DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » Star Trek: The Original Series - The Complete Third Season
Star Trek: The Original Series - The Complete Third Season
Paramount // Unrated // December 14, 2004
List Price: $129.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Holly E. Ordway | posted December 9, 2004 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly
The movie

The original Star Trek was ahead of its time. That was a great thing for television science fiction in general, as it opened up new possibilities beyond kiddie cowboys-in-space fluff. Unfortunately, it was bad for Star Trek itself, as basically nobody at NBC actually understood what Gene Roddenberry's show was about. After being rescued by fan petitions from cancellation after the second season, Star Trek didn't get much of a reprieve. Already hampered by a shoestring budget, Star Trek was condemned to the deadly time slot of Friday 10PM, and would end up being unredeemably canceled at the end of this, its third season. Of course, speaking from nearly forty years afterwards, it's hard to hold a grudge about Star Trek getting cut off so early. After all, if Roddenberry had been able to say all he wanted to say in his first sci-fi series, would we have be cheated out of the great series of feature films and subsequent television series that lay in the future?

But leaving aside alternate realities, let's take a look at the Original Series, Season 3. There aren't any truly stand-out episodes in this season as there were in the first two, but we do get a reasonable sampling of solidly entertaining episodes mixed in, to be honest, with some pretty terrible stuff.

Season 3's biggest problem, frankly, is its season opener. "Spock's Brain." Come on. This is the worst Star Trek episode ever. Of any Star Trek show – even counting the Next Generation one with Tasha Yar and the tar monster. It's just awful. What-the-hell-were-they-thinking awful. And it was the first episode of Season 3? That's not a bad decision, that's sabotage! Who knows how many potential new viewers tuned in only to say "What? No thanks!", thereby missing out on the excellent second episode, "The Enterprise Incident."

There are other weak episodes in this season besides "Spock's Brain." "And the Children Shall Lead" offers up a rather cheesy story of the Enterprise being threatened by children, who seem to be under an alien influence. "Plato's Stepchildren," apart from its significance in television history, is pretty silly. "The Way to Eden" gives us hippies in space! Way cool, man! (I admit that I actually thought this episode was OK back when I was a teenager, since Chekov -- the cutest member of the Enterprise crew – has a decent-sized part in this episode. Sadly, though, I now have to report that the episode, taken on its own merits, is very weak.) And, of course, we get a liberal helping of cheesy moments in other episodes, like the now-hackneyed ploy of blowing up the Enterprise, the confrontation with the all-powerful computer, or the even-more-overused "Kirk falls in love with attractive guest-starring woman."

On the whole, though, Season 3 holds up to review better than I expected that it would. There's a sense that Star Trek is trying to reach out and do more and different things than in the previous two seasons; to stretch its own limitations. If that means that sometimes the show overreaches itself and falls flat, it's still better than having the series stay safely within its limitations, content to tell the same story over and over.

In Season 3, we get some interesting story ideas and aliens, from the sped-up beings in "Wink of an Eye" to the interdimensional trap in "The Tholian Web" or the intriguing use of time travel in "All Our Yesterdays." Another solid feature of Season 3 is the inclusion of two episodes featuring what had become the archetypal Star Trek antagonists: the Romulans and the Klingons. These "bad guys" (often portrayed, at least in the case of the Romulans, as reasonable people who just happen to be on a different side from the Federation) make for a nice sense of continuity over the course of the series. While there's no actual connection between the stories, the recurring use of these aliens helps to build up a sense of the Star Trek universe as a real, consistent place. "The Enterprise Incident" (with the Romulans) and "Day of the Dove" (with the Klingons) certainly stand out as two of the more solid early-season episodes.

It's also worth noting some of the other significant features of Star Trek's final season. Most famous is the scene in "Plato's Stepchildren" in which Kirk, under the telekinetic control of one of the aliens, kisses Uhura: not a big deal now, but in 1969 it stood out very dramatically as the first interracial kiss ever to be shown on U.S. network television. On a smaller scale, a few of the incidents in Season 3 will be of interest to Star Trek fans. "Is There in Truth No Beauty?" (a reasonably strong episode, incidentally) features Diana Muldaur's second appearance on the Original Series, as Dr. Miranda Jones. (Muldaur would go on, many years later, to play Dr. Pulaski in the second season of Next Generation.) It's also entertaining to see Star Trek's early attempts at pushing the envelope of "reality" before coming up with the plot device of the holodeck: in "Spectre of the Gun" the away team is mysteriously transported into a recreation of the gunfight at the OK Corral (on the losing side!), and in "The Savage Curtain" the Enterprise crew comes upon a planet that seems to be inhabited by famous people out of the past: Abraham Lincoln from human history, Surak from Vulcan, and Kahless from Klingon, among others. The latter isn't necessarily a particularly good episode (although it's not bad, either), but it does demonstrate Star Trek's willingness to try out new ideas.

