DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
HD DVD / Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer
Search: For:
Reviews » Blu-ray Reviews » Marmaduke (Blu-ray)
Marmaduke (Blu-ray)
Fox // PG // August 31, 2010 // Region A
List Price: $39.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Adam Tyner | posted August 31, 2010 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Skip It
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly
"I liked it when Marmaduke farted."
Hannah Dixon, age 8, on Marmaduke

Yeah, that's kind of the review right there.

Kids
Marmaduke, nooooo!
like doggies. Kids like things that fart. Kids definitely like computer-generated critters who talk and line-dance. That's pretty much the magic behind Marmaduke, an adaptation of a comic strip I didn't even know was still being published from the studio who brought you Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakuel and the Garfield flicks.

Marmaduke is the kind of movie you drop in the DVD player, mash the big button on the remote, and run away as quickly as your stubby little legs will take you. It's not a family movie: it's a kiddie flick. If you're a parent, you know the difference. If you're not a parent, then...wait, why are you reading this again? Anyway, if you haven't read the Marmaduke strip since Jimmy Carter was in office, it hasn't really changed all that much. Marmaduke's a dog. A big dog. He eats a lot. He...actually, that's pretty much it. One panel a day, every day, for 56 years, so that's somewhere around twenty thousand "it looks more like Marmaduke's walking him!" gags. If you're scratching your head wondering how someone could take that and drag it out into an hour-and-a-half movie, the answer's "high school".

See, Marmaduke is pretty much a high school comedy about a slacker teenager, only with...y'know, dogs. Keeping in mind that I don't remember the names of any of the not-an-animal characters, the story goes something like this: Marketing Exec Who Cares More About His Job Than His Family (Lee Pace) lands a ritzy new position out in sunny California. The family's really not all that jazzed about moving up stakes from Kansas to the O.C., which they really do call "The O.C." somewhere around 1,386 times throughout the course of the movie, but they love Dad, so they support him anyway. Not that there's all that much point in mentioning the rest of the family, but it includes Judy Greer as the mom who crinkles her nose whenever Marmaduke (voiced by a sleepwalking Owen Wilson) farts, the boy who doesn't really want to play soccer, the 13 year old girl who's
Marmaduke, nooooo!
hopelessly embarrassed by her dad, and an adorable rugrat who speaks in broken-toddler-English so the audience coos "awwww" with every "goo'bye, Mahmadook!" They're kind of just there to scowl with disapproval whenever the Workaholic Pop does too much Workaholic Pop stuff. The family kitty Carlos (who's only named "Carlos" so George Lopez could do the voice) gets more screentime than the rest of 'em combined.

Okay, so Workaholic Pop is toiling away as the new director of marketing for this organic dog food company in Los Angeles that gives him a $2.5 million house and a company car, and there's obviously kind of some pressure to deliver. His eccentric new boss (William H. Macy) is a doggie nut and asks Workaholic to meet him in the local dog park to ominously talk things over. That's where the high school part comes in. Marmaduke is introduced to all the different cliques at the park...cheerleaders, drama geeks, and all that...but the two big ones are the Mutts and the Pedigrees. Turns out Marmaduke's not a purebred Great Dane, so he's stuck with the dweeby outsiders, complete with the understatedly pretty girldoggie who's quietly in love with him (voiced by Emma Stone). Marmaduke's way too smitten with Jezebel (voiced by Fergie), a g-l-a-m-o-r-o-u-s collie with a terrible name, to pick up on that sort of thing. The pedigrees are a pretty exclusive club, and the slobbery alpha male who reins over 'em (voiced by Kiefer Sutherland) isn't taking any new applications. So, in between wreaking havoc in the family's McMansion and ramming William H. Macy in the balls over and over again, Marmaduke tries to get in tight with the pedigrees so he can make his move. 'Course, it's a high school movie at the end of the day, so Marmaduke alienates every last one of his friends, throws a party when the folks are away and trashes every square inch of the house, gets the girl, loses the girl when it comes out what a dirtbag he is, and then there are all sorts of moral messages about what's really important. Oh! And there's a
Marmaduke, nooooo!
surfing contest for dogs. Almost forgot about that. Cowabarka!

