DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » Downfall
Downfall
Columbia/Tri-Star // R // August 2, 2005
List Price: $29.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Svet Atanasov | posted August 8, 2005 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
DVD Talk Collector Series
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly
The Film:
April 1945, the last days of Hitler. Berlin is on the verge of being destroyed by the Red Army. Hitler and the entire political and military leadership of the National Socialist Party are slowly realizing that the end is near. The remaining parts of the once almighty German army are unable to push back the Russians, both the Eastern and Western fronts are now doomed. Yet, Hitler still wants to believe that his military leadership will outmaneuver the Red Army and prevent it from entering Berlin. Sheltered in a bunker nearby the once glorious Reichstag he often bursts in rage only so he could minutes later disappear in his office contemplating what Germany could have been.

On an extraordinary large Victorian table a miniature model of Berlin has captured Hitler's attention. Massive white architectural prototypes of buildings that would have epitomized the power of the Nazi regime are now just a pile of useless paper. Berlin, as Hitler envisioned it, is never going to be built. His plans to redraw the map of Europe now seem like a memory that even the most zealous of his followers will have to admit was a failure.

Under the thunderous skies of Berlin, however, soldiers are still fighting. Every street, every home, every sidewalk is a battlefield. Even little children wearing intimidating uniforms are being called upon to defend the city. Those who refuse to join the resistance are swiftly being dealt with, ordinary looking men are hanging from street poles and bodies are lying around often decorated with brash signs denouncing the "traitors". A state of human pandemonium has engulfed the city of Berlin.

Based on the books "Until the Final Hour" by Hitler's secretary Traudl Junge and "Inside Hitler's Bunker" by Joachim Fest Der Untergang a. k. a Downfall is a film that examines the last days of Hitler before his infamous suicide. Directed by Oliver Hirschbiegel, well known for his 2001 project Das Experiment, this is a film that shakes the very core of the image Hitler has been associated with during the years. An extremely mature and well-balanced look at the final hours of Nazi Germany Der Untergang is more of a character study than a typical period film.

The level of realism that Oliver Hirschbiegel delivers is not only unprecedented it is quite frankly intimidating. I can hardly recall another actor in recent history recreating a historic figure of Hitler's magnitude as uncompromisingly perfect as Swiss-born Bruno Ganz conveys. The inhumanly vile outbursts, the powerful gestures numbing everyone surrounding Hitler, the look of a madman well-aware of his mission, are not the acting of a man attempting to reconstruct a controversial political figure. What we see in Der Untergang is Hitler, awaiting his fate and contemplating the inevitable.

There is much in Der Untergang that is rather suggestive than outright revealing. Shot almost entirely within the confines of Hitler's bunker the film never really attempts to recapture the massive onslaught Berlin was exposed to. On the contrary it reveals a rather intimate look at a man that is as abusive with his generals as he is affectionate with his secretary Frau Junge. In fact, much of the narrative is indeed structured around Hitler's emotional struggle to surmount the fact that his vision of a Greater Germania is slowly fading away. Yet, together with the impeccable recreation of Hitler Der Untergang reveals the city of Berlin in a manner one could only imagine seeing in Dante's Inferno. The few shots of kids dragging bazookas, the Nazis frantically throwing books and documents through the windows of half-crumbled buildings, "civil" groups dealing with the "Bolsheviks" on the streets of Berlin, and amateur doctors cutting torn-apart human legs give Der Untergang a level of authenticity that even Roman Polanski's The Pianist could not achieve.

There are scenes in Der Untergang that my writing I am afraid will fail to describe adequately. Near the end when all seems lost many of the bunker's inhabitants begin final preparations. Some submerge into a grotesque orgy of alcohol and uncontrolled dancing other retreat in the darker corners of the underground shelter preparing to commit suicide. No one shares the illusion that the course of history can be reversed. Hitler also stages a final diner after his relationship with Eva Brown has been made official. A group of children is singing German songs while a few of Hitler's generals are quietly smoking in a state of total disbelief. These are scenes so overwhelming that the intensity they are filled with is simply unbearable.

