DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
HD DVD / Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer
Search: For:
Reviews » Blu-ray Reviews » Stargate - Continuum (Blu-ray)
Stargate - Continuum (Blu-ray)
Fox // Unrated // July 29, 2008 // Region A
List Price: $39.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Don Houston | posted August 7, 2008 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly

Easy traveling through a wormhole.

Background: Stargate is the franchise built from a single movie, turned into a pay cable series, then a free cable series, into all sorts of spin off projects including an upcoming videogame. The concept was built on the many gods people around the world worshipping actually being alien visitors, most of whom enslaved our ancestors, that came here via a network of large rings that connected planets across vast distances in space. The rings linked stable wormholes and provided reliable transportation, the original movie showing a governmentally financed science project discovering how to use them. A military team is sent to explore, finds a powerful alien pretending to be a god, they kill him to free the local inhabitants, and all is well. The series spun it a bit broader and had a whole network of competing "System Lords" with ten seasons of the show Stargate SG-1 and four of Stargate Atlantis to show for it. The main series ended but spun off one direct to video movies earlier this year and coming up in a few weeks will be the second such movie, the subject of this review in Stargate: Continuum Blu-Ray.


The team!

Movie: Stargate: Continuum Blu-Ray is a relatively stand alone project that attempts to tie a lot of series history together, designed largely for fans over newcomers, and easier to follow than the recent Ark of Truth for those that haven't watched the show religiously (pun intended). The world is contemporary to our own and the space faring ways of our military are largely secret to the general population, the thought being that the public would panic if they knew how many times the program itself invited danger to Earth. In the years of the programs existence, we have made powerful enemies, powerful allies, and encountered a wide variety of sentient life forms that have alternately helped or hindered our progress; the program establishing principles of first contact and a code of conduct not completely alien to the Star Trek franchises Prime Directive. Based in the Cheyenne Mountain military base, the Stargate program has a number of small expeditionary teams, the lead of which is SG-1; the members changing over time as actors came and went. The current lineup of the team is made up of team leader Lt. Colonel Cameron Mitchell (Ben Browder), Colonel Samantha Carter (Amanda Tapping), Dr. Daniel Jackson (Michael Shanks), and Teal'c (Christopher Judge) with associate member Vala Mal Doran (Claudia Black), Using Mitchell's aggressive action style, Carter's scientific knowledge and intellect, Jackson's knowledge of societal dynamics and history, Teal's military prowess in battle, and Vala's thieving self interests, the team wins in almost every encounter over vastly superior numbers and technology using their combined abilities. Their plans always fall apart while executed but their resourcefulness is legendary and their on the fly ability to overcome adversity is the most standard thing about their group other than their refusal to leave a comrade behind.


Defiant Ba'al!

Continuum begins with the Tok'ra, an alien race similar to the series main adversary the Goa'uld that uses symbiotes, performing a criminal punishment on a hated foe, Ba'al (Cliff Simon), to remove his controlling symbiote. This will effectively kill the part of him responsible for mass carnage and terror, freeing his human host in a humane way. On hand are the team, a bunch of Tok'ra never seen before and General Jack O'Neil (Richard Dean Anderson; the former leader of the team), the boring ceremony resulting in Ba'al warning them all that this isn't over and hinting that the original Ba'al is still alive. Whether this version is the last clone or merely a lying original, they are content that his reign of terror is over, the last of the System Lords to be killed off or otherwise dealt with in an increasingly peaceful galaxy. There was no mention of the Ori, another invading alien race, so the specific place in the franchise timeline is not established but it strikes me that it is sometime after Ark and before Stargate Atlantis: Season 4 where Carter moves for a year, this not set in stone due to the manner in which the show is written (with plenty of loopholes in case the writers are caught by diligent fans).


1939


The long arctic walk complete with a sun.

Just as Ba'al is set to be punished, people start disappearing in plain sight, the evil despot laughing as he kills one last victim (see it for yourselves), and buildings start vanishing as though never there. The remaining team members rush to the Stargate and ends up in the icy hold of a freighter, the audience let on early as to the events that provided this event; Ba'al time traveling to re-write history. The team miraculously not all vanished in the process, the explanation that the vortex of the wormhole saving them falling flat considering Ba'al's first set of acts upon returning to the past. The team ends up in the Arctic Circle and are rescued by a conveniently placed team including a popular but cranky former member that knows nothing of their history together; the group separated and interrogated at length largely based on the fame of one member whose alternative time line version died a few years back in a hugely popularized tragedy.


The interrogation.


The armada!

The US government brings in an assortment of people the team claims to know who don't, of course, know them due to the paradoxes of time travel that fans have experienced before, leading to all of them being safely tucked away and warned what will happen if they try to contact one another. The trio warns that Ba'al will eventually strike at Earth and it is only a matter of time before the cover-up blows up in the face of those in charge. A lengthy portion of the movie deals with this dynamic, including the group getting used to their mundane lives for the "One Year Later" at which time, their prediction holds true. Needless to say, they have no means of putting things back in place until a series of coincidences give them a narrow opening to fight Ba'al's scheming ways, using a trick employed in the series at the very end.


RIP Don Davis!


Teal'c serves another.

