There's a lot that's wrong with Edwards Burns' Nice Guy Johnny, and we'll get to all of that, but for now, let's talk about what's right: Kerry Bishé. She's a new face to this reviewer (I guess she was on that new version of Scrubs that no one watched), but she's fantastic here--she's got a fresh-faced magnetism, outstanding timing, natural delivery, and she's sexy as all get out. Her role is old hat--the free-spirited hottie--but she doesn't play it like the chestnut that it is; her work is rooted in openness, and just a hint of good old-fashioned longing. She's got incredible ease on screen; the camera loves her, and by the end of the picture, the audience does too.
The film itself doesn't fare so well. It's the latest from Edward Burns, the onetime Sundance phenom (and occasional actor) who has seen his directorial efforts slowly slide out of even the arthouse consciousness. Watching Nice Guy Johnny, you start to understand why you didn't hear about his last three or four efforts; he's made no growth as a filmmaker. It has all of the same problems as The Brothers McMullen and She's the One--but they're less forgivable now, because he's not a novice anymore.
Matt Bush (best known as the guy who kept nut-punching Jesse Eisenberg in Adventureland) plays Johnny Rizzo, a would-be sports talk radio host, grinding it out on the overnight shift at a station in Oakland. His fiancée Claire (Anna Wood) is losing patience; he promised her a good-paying job by the time he turned 25, so he's heading back home to New York for the weekend to interview for a job her father has set up for him. Once there, he connects with his horndog uncle Terry (Burns), a free-wheeling bartender and ladies man who thinks his nephew is far too young to get married and settle down, so he spirits the kid off to the Hamptons for the weekend to help him "get some strange."
It doesn't work out like that, though; Johnny is a nice guy, and nice guys don't cheat on their fiancées, even when they meet a charming knockout like Brooke (Bishé). But they end up hanging out anyway, and then they start to like each other, and she of course thinks it's ridiculous for him to give up his radio dream, and there are misunderstandings and fights and confessions and so on, and everything happens pretty much exactly as anticipated.
The movie's biggest problem is Bush, about as unsteady a leading man as you can imagine--I'm not sure what Burns saw in this kid, but whatever it was, it doesn't come across on screen. First of all, he looks to be approximately 12 years old; Bishé towers over him, and their romantic scenes look, at first glance, like a hot babysitter throwing herself at the kid she's in charge of. Towards the end of the film, when he gets impatient with Terry, he bangs himself around in his seat like a five year old, whining "Can we go, I wanna go!" But his boyish looks aren't the only problem--his voice is a high-pitched squeak, rendering his already-unconvincing "on air" scenes entirely implausible. Has Burns ever listened to sports radio? Does he know a radio voice when he hears one? And does he know that they sound like they're speaking extemporaneously--as opposed to this guy, who is clearly reciting words Burns wrote in a script for him? Not to beat up on the poor guy, but seriously, if the radio scenes are bad, the movie's entire premise falls apart; we understand why Claire wants him to give up being a radio show host, because he's a terrible radio show host. She's the sensible one in that relationship.
But that's entirely by accident; the film paints the fiancée as a one-dimensional shrew with no redeeming qualities, which adds up to no suspense as to who Johnny's going to end up with. We can't imagine what they ever saw in each other, so we can't fathom what would keep him with her. Burns deals from a similarly loaded deck with the career business; the job her dad (a therapist) has lined up is the comically undesirable position of warehouse manager at a cardboard box facility. Seriously? Wouldn't Johnny's choices be more interesting if he were choosing between two different but desirable women? Or between a starter position in his preferred field, or a good job that just wasn't his dream job?
Burns, as always, is natural and charismatic, but his many, many dialogue scenes with Bush are all dead declaratives and forced banter--there's no rhythm to his writing, no pulse. Good actors (like him and Bishé) can make it work, but when an actor's not up to the task, watch out. Then again, these are the same problems his films have always had: pedestrian coverage and cutting, uneven performances (remember how badly Mike McGlone and Maxine Bahns stuck out from the rest of the solid performers in She's the One?), heavy reliance on music montages (some of these lyrics are laughably literal), and repetitive dialogue that gets some laughs but mostly sounds like first draft (if I had to hear about Johnny's dreams one more time, I would have screamed).
The film's low budget and shot-on-video roots are only obvious in daytime wide shots, which are somewhat blocky and chunky-looking. But as long as the picture stays in medium and close-ups (which, for most of the running time, it does), the transfer is smooth and attractive--skin tones are natural, saturation is good, and black levels are deep and inky. There are fleeting moments of instability and occasional pixilation, but for the most part, it's a good image--particularly considering the dollars on hand.
The English 5.1 track is pretty underwhelming; the dialogue-heavy mix is mostly concentrated in the center channel. But the moments of environmental sound (like the breaking waves during the beach bonfire scene) are barely present; surround channels are primarily used only to boost the music track. Dialogue is nice and clean, but there's not much more to the track than that.
English SDH and Spanish subtitles are also available.
The Audio Commentary by writer/director Ed Burns is engaging and informative--as with his previous tracks, Burns sees the listener as a bit of a co-conspirator, with whom he shares the secrets of working fast on a low budget.
The "Original Casting Footage" (3:28) shows Bush and Bishé auditioning together, in a clip that appears to have been compressed for RealVideo (it's really choppy). Also included are a pair of Teaser Trailers (3:53 total); an Extended Scene (4:18) from early in the film, expanding the first two-scene between Bush and Burns; and a pair of Burns/Bush Deleted Scenes (3:03), neither of which adds much.
Ultimately, with nothing much at stake, Nice Guy Johnny is not terribly funny and not really dramatic. Most scenes are greeted with stony silence, and it evaporates from the audience's memory the moment it's over. But I'm telling you: Kerry Bishé. Keep an eye on that one. She's gonna be a movie star.
Jason lives with his wife Rebekah and their daughter Lucy in New York. He holds an MA in Cultural Reporting and Criticism from NYU. He is film editor for Flavorwire and is a contributor to Salon, the Atlantic, and several other publications. His first book, Pulp Fiction: The Complete History of Quentin Tarantino's Masterpiece, was released last fall by Voyageur Press. He blogs at Fourth Row Center and is yet another critic with a Twitter feed.