One of Marmaduke's first lines in the movie is "I know it's juvenile, but it's all I've got", and that pretty much sums up a movie this lazy and laughless. I mean, you know how a scratched record is about the most cliched, overused sound effect gag in the Big Book of Cliched, Overused Sound Effect Gags? Marmaduke belts out three record scratches, and that might be a record. The whole thing's bookended with Marmaduke farting in his owners' bed. I lost track of the number of pee jokes, but the highlight there for sure is one of the pedigrees whizzing in a guy's cup followed by a huge spit take. Admittedly, I'm not so much the target demographic, but not a single one of the clunky one-liners, goofy puns, or desperate pratfalls scattered around in Marmaduke manage to connect. For a flick aimed towards kids, it's surprisingly low-energy too. The movie clocks in at 86 minutes but drags on for what feels to be at least another half hour on top of that. Quite a few lines of dialogue are followed by a really long pause, and while that might make sense coming after a gag to wait till the kids in the audience are finished cracking up, there's a lot of dead air even with standard issue exposition. There's a lot of exposition too, with Marmaduke overexplaining everything he's doing even when he's in the middle of doing it. His jowls never really stop flapping. There are mostly pointless little subplots with the rest of the family, but they're forgettable
Marmaduke, nooooo!
characters, and their kinda-sorta-arcs are every bit as bland and unmemorable. Since older viewers might not be as impressed by such sparkling dialogue as "Marmaduke? More like Marmafake!" as the junior set, the screenplay awkwardly shoehorns in a bunch of really dated references to stuff like The O.C. (a lot), Almost Famous, Point Break, Baywatch, Wayne's World, Austin Powers, and "Who Let the Dogs Out?" What, was this written in 2003 or something? What's next? A crack about Tommy Dorsey's trombone?

Maybe you're thinking that Marmaduke is an easy target and that I'm a terrible, terrible person for picking on it. You wouldn't be wrong. Still, there are so many genuinely amazing films out there that appeal to the entire family. This, meanwhile, is a lazy cash-grab that panders to four year olds. The whole thing's really talky, slow moving, and obvious. It squanders an unbelievably talented cast. I mean, Sam Elliott? Lee Pace? Judy Greer? William H. Macy? That's more like the line-up for some brilliant indie comedy, not this sort of studio hackery. None of the actors really manage to infuse Marmaduke with any sort of kinetic energy either, with the whole thing kind of limping around lifelessly. Even the voices for the chatty animals seems to float disinterestedly above 'em...it's not done skillfully enough for you to escape into the idea that these critters really are talking to each other. Why does Marmaduke even exist? The very long running Beethoven franchise makes for better Marmaduke movies than this. If your kids are bugging you to pick up this Blu-ray disc, I won't try to talk you out of it or anything, but...yeah, you'll want to leave the room in a hurry. Marmaduke's low-rent, amateurish, and dim-witted, so my vote...? Skip It.


Video
Marmaduke is about as bright, vivid, and candy-colored as anything I've stumbled across on Blu-ray. The movie's fresh out of theaters too, so it kinda goes without saying that it's very sharp and detailed, and its black levels are really punchy to boot. The film stock this time around is a little grainier than usual, though, and it doesn't serve up quite the same level of fine detail that Blu-ray has spoiled me into expecting. Marmaduke still looks very nice in high-def, sure, but it does come across as a little cheaper than I waltzed in hoping to see. Think a really, really strong presentation of a Disney Channel Original Movie, maybe. There aren't any glaring flaws or anything to drag it all down, though. Really good but -- just because of the way it was shot -- not quite great.