Taken by itself, I would rate Season 3 as being a bit lower in quality than Season 1 or Season 2. What bolsters its rating here is that the Season 3 set contains the original pilot: "The Cage," in two versions. As viewers who have seen the other Star Trek seasons will recall, "The Cage" was the first pilot episode, but it was rejected as being "too cerebral." (Insert demonstrations of extreme annoyance with 1960s-era network TV.) The always cash-strapped Star Trek later cannibalized this unaired footage for "The Menagerie," itself a quite good episode that makes clever use of the earlier material. But it wasn't until twenty years later that the original version of "The Cage" was shown to viewers. The first version of it was a Frankensteinian re-construction that mixed color footage from the material re-used in "The Menagerie" with black-and-white footage, which was all that could be dug up for those parts of the original pilot that hadn't been re-used.

Fortunately for Star Trek fans, a more complete print of the original episode was later discovered, and so we get a full "restored version" as well. This version is entirely in full color, and is in better condition than the first reconstruction of "The Cage"; in fact, apart from a few more flaws here and there, it looks as good as any other Star Trek episode. That's a definite plus, since "The Cage" is easily the best episode on the Season 3 set. While it's certainly different in many ways from the show as it was eventually produced, those differences are generally positive. It's hard to watch "The Cage" without wishing that it had been accepted as the pilot... the story is intelligent and thoughtful, Jeffrey Hunter makes an excellent Captain Pike, and it would have been great to see Majel Barrett continue as the serious and intelligent first officer rather than getting relegated to the role of short-skirted Nurse Chapel. Well, chalk it up to the fact that if Star Trek as a whole was ahead of its time, "The Cage" was even farther ahead. In fact, "The Cage" plays rather a lot like an episode of Next Generation, making for an interesting link between the two series.

The restored version of "The Cage" is definitely the one to watch, but it's worth checking out the original version of the episode to catch Gene Roddenberry's eight-minute introduction, in which he talks about the making of that episode and how it was received. There are some very interesting snippets of information here, so it's not to be missed.

The DVD

Star Trek: The Original Series Season 3 is a seven-DVD set, containing all 24 episodes from the show's 1968-1969 season, plus two versions of the original unaired pilot. The set is packaged in the same retro-style, clunky case as the earlier seasons, except this time it's red. At this point I'm sure everyone knows I think these cases are annoying, so let's move on.

Video

These Star Trek episodes appear in their original television aspect ratio of 1.33:1. The overall appearance of these 35-year-old episodes is excellent, with good colors and contrast, and a generally very good handling of detail, especially in close-ups, which consistently look excellent. There's a moderate amount of noise, mostly apparent in middle- or longer-distance shots where the image becomes a bit softer-looking, and a few print flaws make it through. All in all, it's a solid transfer for a vintage show.

Audio

The remastered Dolby 5.1 soundtrack continues to provide an excellent listening experience. The dialogue is consistently clean, crisp, and natural-sounding, and the overall audio track is clean, with no trace of background noise or distortion. Sound effects and music are handled nicely, as well. The original Dolby 2.0 track sounds about the same (there's not really any use of surround in the 5.1 track) except for being a bit flatter-sounding.

Extras

Star Trek: The Original Series finishes up with a nice slate of special features. Text commentaries by Michael Okuda and Denise Okuda appear on two episodes, "The Savage Curtain" and "Turnabout Intruder." The original previews for the episodes also appear on each disc of the set.

Disc 7 is where the majority of the special features are located, beginning with "To Boldly Go: Season 3," which wraps up the original Star Trek run with a 22-minute discussion of the third season, with a lot of attention paid to its cancellation, revival, and final cancellation. Other general-interest featurettes include "Star Trek's Impact," a nine-minute piece narrated by Eugene Roddenberry (Gene Roddenberry's son), and "A Star Trek Collector's Dream Come True" (7 minutes) in which a model and miniature designer discusses the original props used in the show. There's also a production art gallery.

Several featurettes focus on specific members of the cast. "Life Beyond Trek: Walter Koenig" (11 minutes) provides an interesting interview with the actor, in which he discusses his relation to Star Trek, his acting work outside the Trek franchise, and his hobby of collecting Star Trek and comic-book-character memorabilia. Viewers who have gotten used to seeing the robust Chief Engineer Scott in these episodes will get a bit of a jolt from seeing "Scotty" in his mid-80s in the "Chief Engineer's Log," which is an interview with James Doohan. While only six minutes long, there are some interesting tidbits of Star Trek trivia here. "Memoir from Mr. Sulu" features an energetic and as-always articulate George Takei discussing his thoughts on Star Trek as well as his involvement with the Japanese-American Museum.

Six "hidden files" are also included: two each on the first three menu screens of the special features section.

Final thoughts

Season 3 may not show Star Trek: The Original Series at its finest, but there are plenty of decent episodes here for Star Trek fans to enjoy. Essentially, if you've enjoyed the first two seasons, you'll want to add Season 3 to your collection as well, especially since it contains the unaired pilot, "The Cage." The overall look of the show on DVD is quite good, and the set does have a reasonable selection of special features. Recommended.

Popular Reviews
1. Welcome Back, Kotter: The Complete Series
2. Legend of Hell House
3. Last Man Standing Season 1
4. Chaplin's Mutual Comedies
5. Wilfred Season 3
6. Dragon Ball Z: Season 6
7. The Walking Dead: Season 4
8. Rosemary's Baby (2014)
9. Herzog: The Collection
10. Tie Me Up! Tie Me Down!: The Criterion Collection


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use