Much has been written about the manner in which Hitler is portrayed in Der Untergang. Some have claimed that Oliver Hirschbiegel has been too generous "humanizing" the dictator. I could not agree more…and yet disagree with such claims. The emotional struggles which Hitler undergoes on the screen are so well performed by Bruno Ganz that the evil which he exemplified is revealed with a force that I have seen in only a few films during my lifetime. This is indeed filmmaking by a mature director that has captured the very essence of a man consumed by madness. In fact, I can attest that Hirschbiegel's approach is precisely why the film worked for me. Der Untergang defies quite well every major cliché that film directors end up following when exploring Hitler's persona by placing morality well before authenticity.

Half a century after his death Hitler is still a man that fascinates historians. His impact as a politician, demagogue, and a leader, strongly resonates with the international community. The faith and hatred he planted in the hearts of his followers created tragedies that history will remember forever. The burden of his deeds is so overwhelming that anyone that touches it turns victim of conventional stereotypes, including film directors that aspire to retell his story. Oliver Hirschbiegel and his latest film Der Untergang are a rare exception. Crafted with an enormous amount of detail this is a film that delivers an Oscar-caliber performance by Bruno Ganz. More importantly, however, it reconstructs the final hours of Hitler in a manner only a few films have successfully managed. There is no "romanticizing" or "glorifying" of Hitler and his closest accomplices in Der Untergang. For anyone claiming that the director does so I recommend that you view the extensive interview with Olivier Hirschbiegel and then see Der Untergang again. If anything, Olivier Hirschbiegel has clearly come to terms with the fact that history can not be reversed though certainly it can be learned from. At least by those mature enough to grasp its significance.

How Does the DVD Look? I am aware of the fact that many are interested in the quality of this Region 1 DVD and how exactly it compares to the existing Region 2 German Premium edition. Below I will compare as much as I could, without the inclusion of direct caps, these two releases.
Sony Pictures have released the film in an aspect ratio of 1.78:1 and have anamorphically enhanced it for widescreen TV's. With this said, I would like to address a few comments regarding the original aspect ratio of the film. Those that own the German double set are well aware of the fact that the film was presented in a 1.78:1 ratio as well although a quick research reveals that the film was actually shot in 1.85:1. While the difference is rather insignificant judging by the number of similarities between the R1 and R2 versions I believe that Sony Pictures have simply used the same film material provided by the German distributors (sans a few differences I will address below).
The picture quality on the Sony release is almost identical to the German R2 version. During the day scenes contrast is well handled, colors and flesh tones appear accurate, and a direct comparison indicates that edge enhancement is kept to a minimum. I would like to specifically discuss the grainy look of the film that many might unjustifiably regard as digitally manipulated or simply as a result of poor presentation. As mentioned in the review above the predominant amount of Der Untergang takes place in a poorly lit bunker as well as during night scenes that offer a substantial amount of grain to the film stock. I performed a very meticulous comparison between the two versions discussed here and in my opinion the level of grain is almost (again) identical. If anything, I believe that the Region 2 presentation looks a tiny bit better when viewed through a digital projector. For those however using standard tubes the difference should be insignificant.
Those concerned with possible PAL to NTSC transfer issues will also be pleased to find that the region 1 release boasts an excellent progressive transfer free of "ghosting" or "combing" so often found on other foreign releases offered on the North American market. The overall quality of the print used by Sony Pictures is in excellent condition and does not show any evidence of wear or damage.
One of the few areas where I see a noticeable difference between the Region 1 and Region 2 releases (of course sans the massive extras provided for the Premium edition) is the degree of natural lighting. Look for example at the scene where Frau Junge first enters the underground shelter. On the Region 1 version I find the lighting rather subdued while the German R2 DVD offers rather more stellar video quality. As a result I see more detail, especially on facial close ups, separating the two presentations. The level of film grain however remains the same which leads me to believe that this is a difference prompted by the conversion process.
Last but not least I would like to address how this DVD presentation compares to the actual theatrical release. As I was especially concerned with the way the film looked, not because it was poorly executed, but because of its delicate and very subtle camera work, I am glad to report that the unique look of the film (subdued colors, delicate lighting, often shaky camera moves, etc.,) is captured perfectly. As far as I am concerned there has been no additional "correction" by the DVD producers and Der Untergang looks as spectacular as it did in the theater.

