Reviewed by Glenn Erickson
Duel in the Sun is being reviewed here for the quality of its presentation; it's been out twice
before from Anchor Bay. In content, MGM's disc is the same as AB's second release entitled
Duel in the Sun Roadshow Edition
from 2000. It has the same double overture that extends the running time by a full ten minutes,
including the clumsy narration opening that apologizes for the character of the Sin Killer played
by Walter Huston.
Duel in the Sun is as nutty a picture that ever came out of Hollywood, and I still get into
the delirious romanticism of its Tiomkin music, the gloriously overplayed sex scenes and King
Vidor's powerful imagery (abetted by a posse of fill-in directors whenever crazy producer David
O. Selznick wanted to flex his authority). For a full run-down on the wildly uneven show, see the
earlier Duel in the Sun Roadshow
MGM's disc is a mixed blessing. Perhaps due to improved encoding and production methods, the picture
looks better than ever, with colors perhaps a bit more stable. No complaint there at all, for this
DVD shows off the picture's extremes of Technicolor almost as well as a theatrical print and far
better than compressed cable transmission.
The nagging problem is the audio, which I am going to guess has been given a big dose of compression
processing to minimize hiss. Well, they went too far because the track is now too "crunchy",
with loud noises slightly distorted and all detail lost out of quieter passages. The dynamic music
is badly effected as well, as if it were out of phase and with some frequencies cancelled out. The
same track malady is present on MGM's visually beautiful
Thief of Bagdad disc.
I played the disc on two TVs from two different DVD players. On the small monitor it was less
noticeable but even there the track was "thick" - I had to turn it up too loud to hear it, and then
it distorted. On the large Mitsubishi with surround the effect was even worse. I often play my old
disc with the picture off just to enjoy the Tiomkin soundtrack in the background (the overture is
quite a workout) and I'll just have to continue using the older disc.
The disc contains a trailer as an extra. The release was licensed from Buena Vista (no explanation
given for that arrangement) in a package of discs released in
a group. As with the others, MGM simply received the masters and proceeded to mastering. So
where along the line the audio problem occurred is hard to say. If someone out there gets a disc
that sounds good (can you hear Orson Welles' opening narration clearly?), let me know right away
so I can happily retract the above and say I simply have a bum screener.
On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor,
Duel in the Sun rates:
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: May 26, 2004
DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2004 Glenn Erickson
Go BACK to the Savant Main Page.