As far as being able to enjoy the movie if you aren't an avid fan, I have my doubts since the movie so rapidly skims over major data needed to make sense of what is taking place. The story inconsistencies were enough to cause flame wars on all the usual fan websites (my first viewing counted twelve, subsequent viewings and listening to the commentary track yielded more) but as more of an homage to the series, it worked well enough to provide the equivalent of a double length episode in the middle of the pack in terms of quality. I'm sure some of the slavering fan boys will say anything to boost sales (it has been established that the success of this one and Ark could bring about more direct to video titles) and even as a lot of the later seasons chugged along in major need of new blood to revitalize the franchise (it had become too inbred on the creative side), this was about par for the course. I like the franchise enough to have watched all the episodes multiple times, keep up with Atlantis, and defend it against haters from time to time online but Continuum was barely worth a rating of Recommended for any fan of science fiction other than the devoted following. As my review is written for a general audience, the "must watch" nature of fellow fans is certainly not the case with those that have passed it up over the years; watch a few episodes in syndication if you have any doubts of your own.


The System Lords!


"They've found us!"

Picture: Stargate: Continuum (Blu-Ray) was presented in the usual 1.77:1 ratio widescreen color as shot by director Martin Wood for release on this high definition version in the AVC codec. The video bitrate was almost always hovering right around the 20 Mbps area (the back cover advertises it as having an average rate of 19.5), a modest but solid improvement over the standard definition release I reviewed awhile back. I saw no compression artifacts this time and the enhanced resolution also provided more accurate flesh tones, more dramatic effects (though they did not look as solidly upgraded), and a relative lack of video noise but the grain was still present, obviously part of the original master. Clocking in at 98:31 minutes, the movie looked better and I sure appreciated not having to see the watermark of the advance copy. The CGI effects still looked somewhat rushed but more in line with the last season or two of the show (though this was high definition and I saw those on cable so you can read between the lines). To sum it up, big fans of the series should drop the extra cash for the high definition version as that appears to be what the visual elements were geared toward.


Uneasy alliances!

Sound: The audio was presented in a 5.1 DTS HD Mastertrack in English at a sampling rate of 48 kHz and a variable bitrate that looked to be hovering around the 2.1 Mbps mark when I checked it, alternative tracks in Spanish, English, and French presented in 5.1 Dolby Digital Surround (all with optional subtitles in English and Spanish). The upgraded audio track certainly sounded better than the SD version, the bass thumping louder and tighter being one element jumping to my attention right away, the crispness of most dialogue sounding straight from post production dub rooms, and the ambient noises added in with some greater care. It was not on par with most high end blu-ray titles I've watched of late so much as a cleaned up version of a TV episode with just a hint of extra "ummph" but I appreciated it all the same.


"I'll cut the power to the tractor beam" sorry, wrong movie.

Extras: The best extra for me was the 22:35 minute long Behind the Scenes Making of Continuum feature. It was a nice balance of the human elements that went into the production with many of the principles giving some comments about what they were trying to do. The audio commentary by executive producer and writer Brad Wright as well as Director Martin Wood was okay but they were more into providing technical cheer leading than extended story commentary; delving into a few areas about things that did not work (I agreed with them in large part) and what they had wanted to do. There was also a 21:54 minute long feature called Stargate Goes to the Arctic that detailed the limited crew actually going to an arctic military base with cast members; the added expense seeming a waste to me since special effects could have saved a bunch to use elsewhere rather than the "look where we shot a few scenes" approach that seems almost like bragging rights. There was also a 9:19 minute long Layman's Guide to Time Travel by Astrophysicist Jaymie Matthews that gave a decent head's up about the paradoxes involved (too bad the producers didn't listen to him more). Some trailers rounded out the extras for those that care.

Final Thoughts: Stargate: Continuum Blu-Ray seemed to suffer from the same issues the series fell prey to since the show was taken over by the Sci-Fi Channel; budgets too low to support the ideas at hand being the biggest problem of all. The 1939 parts looked hopelessly fake, the CGI was years behind that expected of a feature movie (if you've seen low budget effects movies on the cable channel, you'll know what I mean), the Migs Vs. the attack ships fantasy, the "One Year Later" cheat, and the totally uncharacteristic manner in which Teal'c "converted to the cause" so readily were the most distressing. The acting was about average for the series and fans wanting one last go will find it worthwhile to check out but make no mistake, this should have been so much better that accepting it as a wonderful return to the series is about as far from the truth as could be. I'm not going to be one of the apologists blindly hawking the movie in hopes of another, better, release in the future; I expect the producers to give fans exactly what we deserve as loyal fans of the series (and nothing less). In all then, it was a pretty fair effort of the producers that will entertain you but I don't see this one making a lot of new fans as it should have done. The blu-ray upgraded version did look and sound better but they could not help the thematic issues of the story as written and I still think that this will be for fans of the show only, given the vast references of insider material that will leave newbies lost. While this seems like a marginal recommendation, it is not, the movie serving more to cap the ten year run of the show than to open the world up to others as the director seems to have wanted (for financial reasons).

Note: All pictures taken from SD version of the movie as screen captures from blu-ray version are not practical at this time (requiring legally questionable methods that I can't endorse).

Find the lowest price for 'Stargate - Continuum (Blu-ray)'
Popular Reviews
1. Pee-wee's Playhouse: The Complete Series
2. Gone With the Wind: 75th Anniversary Edition
3. Nightbreed: The Director's Cut
4. 24: Live Another Day
5. Jennifer
6. Penny Dreadful: The Complete First Season
7. Desperately Seeking Susan
8. Avalanche
9. Squirm
10. The First Power


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use