Marmaduke is given plenty of room to stretch out on this dual layer Blu-ray disc, and its scope video is compressed with AVC.


Audio
Marmaduke's
Marmaduke, nooooo!
24-bit, 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack is lugging around a low-end about as massive as that Great Dane himself. (Wow, did I really just write that? I'm sorry.) Marmaduke knocking over everything in the house that's not nailed down, the thick, meaty thuds from all those pratfalls, and even a little G-funk...the subwoofer's given a pretty hefty workout. I'm kinda surprised the same doesn't carry over for the surround channels, though. The rears are dozing off for just about every last second of Marmaduke, to the point where it might as well be a straightahead stereo track. A few barks are tossed in the surrounds, and the rear channels also reinforce a woozy drug trip, chirping birds at the park, and waves crashing at the beach, but it's really, really tame. I don't remember spotting any pans or anything to the rears either...the whole multichannel thing comes across as kind of an afterthought. Marmaduke's dialogue is consistently discernable throughout, but it has a really canned quality to it...kinda clipped and edgy sounding at times too. It's a direct-to-video quality soundtrack with a meatier low-end.

Marmaduke also serves up Dolby Digital 5.1 dubs in Spanish, French, and Portuguese. Subtitles are offered in English (SDH), Spanish, Portuguese, Cantonese, and Mandarin.


Extras
Marmaduke is a BD Live-enabled disc, and there's one extra that's exclusively lurking around online. "The Fabulous Life of Hollywood Pets" (4 min.) can be downloaded at a higher quality or streamed. It spends a few minutes with the cast and producers gabbing about their own doggies: everything from Fergie's pair of dachsunds all the way to Marlon Wayans' labradoodle.

  • Puppy Marmaduke and Kitty Carlos: Home Movies (3 min.; HD): If you want to see a pint-sized Marmaduke and pretty kitty Carlos chase each other around, paw at ribbons, and become bestest friends -- complete with color commentary! -- then here you go.

  • Marmaduke Mayhem! (3 min.; HD): This gag reel piles on impromptu dancing, flubbed lines, mugging for the camera, and the pooches missing
    Marmaduke, nooooo!
    their marks. The highlight, though...? A couple of trainers darting into the frame to yank an entire slice of pizza out of a Great Dane's mouth.

  • Deleted Scenes (9 min.; HD): Marmaduke coughs up eight more scenes for its deleted scenes reel, including a peek at some of Marmaduke's dogmigos back home in Kansas, Marmaduke chatting up a pug thug in an SUV, a flashback to how Marmaduke wound up with such a goofy name, and Marmaduke flushing a remote control or something down the toilet and somehow killing all the power in the house (what?). There's also a lot more with the dog whisperer played by Little Britain's David Walliams.

  • Cowabarka! (5 min.; HD): As you could probably guess by the name, this featurette is all about the dogs hangin' twenty on the surf. It's fat-packed with tips and tricks to teach your own doggie to surf, how to acclimate them to the water, and all the training that goes into something like this.

  • Canine Casting (3 min.; mostly SD): This reel splices together footage of a bunch of puppies who were mulled over for casting, complete with some goofy fake direction delivered via voiceover.

  • Trailer (2 min.; HD): Last up on this Blu-ray disc is Marmaduke's life-redefining theatrical trailer. Clips for Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakuel and Percy Jackson are piled on here too.

The second disc in the set is a DVD of Marmaduke, so now you have something else to distract the kids in the minivan or whatever. There's not a digital copy this time around, which doesn't matter to me but seems kinda funny since the Blu-ray disc opens with a promo about how awesome digital copies are for family flicks like this.


The Final Word
Find the lowest price for 'Marmaduke (Blu-ray)'
Popular Reviews
1. Noah
2. Rio 2
3. Marty
4. Ong Bak Trilogy
5. Brannigan
6. Born Yesterday
7. Kid Cannabis
8. Orphan Black: Season 2
9. Forever Female
10. The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use