVDTalk.com All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

Release List Reviews Price Search Shop SUBSCRIBE Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise