DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » Medical Center: The Complete First Season
Medical Center: The Complete First Season
Warner Bros. // Unrated // July 12, 2011
List Price: $59.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Paul Mavis | posted August 21, 2011 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly

"Do you know Dr. Gannon?"
"Yes, I do."
"He grooves."

Dreamy Dr. Joe can crack my chest open anytime. In fact, he already did...when he first flashed those cold, cold baby blues at me. Warner Bros.' increasingly addictive Archive Collection, their exclusive on-line outlet for M.O.D. (manufactured on demand) discs of their library titles, has rescued from obscurity one of the best TV dramas from the 1970s: CBS's Medical Center. Starring heartthrobs Chad Everett and James Daly (you bet Daly was also a heartthrob―my granny would get the vapors whenever he adjusted his stethoscope), Medical Center: The Complete First Season is a six-disc, 26-episode collection of the popular, long-running medico show's premiere outing, and it's just what you'd expect from a network A-list series from that time period: beautifully written, performed and produced. No extras, unfortunately, for this terrific-looking series (the original TV pilot, U.M.C., starring Daly and Edward G. Robinson, and retitled Operation Heartbeat for release, is available separately from Warner's Archive Collection).

Los Angeles, California, 1969 B.O.C. (Before ObamaCare). At the state-of-the-art Medical Center, strapping, square-jawed, 100% insured-against-malpractice Dr. Joe Gannon (Chad Everett) strides through the pea green soup-colored halls like an Olympic god, dispensing pity bromides and lightning-fast scalpel incisions with eerie aplomb. In Room 447, there's a racist who doesn't like his black doctor. In Room 443, there's a blind girl whose hippie boyfriend cracked up his motorcycle. In Room 441, there's a U.N. Ambassador whose heart is about to vapor lock. And calmly, calmly, Dr. Joe moves from one room to the other, working slowly and carefully through his diagnosis before whipping out a number 10 Dermatome and striking like a cat, much to the consternation of flibbertigibbet parents, joy-boy scalpel jockeys, and administrators who don't know their catheters from their elbows. Usually offering backup is Chief of Staff Dr. Paul Lochner (James Daly), who knows Dr. Joe is the best surgeon around, who knows Dr. Joe is almost always right, and who knows Dr. Joe is certainly the best-dressed cat on his staff. That doesn't mean they don't scrap and spark a little over procedure, or over diagnoses; however, their relationship is basically sound: Dr. Joe gets the sighs from adoring female patients, and Dr. Paul has board meetings and drinks a lot of coffee. Into these halls come the sick, the broken, and the dying, and they leave...healed.

I couldn't resist being a little facetious in that synopsis, but truth be told, the serious-minded Medical Center doesn't really play like that at all. A never-miss favorite of mine when I was a kid, I chiefly remember two things from the series: first, I wanted to be Chad Everett (why not? He's perfect, for chrissakes), and second, goddammit if I wasn't always palpitating suspicious lumps I imagined all over my body because everyone seemed to come into Medical Center with a suspicious lump and sure enough, they wound up with some kind of tumor―shows like this scared the beejezzus out of me as a kid, and probably turned me into the hypochondriac I am today. Prior to greedily watching every minute of this first season on disc, I doubt I saw Medical Center since its original run over 40 years ago (did it ever go into syndication, because I never saw it in my market). I didn't remember any episodes from this go-around (I was only three when it premiered), but what did stick with me from later seasons was a heavyweight show that mixed glossy professionalism and literate writing (from the "Tiffany" network that invented such a combo) and this first collection of episodes was no different.

Watching the show today, I was impressed with the measured seriousness of the piece, and the episodes' consistent resistance to "ham up" the dramatics. On the contrary, unlike the recent review I wrote for the 1961 medical drama, The Interns ("hokey" incarnate, for the most part), Medical Center is remarkably straight-faced (for 1969) when it talks about sensitive medical subjects like abortion or V.D., achieving an admirable semi-documentary feel for the actual process the doctors go through to reach a diagnosis, followed by lengthy treatment (or at least as lengthy and "semi-documentary" as you can get in a big, expensive, glossy 50-minute network drama). Now, I must admit at this point that I was curious to see what others thought about this series (since I was enjoying it so much), so I had my wife watch some of it with me―she claimed she'd gladly get hit by a crosstown bus if Chad Everett would do the stitching, so she got kicked out―and I also scanned the net to see if I could find any contemporary reviews.

