Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




XXX - State of the Union

Columbia/Tri-Star // PG-13 // July 26, 2005
List Price: $28.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Ian Jane | posted July 19, 2005 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:

Xander Cage is dead, long live Darius Stone! Following up sometime shortly after the events in the XXX: Director's Cut in which Xander Cage is blown up and killed, XXX: State Of The Union throws former NWA bad-boy Ice Cube into the role of America's newest top super secret agent.

When a group of commandos overtake the XXX compound in Virginia, Augustus Gibbons (Samuel L. Jackson reprising his role from the first film) decides that it's time to find someone badder and more extreme to fill Cage's shoes and find out who is after them and why. His pick is Stone, who he worked with some time in the past in some sort of special op unit (it's never explained in much detail) and who is currently doing time in the big house for punching out his commanding officer, General Deckert (Willam Dafoe), who has since been promoted to a higher up position in the White House.

Gibbons and company spring Stone from a maximum security prison and quickly get him up to speed on they 'hows and whys' of being a XXX. They brief him on as much as they know about the attack and pretty much set him loose to do his thing and he takes to it like a fish to water. As Stone starts snooping around Washington he uncovers Deckert's plot through some undercover work and soon enough he's called into action to save the country from evil.

If the first XXX was a James Bond film for those suffering from ADD, XXX: State Of The Union is a James Bond for the mentally retarded. This movie has plot holes in it the size of the Pacific Ocean and a good portion of the film simply defies logic. Loose ends are never resolved, continuity is thrown out the window, and lots of stuff blows up. Car chases, shoot outs, explosions, a bullet train, and a few hand to hand combat scenes keep the action coming fast and furious like, but unfortunately the film checks its brain at the door on the way in.

The film makes a couple of backhanded references to its predecessor such as when Ice Cube notes what he 'isn't going to do for his country' or when Samuel Jackson answers the question of what happened to the first XXX with a coy 'he's dead' but other than that it doesn't really have a whole lot to do with the earlier film.

While much of the success of the first film was in the stunt work, here much of the daredevil action if handled completely, and very obviously so, by computer graphics. At times the film feels more like a video game than a movie and sadly these scenes do suffer because of it. When Ice Cube races a Shelby Cobra down the railroad tracks after the Presidential Bullet Train, the fact that the helicopters that are backing him are not real really does hurt what could otherwise have been a fun, over the top moment. Instances like this are peppered throughout the film and it hurts the movie in a big way.

The camerawork is frenetic in that the film never stops moving though not without a few impressive moments (the rooftop chase when Stone escapes from prison is nicely done… until he jumps up to catch the helicopter). The dialogue is corny, cliché-ridden, and difficult to take seriously and the performances are completely hampered by the script. Dafoe and Jackson have been excellent in the past and even Ice Cube has had a few shining moments but sadly you wouldn't know that by any of their work in this movie.

That being said, despite its rampant stupidity, XXX: State Of The Union is an entertaining, if completely dumb, time waster. The dialogue is as ham-fisted as it gets, with Ice Cube talking trash to anyone who gets in his way just to show how 'street' he is (for further proof of this, when going over his dosier we see a picture of him from his N.W.A. days) and these moments provide plenty of unintentional (?) hilarity. The movie isn't trying to be anything it isn't. It's not marketed as an intelligent action film or even an original one – it's simply a comic book come to life. If you're able to turn of your brain for a hundred minutes or so, as many of us are, Ice Cube and Samuel L. Jackson will probably entertain you at least a little bit. The filmmakers have followed up a flashy, brainless action film with an even flashier (though unconvincing) and more brainless action film.

The DVD

Video:

The anamorphic 2.40.1 widescreen transfer does a fantastic job with the color reproduction but could have been just a hair sharper. Mastered in high definition, there's a pretty solid level of detail throughout the majority of the film but one or two scenes, action scenes mostly, are ever so slightly flat. Other than that, however, this transfer is very good. The colors are bright and powerful, the black levels stay strong and deep throughout and the skin tones look natural. There aren't any problems at all with print damage and film grain is only noticeable once or twice during play back. The image is consistently clean and clear and free of any serious defects and while there is some edge enhancement and line shimmering in a few spots, it's not overwhelming and doesn't prove to be too distracting at all.