How Does The DVD Sound?
I assume that just as it was the case with the video presentation many will be curious to learn how the two existing versions compare in terms of audio quality. Well, this time around I can clearly indicate that the German Premium edition is without a doubt the better option. While the Region 1 release boasts only a German 5.1 Dolby Digital track the German R2 disc offers a thunderous DTS track that simply is beyond any direct comparison. I suppose that the easiest way to determine the differences between the two versions would be to view the air raid that Berlin gets exposed to towards the middle of Der Untergang. The sound aggression you would hear from your DTS infused speakers is almost intimidating and places you in the middle of the action much more convincingly than the 5.1 track.
With this said, the Region 1 release has nothing to shy away from (aside only from the fact that the English subs appear burnt-in and are NOT optional). For those that are not hardcore audiophiles the 5.1 track will without a doubt meet the expectations. It is indeed a well-mastered mix that separates action from dialog perfectly and compliments the film rather well. If you, however, are looking for the complete package of Der Untergang the audio presentation clearly places the Premium Edition as your undisputed winner between the two English friendly versions.

Extras: This is the most delicate part of the Region 1 presentation as there are only a few extras to comment on. First of all there is an audio commentary by director Oliver Hirschbiegel in English that is absolutely a delight to listen to. I would specifically like to point out that the commentary is in excellent English and offers a very revealing look at a film which is to say the least controversial. Next, there is a rather elaborate making-of and a few short interviews with the cast and director of the film that are present on the German single disc edition (the Premium version offers extended interviews and additional extras which for those considering the German disc instead of the R1 are non-English friendly). A rather unfortunate presentation by the North American distributors in terms of extras as Der Untergang clearly could have been a double disc edition with ALL of the extras provided on the German Premium edition. If there ever was a film warranting special treatment this is it. What a missed opportunity!!!

Final thoughts: Considering all of the pros and cons of the existing two editions in my opinion the German Premium edition clearly comes out as a winner. From a stylish design and presentation and an impressive DTS track that elevates the film to a substantially different experience without detracting from the picture quality the R2 of Der Untergang should clearly be the option for those wishing to own the film in their collections. Even more so considering the fact that the actual difference in terms of pricing will be considerably in favor of the German disc (I assume that the R1 version will be priced between 20-23$ and the German disc could be imported for a few dollars more).
With this said I will also go against my own quality standards (read about burnt-in subtitles above) by placing the R1 DVD in the DVDTALK's Collector's Series class, due to the enormous power of the film and quality acting provided by everyone involved with this project and the unfortunate lack of substantial extras. I wish North America could have gotten a massive double set that does justice to this controversial film but I am also a realist and I do understand that foreign made films, and especially films that received such a poor and limited distribution in the US, as Der Untergang did are unlikely to convince distributors that massive DVD treatment is needed. Regardless, seek and see this film, there is much in it that we could learn from. And for those that appreciate serious cinema-OWN IT.

Popular Reviews
1. William Shatner's Get a Life!
2. Batman: Assault on Arkham
3. The Amazing Spider-Man 2
4. Dr. Kildare: The Complete Third Season, Part One & Two (Warner Archive Collection)
5. Toy Story of Terror
6. Y tu mama tambien
7. Out Of The Past: Warner Archives
8. Woodstock, 3 Days of Peace & Music (40th Anniversary Revisited)
9. The Children's Hour
10. Muppets Most Wanted


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use