So much has been said about Nirvana at this point in
magazines and on talking head basic cable clip shows
that another documentary almost seems superfluous. But
the Classic Albums series is always a cut above the average
reminiscence release, thanks to its dedication to
looking underneath the sheen of the finished recording
at the process that created it. In the case of
Nirvana's "Nevermind" it's not just the sound of the
album that's important, but the impact it had on
popular music.
When they recorded "Nevermind," Nirvana were a trio of scruffy musicians with the
expectation of maybe selling a couple hundred thousand records. With the simple, groovy
basslines of Kris Novaselic, the powerhouse drumming or Dave Grohl and, most especially,
the writing, singing, and guitar playing of Kurt Cobain, the band had the perfect
ingredients to mix punk abrasiveness with Beatles melody and the abstract
word-music of the Pixies into something new. "Nevermind" was a landmark in rock that
took the wind
out of the sails of the waning 80's hair band genre
and introduced the gritty, pared-down sounds of punk
and underground rock to the mainstream.
Produced by
Butch Vig (who later went on to co-found the band
Garbage), "Nevermind" was a blast of feedback and
noise directed directly at the ears of the kids who
needed a new sound. But it's also a tremendously
complex record, filled with beautiful melodies and
somber dirges. The band can turn from the chaos of
"Territorial Pissings" to the watery depths of "Come
As You Are," from the surprisingly happy bounce of
"Drain You" to the somber, almost ghostly "Something
in the Way," with absolute clarity, weaving a
consistency throughout all the tempos and
sounds.
The album, of course, is kicked off with
"Smells Like Teen Spirit," a song of such pop
perfection that it's been played and played again to
the point of absurdity. But beyond the radio success
of this most memorable of singles lies a simple structure, memorable hooks, ambiguously
magnetic lyrics ("A mulatto, an albino, a mosquito, my libido") and musicianship that
ranges from the bouncy rhythm section of the verses to the thunderous choruses to the
buzzsaw guitar solo, which wraps up with a ringing echo of feedback. With all the Limp
Bizkits and Linkin Parks on the scene today it's still stunning how live and raw
"Teen Spirit" sounded.
Like much of the Classic Albums program, the best part of the "Teen Spirit"
segment is when Vig sits in the studio and dissects the various isolated tracks to show
how a sound - even one as seemingly threadbare as Nevermind's - is constructed.
Removing all but Cobain's vocals on "Teen Spirit" Vig shows how hard the man sang. His
vocal chords do sound like they're almost tearing from strain over the final "denial"s.
Similarly, the vocals on "In Bloom," taken away from the rest of the instrumentation
are haunting in their simplicity. Hearing Cobain a capella like this (a new context
for a voice we thought we'd head the last of) is eerie; It's like a voice crying out
from the beyond. When Vig adds Cobain's second vocal track to "In Bloom" (the vocals
were doubled on many cuts to give them a more mysterious, melodic quality), it becomes
somehow bigger. Adding in Dave Grohl's two tracks of harmony suddenly turns this
voice-only performance of the song into a symphony. It's striking how beautiful
it sounds. Vig's orchestral treatment of this basic rock configuration is evident at
other times as well, like when he layers five different guitars (ranging from a clean
track to an ultra-fuzzed out distorted sound) to create something powerful and
monumental.
Another song that gets a good bit of attention in the Classic Albums program
(not every song is dissected) is the somber closer "Something in the Way." This
melancholy dirge obviously affected Vig during recording. He recalls not feeling like
it was working until Cobain laid on his back in the control room and strummed the
guitar and sang in a whisper so quiet that he was concerned that any noise in the
studio would ruin the take. Listening to this hushed performance with Vig, obviously
moved by the memory, makes the lyrics - previously obtuse for this listener - take on
new, personal meaning. Vig added minimal instrumentation to Cobain's initial reading of
the song - subtle playing from Grohl and Novaselic as well as some funereal cello - but
he helped nail the atmosphere Cobain brought to that session.
In addition to the studio segments, Classic Albums features typical interviews
with folks like Sonic Youth's Thurston Moore and Rolling Stone writer David Fricke
which add some minor insight but the only interviews that really count are with Vig
and, especially, Grohl and Novaselic. Their stories and anecdotes of Nirvana are
crucial to "Nevermind." Grohl, who's found enormous success with Foo Fighters, clearly
holds his few short years in Nirvana in high regards. He's a funny interview subject
with a laid-back style.
Novaselic, a lifelong friend of Cobain's, has almost a sad vibe
about him. Near the end he croaks out that "Nevermind" is probably the best thing he'll
ever do in his life. As far as creative highpoints go it's not a bad one to have under
your belt, but the unspoken suggestion is that he missed Cobain very, very much. It's a
heartbreaking little moment in a program that's far too classy to dwell on the darkest
side of Nirvana's legacy. But, as with all the band's music, it's all there, under the
surface. For a band that only released three studio albums (including one other
classic, the much harsher Steve Albini-produced "In Utero") Nirvana's impact is
tremendous.
VIDEO:
The anamorphic video is pretty good. It mostly consists of talking heads with the
occasional grainy hand-held shots of Seattle or Aberdeen and some archival footage of
the band. Some of the more significant live clips (like the debut performance of "Teen
Spirit") are understandably rough, having been shot on low-grade camcorders. But
overall this is a colorful, well-shot piece.
AUDIO:
The Dolby Digital stereo audio is very good. Interview voices are clear and the music
sounds great. In the studio segments with Butch Vig the music has a clarity that really
enhances the idea that you're there with the producer, hearing the master recordings.
EXTRAS:
The disc includes additional segments on the recording of "Drain You," the making of the "Teen Spirit" video, the legendary
naked baby album art (including an interview with the now-grown baby!), Dave Grohl
joining the band (which really should have been added to the main feature), and the
band's trip to LA to record the record. There is also the full version of a performance
of "Polly" glimpsed briefly in the main program. A very nice set of extras.
FINAL THOUGHTS:
The Classic Albums series can be illuminating even when the music is only of
passing interest to the viewer. But when the record means so much to so many it becomes
a truly fascinating experience. The added drama of Nirvana's fate makes this glimpse
into the origins of the record extra interesting. If only the powers that be would
release the full Nirvana MTV Unplugged performance (possibly the single best original
programming that channel ever produced) then audiences could make a complete assessment
of the band's impact.