Sound:

You've got your choice of watching the film in either its original English language in a very aggressive Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound mix, or dubbed into French in a Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround mix. Optional subtitles are available in French and English, and an English closed captioning option has also been provided.

While it's kind of funny to watch Ice Cube do his thing dubbed into French, the obvious choice is the English language Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound mix as it makes full use of all the speakers in your setup (well, unless you've got 6.1 or 7.1) and gives your subwoofer a pretty healthy workout as well. The dialogue is clean and clear and always easy to understand and the surround channels really kick in during the more action intensive scenes. During the shoot outs, bullets whiz past you from all direction, and during the car chases the engine noises put you right in the driver's seat. The explosions will shake your subwoofer nicely and the sound of debris will fly around you. In short, the sound mix does a very good job of bringing the action into your living room and it's just as over the top as the movie itself is.

Extras:

Gluttons for punishment will be delighted to find not one but two commentary tracks supplied on this DVD. The first track is from director Lee Tamahori and screenwriter Scott Hindberg and although it's a fairly lively track, it isn't all that mind blowing. They cover the basics of the film's production, how Ice Cube was chosen for the role, how they came up with some of the action set pieces and a few of the obstacles that they encountered in bringing them to life. All in all, not a bad commentary track, but not a classic either. If you were really into the movie, this one is likely going to be worth your time. The second commentary track is from a few of the visual and CGI effects supervisor's who worked on the film. This one is considerably more technical in nature, and it does a halfway decent job of enlightening us as to how they worked the flesh and blood actors and props into the computer generated set pieces. While I don't feel that they were all that successful in their attempts to seamlessly blend the real with the unreal, some of the 'how did they do that' questions that are answered here in this commentary are rather interesting.

Up next is a fairly extensive documentary on the making of the film entitled From Convict To Hero: The Making Of XXX: State Of The Union that is actually quite worthwhile if you're into behind the scenes material. We get plenty of interviews with pretty much all of the key cast members and a few of the guys and gals who make it all come together behind the camera as well, but in addition to that we get quite a bit of raw stunt footage that shows how much work went into the action set pieces that make up the bulk of the film's merit. Interestingly enough, Dafoe states that he based his performance on Donal Rumsfeld, which puts his character's politics in a much creepier light.

Up next are three brief 'making of' featurettes that each take a look at a more specific aspect of the movie. First up is Top Secret Military Warehouse which gives us an interesting look at the set design and soundstage area that was used throughout the film. XXX: According To Ice Cube is a sit down session with the star of the film who talks about why he liked the role, why he took the role, and how he feels about the film. Finally, Bullet Train Breakdown shows how the bullet train sequence was created by blending computer generated graphics with soundstage work and real life stunt work.

Rounding out the extra features are three quick deleted scenes that were mainly cut for pacing reasons that are available with or without an optional commentary from Tamahori. There are a few fun moments in here but nothing that at all affects the outcome of the film. There is also a handful of trailers for other Columbia/Sony DVD releases including Stealth, Steamboy, and the XXX Unrated DVD release.

Final Thoughts:

XXX: State Of The Union looks great and sounds great and Sony has slapped a fair amount of mediocre extra features on the disc providing pretty decent 'bang for the buck.' Sadly, the movie is pretty bad. Plenty of unintentional hilarity give the film a few worthwhile moments but the replay value just isn't there and I can't see anyone wanting to go back to this one more than once. With that in mind, action movie die hards or those who appreciate movies on a 'so bad it's good' level might want to give this one a rental.

Ian lives in NYC with his wife where he writes for DVD Talk, runs Rock! Shock! Pop!. He likes NYC a lot, even if it is expensive and loud.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Rent It

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links