DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » P.S. I Love You
P.S. I Love You
Warner Bros. // PG-13 // May 6, 2008
List Price: $28.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Cameron McGaughy | posted May 1, 2008 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Skip It
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly
"I think it's time it stopped. It's not healthy...at some point you're going to have to face things on your own." - Patricia Rawley

The Movie
Dear Hilary...why did you do it? Why?! I'm one of your biggest fans, was thrilled with your two Oscar wins, and I love your acting--even in The Black Dahlia! But what possessed you to tackle this pandering piece of poo?

I'm not a woman, but if I was, I'd be really, really insulted by this romantic comedy based on a novel by Cecelia Ahern. Swank plays Holly Kennedy, a real estate agent who wants more in life, even with hunky Irish boyfriend Gerry (Gerard Butler) already at her side. But her life takes a turn for the worse when he dies of a brain tumor, leaving her to wallow in depression as her mom Patricia (Kathy Bates) and best friends Denise (Lisa Kudrow) and Sharon (Gina Gershon) try to cheer her up.

But fear not! Soon, she receives a surprise present on her 30th birthday, along with an audio tape from beyond the grave: Gerry telling her that she can expect to receive a series of letters from him in the future. "You must do what I say, okay?" he warns. Wow! What a sweet sentiment! Apparently, this film's message is that the best way to get over a deceased loved one is to obey his posthumous advice to go shopping. And if you're really lucky, you may be rewarded by falling in love again--with a man who looks and sounds exactly like your dead husband!

Depressed? Shop!

As if the "Buy stuff!" solution wasn't insulting enough, this film takes ample opportunity to continually lower its portrayal of women. The script--adapted by two men, director Richard LaGravenese (remember Living Out Loud?) and Steven Rogers--also includes stuff about shoes, has Holly bringing her husband's urn with her to functions, features Swank channeling Judy Garland's "The Man That Got Away" from A Star is Born by singing into her remote control and tries to get Butler shirtless as much as possible (not that there's anything wrong with that, but just watch 300!). It all might work if it didn't feel like it was simply injected for the sake of appealing to its target audience: lonely single women.

At least it's not a hairbrush...

The story reaches a new level of shame when Holly and her gal pals head to Ireland, a trip arranged by her dead hubby. The trio decides to take a row boat out to the middle of a lake, and wacky antics ensue when they inadvertently catch a fish. Watch the gals shout, laugh and fall over as they try to do guy stuff! Then, when they lose their oars, watch them refuse to jump in the water to get them (the oars are really close, too), instead opting to mope in the boat, talk about cosmetics and scream for help, eventually being saved by two men. (I'd say "You can't even write something that clich├ęd!", but apparently someone did...)

Aww...women are helpless! How cute!

Even worse, the writing is lazy. You'll get two lines that try to use the word "leprechaun" to comedic effect (neither works). And if you needed another reminder that some men really can't write for women, we get two "hung" jokes...

Big Dick Joke 1:
Holly: "Do all Irish men sing?"
Gerry (in the middle of singing): "Only the really well-hung ones."

Big Dick Joke 2:
Gerry to Denise (in a letter from heaven): "I've got a few hot men lined up (for you)...I hear Ben Franklin is hung like a horse."

The film is doomed from the start: Gerry is dead by Scene 2 (his funeral), after the opening sequence in which the two lovebirds argue (and make up) in their apartment. It's a long scene that immediately shouts to our attention that Swank and Butler have zero chemistry together. They spend a lot of the time fighting over something stupid, and Holly comes across like she doesn't trust Gerry or truly love him all that much, an idea reinforced through some of the flashback scenes of the couple--making it impossible to buy into the film's conceit (and Holly's feelings) later. The opening scene feels rehearsed, a "cute fight" that Holly decides to take too seriously. The relationship feels fake from the beginning, and her behavior is scripted solely to make her feel guilty later.

We saw more skin in 300...

LaGravenese and Swank have teamed up before, in the far better Freedom Writers--a film also injected with saccharine, but sold it in a much more believable way. I have a heart, and I can enjoy schmaltz, sappiness and a good ol' chick flick as well as anyone (the scene where Holly calls Gerry's voicemail repeatedly just to hear his voice was one of the very few genuinely touching moments here), but not when it's this stupid. This isn't grounded anywhere near reality and has a weak script, leaving it up to the actors to try and rise above to pull it off--and they can't.

I'm glad Swank tried to take on a comedic role, but she can do far better than this. Bates feels equally staged in her performance, but it's Harry Connick Jr. who is simply horrendous. He plays Daniel, a worker in Patricia's bar. He has a crush on Holly, but always says the wrong thing (like pointing to Holly's urn and telling Gerry that it looks like he lost weight), which for some reason people in the story find funny. He sounds like he's doing bad stand up, rattling off self-deprecating monologues with incessant jokes that fall flat (lesbians! ha!), made worse by his awful delivery, a dull monotone that always sounds sarcastic and angry.

