DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » Fantomas: Five Film Collection
Fantomas: Five Film Collection
Kino // Unrated // September 21, 2010
List Price: $34.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by John Sinnott | posted September 10, 2010 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly
The Movies:
 
Though most people reading this have never heard of the master criminal Fantômas, there was a time when the character was internationally known.  The star of a series of pulp novels, the character was created in 1911 by French writers Marcel Allain and Pierre Souvestre. The villain captured the imagination of the public and soon the pair had penned dozens of Fantômas novels.  Eventually there were Fantômas comic books, TV shows, and, of course, movies. 
 


In 1913, soon after the novels started, the French studio Gaumont bought the rights and pioneering director Louis Feuillade created a series of five feature films starring the dastardly villain.  Restored in 1998, these silent movies have just made it to region one thanks to Kino.  The entire serial of five movies has been released in a wonderful looking three DVD set that is a must-buy for fans of early cinema.
 
Since this is a serial, with one movie leading into the next, sometimes with cliffhanger endings, I'll give a brief synopsis of each one and then discuss the movies as a whole.
 
Fantômas in the Shadow of the Guillotine (1913 54 minutes):  The first movie introduces viewers to Fantômas, a wily criminal and a master of disguise.  He takes up with Lady Beltham and murders her husband and hides the body.  Investigating the disappearance of the nobleman, Inspector Juve along with his reporter friend Jérôme Fandor discover some clues that lead them to the body of the missing man and implicate a man named Gurn.  Gurn, none other than Fantômas in disguise, is quickly arrested, convicted, and sentenced to death.  But being on death row under heavy guard isn't enough to stoop the criminal genius.
 


Juve vs. Fantomas (1913 62 minutes):  A great film and the best in the series.  Astounded at Fantômas' escape, Inspector Juve becomes obsessed with capturing the criminal, especially after he robs all of the passengers in a train car and then crashes it (killing the people aboard) in order to hide the crime.  Filled with action and suspense, this chase through the French countryside has just the right touch of humor to make it a classic.
 
The Murderous Corpse (1913 90 minutes):  What a wonderful title for a movie.  This time a young man, Jacques Dollon, is framed for murder by Fantômas.  Dollon is arrested and processed, then locked in a cell where he mysteriously dies.  When his sister arrives at the police station to visit him, she's informed of his death, but when they take her to see the body, it has disappeared!  Who could not only kill a man in police custody, but also steal his body?  Why Fantômas of course.  Things get even stranger when a priceless necklace is stolen from a lady at a dress ball.  There's a fingerprint of the crook who took the jewels on the lady's neck, and when it's analyzed they find that it belongs to the dead Dollon.  More crimes occur, and all with Dollons fingerprints at the scene. 
 


Fantômas Vs. Fantômas (1914 60 minutes):  The press is skewering Juve because he's unable to capture Fantômas, and one reporter opines that the reason might be because Juve himself is really Fantômas.  The chief of police questions Juve and send him to prison where he languishes for much of the film.  Fandor, realizing that he'll be arrested next, takes off and tries to track down the real Fantômas so that he can free his friend.   Lady Beltham, still in league with Fantômas but now married again to a member of society, announces that she will host a huge costume party to raise money that will go to a reward for Fantômas' capture.  (This was Fantômas' idea in any case... she's still loyal though appalled by his criminal acts.)  Both the police and Fandor decide that the ball might be just the place to gather information about Fantômas.  Fandor dresses up as the master criminal and so does a police agent. A third person arrives dressed in Fantômas' black outfit and hood, the real Fantomas of course.  When two of the Fantômas' collide on the dance floor they step outside to settle the matter but only one will walk away.  (In a surprising move, the actual fight takes place off screen.  How many times have doppelgangers fought in the movies?  It's amazing that Feuillade didn't see the potential in the concept.)
   
The False Magistrate (1914 71 minutes):  More escapes, disguises, and astounding crimes in this adventure.  Fantômas is captured in Belgium and held in prison, but the officials won't let Juve take him back to France to stand trial for his crimes there.  Not to worry, Fantômas escapes this time with Juve's help (in an amazingly bizarre plan that has to be seen to be believed).  Once free, Fantômas travesl back to France where he kills and assumes the identify of a man. A man who is actually a judge.   
 
These films are very entertaining and have a strange surrealistic touch to them that is just wonderful.  I have to admit that if it had been a straight cop and robber series I would probably have grown bored, especially with the way the movies were filmed (more on that later.)  As it is, the weird movie logic that permeate these films adds a lot by both recalling back to a simpler time and by resulting in some wonderfully unusual scenes. 
 
A great example of this is when Juve overhears that Fantômas is planning on killing him on a particular night.  What does the inspector do?  He goes to bed as normal, but before he retires he dons a spiked vest and a pair of spiked arm bands.  It's the perfect defense if Fantômas is planning on killing him by putting a huge snake in his room, which is luckily what happens, but not so great of a defense if the villain was just going to shoot him. 
 


Another surrealistic element of these movies are the disguises that Fantômas (as well as Juve and Fandor) employs.  When he puts on a beard and wig Fantômas isn't just altering his appearance; he's actually becoming another person with associates, friends, and a job.  When Fantômas poses as a doctor, he has a residence and practice and is a respected member of the community where he's living.  When he puts on the guise of a businessman he goes to his office and calls in his secretary.  It's as if the act of putting on makeup not only changes ones appearance but also their lifestyle.
 
