Jane Goodall's Return to Gombe
is a 50-minute special from the Animal Planet channel, which should
provide a good preview as to how in-depth the program is going to be.
It's decent for what it is, but it's certainly "nature
As most viewers should know, Dr.
Jane Goodall is famous for her work with the chimpanzees of Gombe,
and for her tireless work in support of conservation and educational
work to protect the chimpanzees and their African habitat. There's
ample material for any number of documentaries on Goodall's work and
on the chimpanzees themselves, but what Return to Gombe
focuses on is a bit of a hybrid. The program follows Goodall as she
wraps up a lecture tour and heads to Gombe for a visit with the
chimpanzees she studied more than forty years earlier; it's a
meaningful visit for her, as she has had little time to return to the
research station in the past several decades. Interspersed with this
material is some information on how the chimps of Gombe are doing: as
it turns out, a power struggle is under way, with the alpha male,
Frodo, under threat by rivals for his position.
The documentary is tantalizing in
that it hints at interesting aspects of chimpanzee behavior. We're
told that the chimps have a complex social hierarchy, and that
diplomacy can be as important as brute force in consolidating
a strong position in the group. It's very clear that the chimps have
individual personalities as well. (Goodall's then-radical choice of
naming the chimps when she started studying them in the 1960s turned
out to be a very good idea; it's not a question of anthropomorphism
when the named animals really do behave in human-like ways). It would
be fascinating to explore how the group really lives and how the
chimps interact with each other; even in the short clips we do see,
it's startlingly clear that these "animals" are much, much
closer to us humans than we're used to thinking. It's a little
disturbing -- in the sense of shaking up one's preconceptions -- to
look into the chimp's eyes and see another thinking being; the "bush
meat" trade that has so devastated ape populations looks a lot
like cannibalism once you get to know the chimps as individuals.
That's not what Return to Gombe
is about, though. Rather than going into any particular topic in
detail, we get a general overview of a lot of different topics,
including Goodall's pioneering work with "Roots and Shoots"
to promote conservation and education in Africa. As an introduction
to Dr. Goodall's work and influence, then, the documentary does a
decent job; if you're already familiar with the basics and want more,
it'll leave you feeling unsatisfied. The program would probably be a
good choice for children.
The documentary is presented in a
pleasing anamorphic widescreen transfer, at what I believe is its
original 1.78:1 aspect ratio (certainly it does not seem to have been
cropped for the DVD). Colors and contrast look good; the footage in
the forest is, not surprisingly, a little lower in quality than the
footage shot in more amenable circumstances, but overall it's a
The Dolby 2.0 soundtrack handles the
requirements of the film well. All the participants come across
clearly (both human and chimp) and the voiceover narration is clear
A 26-minute featurette called "On
the Road with Jane Goodall" takes a reasonably interesting look
at Goodall's work as a traveling lecturer and promoter of
Jane Goodall's Return to Gombe
is a fairly well done program that offers a light-weight introduction
to Goodall's research and conservation work. It's "light"
in the sense of not going into any depth of information, not in tone:
apart from the oddity of calling Dr. Goodall by her first name (which
I consider to be a little disrespectful), the program has a serious
and thoughtful approach. It's not going to provide much new
information to adults who are already even a little bit familiar with
Goodall's work, but it would be a nice introduction for children.
I'll give it a strong "rent it" recommendation for younger
audiences, whether at home or in a classroom.