The urn: Don't leave home without it!

But falling into that so-bad-she's-almost-entertaining category is singer Nellie McKay as Holly's sister Ciara--there's absolutely ZERO believability that she and Swank could be related. I'm not sure what movie she's acting in, but she apparently thinks it's the 1920s, or that she's 12, or that she's part of The Little Rascals. Her lines have a super chirpy delivery, and every time she opens her mouth the film grinds to a halt. I quizzically wonder how on Earth she was cast...she reminds me of Dr. Nick on The Simpsons ("Hi everybody!"), only without the accent. Just check out her awkward, out-of-place delivery of the line "Hey guys! We're here!" at the 48-minute, 50-second mark, and you'll know what I mean. Amazon lists her music as a combo of lounge, shock comedy and "retro space age", which would make sense to me after watching this performance.

McKay stands out.

Butler actually does his best to infuse Gerry with energy and life, and makes him memorable. But it's hard to get over the creepy idea that he wanted to somehow control his wife's life and recovery after his death. It comes across as more spooky than sweet. Gershon isn't bad, but her character has nothing to do. The only saving grace here is Kudrow, who is responsible for the film's few laughs (okay, I also laughed at a well-placed punch line using the name of a Michael McDonald song, but that's it!). Kudrow also deserves better than this role, although I would have enjoyed seeing more of her relationship with Tom. He's played by Dean Winters, who you may recognize as Liz Lemon's ex on 30 Rock...I smiled hoping he would drift into his Beeper King salesman persona, to no avail.

P.S.--Hilary, I still love you!

Forever a friend...

The DVD

Video:
This flipper disc has both a 1.85:1 anamorphic widescreen transfer and a full-frame presentation. It has a decent look, but I was surprised at the lack of detail with the darker colors in many of the scenes, especially early in the film. The blacks lack any definition, and other dark colors blend in, creating a mass. There's also grain that's noticeable with skin tones in some scenes. Overall though, still a decent presentation.

Audio:
The Dolby 5.1 surround track works well, and is also available in French and Spanish, with optional subtitles in English, French and Spanish. There aren't a lot of remarkable sound effects here, but a few little touches add some nice atmosphere, and the dialogue is always crisp.

Extras:
First up is "A Conversation with Cecelia Ahern", a collection of interviews (7:26) with the author, as well as the cast and crew. Chiming in are producers Molly Smith and Wendy Finerman, writer/director Richard LaGravenese, and actors Swank and Butler. There's not much time for these people to provide anything too meaningful. Swank and Butler have very short segments; Swank notes that the film has a message to "hold those that you love near," apparently overlooking the fact that her character grows to seriously neglect her friends and ignores her godmother and maid of honor duties. Ahern gets the most time, and shares her ideas about creating the book. I haven't read the novel, but she wrote it when she was 21, and it doesn't appear that she went through a similar ordeal herself.

There are five additional scenes (12:34), including McKay hamming it up some more at Celia's one-woman show (look for Holly, sitting in the audience with her urn!); it has a few bloopers at the end of the scene. There's also an actually funny (albeit morbid) scene with Gerry feigning death twice as he books a trip for Holly.

Then there's the immensely annoying "The Name of the Game is Snaps" featurette (4:48), a faux old-time instructional video (in black and white with fake scratchy film) that explains one of the games that gets brief mention in the movie. It's a highly confusing and extremely un-fun looking endeavor involving snapping your fingers for vowels as you try to get someone to guess a phrase--made all the more excruciating by the cheesy performances of the actors playing Jim and Jane, your teachers. My head hurt watching this. I'd rather watch the feature three times in a row than sit through this five-minute exercise in torture again. (Please, make it go away...)

Rounding out the extras are a James Blunt music video for "Same Mistake" and trailers before the feature.

Final Thoughts:
I love Hilary Swank. I love Lisa Kudrow. I do not love this movie. Filled with scenes that aren't funny, aren't moving and seem to have an antiquated view of women, this film gets derailed in the first scene. But if the idea of a dead husband sending his wife letters from beyond the grave and instructing her how to live sounds fun, give it a go. Or just buy a knockout outfit and become your own disco diva. Skip it.

Other Reviews:
Popular Reviews
1. Criminal Minds: Season 9
2. Batman The Complete TV Series Limited Edition Blu-ray
3. The Expendables 3
4. L'avventura: Criterion Collection
5. It Happened One Night - The Criterion Collection
6. Sgt. Bilko - The Phil Silvers Show: The Complete Series
7. The Shooting / Ride in the Whirlwind: Criterion Collection
8. Corky (Warner Archive Collection)
9. 22 Jump Street
10. The Jeffersons - The Complete Series: The Dee-Luxe Edition


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use