ExcelSagaReview

Excel Saga is
undeniably one of the weirdest and wackiest
anime series ever made. That's a seriously bold claim and the absolute
reality
of what it feels like to watch this bizarre anime. It's even zanier
than one of
my personal all-time anime favorites: FLCL (Fooly Cooly).
Those
who have seen FLCL and have yet to experience Excel Saga
probably wonder
what exactly that means... It means that this is another anime unlike
anything
else seen before. Whoa! There might not be giant robots popping out of
kid's
heads (an FLCL reference) but there are spoofs for almost every
type of
anime around and the tone is all over the map (rather gloriously).
Funimation's
new reissue under the Anime Classics label presents the entire
26
episode run of seemingly random hilarity and quack-tastic fun for
newcomers to
discover this comedic favorite that has delighted dedicated anime fans
for
years.
The
series
jumps between pure comedy, action, sci-fi, fantasy, romance, horror,
and
several other genres almost every episode. The creator of the manga
appears on
the show in anime form to give the director and writers permission to
turn each
episode into another type of genre series or one-off blend with each
episode.
Excel is
the
lead character. In fact, almost every episode places a larger focus on
her
character than anyone else in the show. She is a teenage girl who acts
zany and
over-caffeinated regularly (if not constantly). She has a dog
named
Menchi who she frequently acts as if she wants to eat (as an emergency
food
supply of course) and the end credits even have Menchi singing a song
(translated by a woman unseen in the rest of the show) about how he
would like
to be eaten if it ever does indeed come to that. There is also this
character
named Hyatt who is always dying (or almost dying) or falling over and
acting
tired or seeming completely weak. She is a partner to Excel in (hey --
wait a
minute: fanboys need to get that idea out of those collective heads!)
helping
the evil mastermind ll Palazzo (who really seems to have little to no
idea on how
to do anything). ll Palazzo regularly has Excel and Hyatt doing
seemingly
random tasks for his secret organization named ACROSS, which is
apparently
supposed to take over the world. It just doesn't seem to be working out
that
way.

The show
also features a continuous storyline with a construction-worker named
Pedro who
works hard at his job for his "sexy wife" and kid. The entire series
takes a
slow and bizarre trip with following his rather unexpected journey and
all that
it entails. Rounding out the central characters are some goofy and
geeky guys
living in the apartment next to Excel. They have their own storylines
that
occasionally connect to Excel's but for the most part they seem to have
separate storylines.
These
characters are pure spoofs of classic anime archetypes. Excel is
ridiculously
hyper and surpasses the typical anime girl with intense energy by at
least a
mile. She can talk with lightning-fast speed. Hyatt is supposed to be
the more
frail, innocent, and natural beauty but instead of merely stumbling the
character dies all the time and has some genuinely questionable
behavior that
makes her a harder character to understand. This character truly helps
point
out the silly and unrealistic nature of these types of characters found
so
frequently in anime, and the results are some of the more outlandish
humor. The
guys are the typical bumbling geeks thrust into weird situations, but
unlike
most anime series they don't have an abundance of women falling in love
with
them head over heels.
The
series
feels like some strangely brewed concoction that mixes ridiculously
over the
top adult humor (think: Futurama, or that other Matt
Groening
series) with the more ridiculous stupidity and vulgarity of South
Park
or that one other show on Fox (if you watch animation, then you know
the show
that I'm vaguely referring to and am refusing to name specifically).
Consider
that weird reference without making an actual reference my own special
kind of Excel
Saga joke. Feel free to interpret!
Here is
a
unique anime series that at many points throughout the entire series
run makes
absolutely little to no attempts at actually being a logically sound
creation
with streamlined storytelling. Who needs logic when instead you can
kill off
the characters in an instant only to bring them back to life in a few
seconds
with a "restart" moment aiming for some pure comedic gold? This is only
one
example of a recurring joke in which the series propels itself towards
the
bizarre and unusual.

