Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




American Gangster (HD DVD)

Universal // R // February 19, 2008 // Region 0
List Price: $39.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Ian Jane | posted March 1, 2008 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:

In the years that Frank Lucas (Denzel Washington) served as Harlem gangster Bumpy Johnson's right hand man, he learned from the best. When Bumpy passed away, it made sense that Frank would rise up and take his place even if a few rival Harlem hoods didn't see it that way. The key to Frank's rising success in the New York underworld of the early seventies was 'Blue Magic' - pure heroin that he had imported from Bangkok. He sold this dope, which was twice as strong as the competition's, at half the price and before you know it the man has so much money he's able to move his family from North Carolina into a massive mansion in New York City and take a beautiful woman named Eva (Lymari Nadal) for his wife.

At the same time, a New Jersey cop named Ritchie Roberts (Russell Crowe) and his partner (Ted Lavine) find a car full of mob money. Rather than keep it, which is what 70% of the cops on the force would have done at the time, they turn it in. While this doesn't do the pair any favors with their fellow officers, it does bring Ritchie to the attention of the Feds, who hire him on to work for the district attorney in hopes of corking the flow of drugs into the area. The deeper Ritchie's investigation goes, the closer he comes to Frank but while all of this is going on, corrupt cops, lead by Detective Trupo (Josh Brolin), are causing problems on both sides of the fence and both sides of the Hudson River.

American Gangster, Ridley Scott's take on the mob movie, is interesting in that despite all the supporting characters and little plot twists in its near three hour running time, it's essentially the story of two very similar men working opposite sides of the street. Roberts is as honest as a cap can be though his wife is in the process of divorcing him for being a philanderer. Lucas is a family man, very good to his mother and his brother, but if you cross him in a business transaction, he'll put a bullet in your head right in the middle of a busy street, witnesses be damned. Each man works very hard to get what they want, and it's these similarities that make the characters interesting. While Roberts is researching the intricacies of Frank's organization, Frank is researching how to keep his supply coming in at the right price and how to get it into the right hands. Their respective systems are a lot alike, as are their personalities, and Scott's film exploits these characteristics quite nicely.

Both Crowe and Washington are excellent in their performances. While both men have been known to go a little over the top in the past, here they're quite restrained and both are very believable in their parts. Throw in some excellent supporting and bit-part performances from Josh Brolin, Ted Levine, Cuba Gooding Jr., Armand Assante, and Clarence Williams III and you've got yourself a very well acted and well cast film. The costume and wardrobe all looks authentically early seventies and the location shooting certainly ensures that the backdrop for the drama looks right, with the natural grittiness of New York City coming through in pretty much every frame of the film. While more engrossing mob films have been made in the past, American Gangster holds its own. Sure it's a little long but the story is interesting enough and the character developed enough that it's never boring.

Notes about the extended cut: An additional eighteen minutes have been added to the extended cut of American Gangster which serve to flesh out the characters a little better and to help with the flow of the film. Nothing is seriously changed here, however, and the bit added to the ending of the film feels a little off.

The HD DVD

Video:

American Gangster is presented in a nice 1080p VC-1 encoded 1.85.1 anamorphic widescreen transfer that does justice to the film's gritty style. Detail is excellent and there are no problems with softness or print damage despite a little bit of grain here and there. Color reproduction accurately depicts the 'seventies' look that they were obviously going for so don't expect the colors to leap off of the screen at you but even in that department the picture looks good. Skin tones are lifelike and very natural looking and black levels stay nice and strong. There are no problems with mpeg compression artifacts or edge enhancement and over all this is just a very solid looking transfer. Shadow detail could have been a little bit better but aside from that, there's nothing to complain about here.

For whatever reason, this HD DVD combo disc contains only the theatrical cut in high definition. The unrated, extended cut of the film is on the B side of the disc (the theatrical cut is also available in standard definition) and is presented in standard definition only. The added scenes in this cut of the film stand out a little bit and don't look quite as good as the content seen in the theatrical cut but aside from that this is a fine standard definition transfer (even if the extended cut should have been available in high definition).

Sound:

For the HD DVD presentation we get French and English language Dolby Digital Plus 5.1 Surround Sound tracks with optional subtitles available in English (SDH) or French. While this track isn't the 'be all, end all' of high definition audio (a Dolby Digital TrueHD track would have been very welcome!), it certainly gets the job done. Dialogue is always nice and sharp and easy to understand while the levels stay properly balanced throughout. Gun shots have a nice punch to them and while your subwoofer isn't going to break too much of a sweat it does get a bit of exercise now and again. The score in particular sounds quite nice and the rear channels are used to fill in the room quite effectively.

The standard definition extended cut features an English language Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound track while the standard definition presentation of the theatrical cut of the film provides English and French Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound tracks. Subtitles are provided in English (SDH), French and Spanish. Subtitles are provided for the movie only and are not available for the supplements.

Extras:

On the HD DVD side of this release, supplements kick off with a commentary courtesy of director Ridley Scott and screenwriter Steven Zaillian. While Scott does a fine job of covering everything you'd expect him to, such as location shooting, casting, and things like that, the real star of this track is Steven Zaillian who has a lot to say about the way he wrote the characters in the film and why. Zaillian obviously did quite a bit of research into what made the two leads tick and it's interesting to hear from him about how he went about putting all of this together. More input from Scott would have been very welcome, he's almost quiet at times here, but this is a decent track even if it doesn't rank up there with the best of Scott's commentaries.

Up next are a few deleted and alternate scenes, seven scenes and an alternate opening scene totaling approximately twelve minutes in all together. These are basically just quick little bits of dialogue trimmed from the film (presumably) to quicken the pacing and the don't really change the film much at all. This is not the eighteen minutes worth of material that's been added to the film in the extended cut.

From there, check out the all too brief featurette, The Real Frank Lucas And Ritchie Roberts, which allows the real life Frank Lucas and the real life Ritchie Roberts some camera time to talk about their lives while Crowe and Washington talk about their respective portrayals. At under five minutes in length, this segment is just way too short, particularly when you consider that the two-disc standard definition release had a feature length documentary on the men who inspired the film.

Exclusive to this HD DVD release is a Picture In Picture track that has Scott show up once or twice for some interview questions but is mainly made up of very brief snippets of the cast and crew on set. This should have and could have been a really solid bonus feature but instead it turns out to be fairly superficial and it really only scratches the surface of the film and its history. Also exclusive to the HD DVD release is the standard Universal studios My Scenes bookmark options, and for those with a web-enabled HD DVD player, access to some exclusive online content from Universal's website (made up primarily of trailers and promotional material).

The standard definition side of this release contains the commentary from Scott and Zaillian available for the theatrical cut only, animated menus, and chapter selection. The supplements are presented in standard definition 480i anamorphic widescreen regardless of which side of the disc you opt for. When you look at the supplements available on the standard definition releases (two and three discs respectively) for this title, you have to wonder why Universal didn't do a better job of porting everything over...

Final Thoughts:

American Gangster is a solid effort from Scott even if there are better gangster movies out there. Crowe and Washington are very good in their respective roles and the film looks great. The HD DVD, despite a very nice transfer, is a bit of a disappointment. Universal really should have carried over the other supplements and given fans the extended cut in HD as well as a TrueHD track, but sadly that didn't happen. Recommended on the strength of the film, not the strength of the release itself.

Ian lives in NYC with his wife where he writes for DVD Talk, runs Rock! Shock! Pop!. He likes NYC a lot, even if it is expensive and loud.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Recommended

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links