These movies also have some creative and macabre aspects that never would have flown past the censors in the US.  In one chapter Fantômas hides a body by plastering it inside of a wall.  When he wants the body discovered, he drives a nail in the wall and blood runs out.  In another chapter the criminal makes part of a disguise out of human skin.
 
As has been implied, Fantômas is not breaking the law to right injustices like Robin Hood or even a gentleman thief like Arsène Lupin.  He's more of a megalomaniacal mastermind, a precursor to the villains that James Bond finds himself pitted against.  Fantômas is willing to kill without remorse for the smallest reasons (which are sometimes absurd) and has a small army of criminals that are under him, ready to do his bidding even though he treats them horribly.  It's a wonderful touch that makes him seem larger than life, which he obviously is.
 


These are old pre-WWI movies that were created when the art of movie making was still in its infancy.  The grammar for telling a story on film was still evolving and seen today these movies seem static and stodgy.  In these films, the story is told with an unmoving camera set for a medium shot which are intercut occasionally with close ups (of objects.. rarely faces or reactions.)  It's as if the viewers are watching the story unfold by peering through a key hole.  It's very similar to watching a play, and it's easy to see how that style became the norm for a short while.
 
The scenes tend to go on for a long time too.  It's as if Feuillade wasn't sure how much he had to show to let viewers figure out what was going on.  In one scene, a man is being fingerprinted by the police, and they show all ten fingers being inked and printed. 
 
While these might put off some people who haven't seen a lot of silent movies, you quickly get used to the style, and that's part of the charm of these movies.  It's also interesting to see how much Feuillade does with this simple and basic formula.  There is one excellent scene where Fandor is trapped in a whicker basket.  He cuts his way out with a pocket knife, the whole act being shown on film (though the film was sped up a bit).  When he gets out, he wipes his brow and sits on the basket, relived to be free, only to find that he's in a room with a dead body.  It's quite a surprising sequence that works well even within the confines of this early style.  Having said that, I can't help wonder as what Feuillade would have done with these scripts if he had filmed them a decade later. 
 
The DVD:
 
Audio:
 
 I've been spoiled by recent releases of silent film.  At one time a score pieced together from a music catalog would be fine, but the scores by the Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra and Steven Horne have spoiled me.  The music accompanying these films comes from a music library and it sounds absolutely atrocious.  Just about everything that could be done incorrectly was.  There's heavy synthesizer music in parts, scratchy old recordings of people singing French songs in others, and though the music does change with the scenes it's generally inappropriate or way over the top.  In a scene were a man discovers an unconscious woman they chose blaring action music.  It sounds like the rebel alliance about to attack the Death Star at the end of Star Wars.  A stock broker sitting at his desk is greeted with ominous, pounding music.  The whole score was really atrocious.  It never allowed the viewer to get lost in the film.  It was a constant reminder that composed scores are worth the price.

The film has English intertitles are clear and easy to read.
 
Video:
 
These films were restored by Gaumont in 1998 and those materials were used for this collection and they look very good for films this old.  There are some scratches and dirt on the tinited prints and occasionally some decomposition will pop up or a marred frame, but generally the image is quite solid.  The level of detail is very good, and the contrast is fine.  There are some scenes where whites bloom just a little or where details are swallowed in a patch of black, but these films still look very good, even with these defects.
 
Extras:
 
Unfortunately this Kino version is missing some of the bonus material that was previously released with these films in Europe, but they make up for it with some nice exclusive material.  First, what's missing?  The UK R2 Artificial Eye release included a 23-minute featurette entitled Who is Fantômas? which is not included here.  If France, these films were accompanied by several galleries, readings from the original novels and a vintage interview with Fantômas co-creator Marcel Allain.  These last were undoubtedly in French, so it's not surprising that they weren't included.
 
This set starts out with two audio commentaries by film historian David Kalat on the first two films.  If you've heard his commentaries for the Mabuse films, you know what to expect:  an interesting and thorough discussion of the films and their place in history.  These were both great commentaries.  The first covered the films and in the second he dealt with the history of Fantômas and his influences on popular culture on both sides of the Atlantic.  Kalat came to the microphone with a full set of notes detailing every aspect of Fantômas and both tracks are well worth listening to.  While I did disagree with his interpretations of the facts on a couple of minor points that he makes, that made me enjoy the tracks even more because it caused me to examine some of the things that I believed.  It's always good to do that every once in a while. 
 
There are also a pair of Feuillade shorts on the first disc, The Nativity (1910) and The Dwarf (1912) which are great to have.  There's a ten-minute documentary on the director also:  Louis Feuillade:  Master of Many Forms.  (None of these apparently are included in the R2 releases.)
 
The extras are wrapped up an image gallery.  While I wish that the Fantômas featrurette would have been included as well, these extras are significantly better than the Artificial Eye extras.
 
Final Thoughts:
 
This is a wonderful set of films.  I really enjoyed Feuillade's Les Vampires, a serial about a criminal organization that he made after the Fantômas movies, and I've been wanted to see these ever since I first screened that later work.  The movies did not disappoint.  With a tinge of surrealism and some very macabre moments these movies about a master criminal are immensely enjoyable.  Highly recommended.
 

Popular Reviews
1. Nightbreed: The Director's Cut
2. Pee-wee's Playhouse: The Complete Series
3. 24: Live Another Day
4. Gone With the Wind: 75th Anniversary Edition
5. Nekromantik
6. Mad Men: the Final Season-Part 1
7. Jennifer
8. Medical Center: The Complete Fifth Season (Warner Archive Collection)
9. Snowpiercer
10. Squirm


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use