One of
the
possible charms and bizarre strengths of this series is an ability to
win
audiences over. Throughout several of the earliest episodes the
predicaments
and general nature of the humor seemed off-putting and disappointing to
some
small degree, but as this unique show progressed the wackiness became
almost
subliminally enjoyable and started to win me over. It wasn't that the
earliest
episodes were bad - in fact, there are some genuinely classic comedic
moments
towards the beginning but it wasn't as easy to recognize until a second
take
was given to try and better understand what was being watched. This
wasn't the
easiest show to become attached to quickly as it was unlike anything
I'd seen
before.
The
entire show
aims to poke fun at every cliché found in the countless and
rather amusing (if ridiculously
weird) anime series that most fans probably consider as perfectly
normal shows.
This is another reason why Excel Saga winds up being so
successful. It
essentially mocks anime but in a completely loving way (well... at least mostly).
Unlike more offensive comedic works - where the comedy seems almost
purposely
aiming to hurt fans this is one series that understands it's better to
play
along with fans who already know how silly some of their favorite
series are
rather than to be cruel and unfair in generalizing the surrealism which
is so
often found in this art form.
New (or
recent) anime fans who are still just getting started as viewers should
know
that much of the humor probably comes easier to viewers if there is an
abundance of familiarity with the many anime series styles that the
show
references throughout. Serious anime fans (those who have at least some
passing
familiarity with the various styles typically found in this art form)
will find
many reasons to laugh and embrace Excel Saga while other
viewers may be somewhat
baffled by how bizarre the show is and not understand why it's
perceived as a
comedy favorite.
With the
humorous and well-made Excel Saga the show-runners knows how to
pull
punches, and delivers them with giant smiley faces plastered
everywhere. It's
that kind of dedication to telling such a gleefully random story that
makes
this a series worth watching and that also makes it clear why this is
deserving
of an Anime Classics release.

The
DVD:
Video:
Excel
Saga looks
impressive on DVD with strong colors that tend
to pop and a notable level of detail and clarity. The show looks
remarkably
clean. Black levels are disappointing though and there are some moments
of
aliasing but this series looks relatively strong nonetheless. The
animation is
suitably represented with the release and the series is presented in
the
original broadcast aspect ratio of 1.33.1 (4:3) full-frame.
Audio:
The
audio aspect of this release is not as impressive as the video. It
would have
been nice to hear a 5.1 surround sound mix for the English language dub
but no option
is available. The series is presented in both English and Japanese
stereo. Both
tracks sound remarkably similar in clarity and detail (which is crisp
and
clear) so viewers will want to decide between the two tracks based upon
dub preference.
The English dub sounded poor in comparison to the Japanese dub as the
original voice
actors understand the humor of the series more and resort less to
simply making
loud obnoxious sounds (as frequently done in the English dub version).
English
subtitles are included.
Extras:
There
are a surprising number of extras featured on
this release. Unfortunately, most of the included extras are less
entertaining
than one would hope to discover. There are still some worthwhile
inclusions
though. The most notable extras are text interviews with Koshi
Rikdo
(Writer of the Manga) and Shinichi Watanabe (Director of the Anime).
They
provide some good insights into the creation of the original story and
how this
anime adaptation was formed. There are also some good (if relatively
short) insights
into their early careers. In referencing an element of the series, a Daitenzin
Commercial is included. A Video Piracy Warning is also
available on
this release with Excel Saga characters bringing the message. Standard
inclusions such as the Original Japanese Trailer, Japanese
TV Spots,
and CD Single and Soundtrack Spots archive promotional
materials. Puni Puni Poemy is the show director
Shinichi Watanabe began working on after Excel
Saga (and there is an actual tie between the series) so there is a
plethora
of short extras related to that show. Here is a list of those extras: Puni
Puni Poemy OVA Preview, Puni Puni Poemy Interview with Yumiko
Kobayashi,
Watanabe's Puni Puni Poemy Interview, Puni Puni Poemy Staff
Interview,
Puni Puni Poemy Character Designs, and Puni Puni Poemy
Latest Info.
Most of these are short promotional videos and they don't provide much
satisfaction. The Staff Interview sounded the most intriguing but it
was more
of a short comedic video and it barely highlighted staff discussing the
series
progression. Closing out the extras are clean opening and ending credits for
Excel Saga and
trailers for other Funimation
releases.
Final
Thoughts:
Excel
Saga is a
fun show that is worth seeking out for those
who think the premise of the show sounds intriguing: It's an
experimental anime
comedy that lovingly pokes fun at the art form and all the wacky series
and character
that exist in the medium. This is a show for knowledgeable anime fans
who are
looking for something a bit different and with plenty of humor. It's
not going
to appeal to everyone but for those who end up enjoying the show it's a
wild
blast of total randomness. Highly Recommended.
Neil Lumbard is a lifelong fan of cinema, and a student who aspires to make movies. He loves writing, and currently does in Texas.