I won't mention any names (they've got this one gimmick...and they've been beating it into the ground for years...), but what I found was about what I expected: polite condescension mired in misreading. Singling out a 40+ year-old show for perceived errors in societal mores is always amusing (what you think is "correct" today, they'll be laughing at 40 years from now, too), while bemoaning the millennia-old dramatic construct of actually having a final act conflict before a resolution (how novel!), was funnier still. As for running down the pacing of Medical Center, that seems to miss the point of the show entirely...while also not understanding the fundamental appeal of vintage dramatic television. Granted, vintage television appears "slower" to viewers today whose attention spans demand entire scenes lasting no longer than 30 seconds. However, Medical Center's focus on the entire procedure of examining, diagnosing and treating a patient shows a willingness to involve the viewer in a lengthy process that produces the very drama inherent in those patients' illnesses, as well as the conflict that erupts from Dr. Joe's meticulous procedural methodology. No wonder the big medico hit of the "new" television era―the dubious, insufferably sanctimonious E.R.―was located in an emergency room: who has the patience anymore to watch Dr. Joe take days to achieve the proper diagnosis and treatment for a kidney patient? Let's watch a helicopter blow up instead, with blood squirting out of arteries while everyone runs around shouting and posing for moody sulks at the camera.

By 1969, the networks were fully aware that times were changing...even if they weren't going to go the route of motion pictures and abandon their strict code of self-censorship. So Medical Center wasn't afraid to push the limits when it came to subject matter (after all, it had to bring something new to its standard Dr. Kildare formula), but it did so in a calm, even-handed, "safe" manner that wouldn't offend the broad audience that tuned in. Vietnam is referenced several times in episodes (The Battle of Lily Wu specifically addresses it with a story about a returning Vietnamese refugee), with one brief mention of the turmoil roiling the nation (in Jeopardy, Joe answers, "Motive for violence? Lately, that's become as American as apple pie."), and with then-trendy generational misunderstandings―usually between fathers and their sons and daughters―highlighted, too. Pretty much everything is on the table here, including race relations (if you haven't seen vintage TV in awhile, you'll be taken aback at how casually "nigger" and "honky" were thrown around then), abortion, drug addiction, and unmarried pregnancy. And the feelings expressed here by Dr. Joe and his patients don't seem any different than what people are saying today. In The Deceived, Pat Hingle, excellent as always, gives a moving speech to his uncaring hippie daughter about patriotism and his chasing a buck after the Depression and WWII (all evils suitable for crucifixion to some hippie teens back in 1969...and some socialist pinkos today), while old pro Walter Pigeon has an equally touching speech in The Fallen Image, where he talks about getting older, and losing one's courage and drive (producer Al C. Ward wrote that screenplay). In A Life is Waiting, Dr. Joe laments the callous way his students dismiss an unborn life, putting Barbara Rush's dilemma over a therapeutic abortion as not one involving religion, but simply, life. And in The Crooked Circle, when whining junkie Tim Considine starts sniveling about the pressures in his life, Dr. Joe, who grew up poor and scratched to get anything he had, calls bullsh*t on the whole "victim of heredity/environment" nonsense: "Whatever happened to guts and self-reliance and responsibility?" he thunders. If you sensed that uniquely American combination of traits waning all the way back in 1969, Dr. Joe....

Those looking for lighter moments in Medical Center: The Complete First Season will delight in O.J. Simpson, in The Last Ten Yards, telling his wife, Miss Jane Pitman, "I'll kill you!"―just like he did to Nicole and Ron Goldman during their last night on earth (fair's fair: Simpson is actually low-key good here in a role tailor-made for him). Rabid fans of Dragnet's "Blue Boy" will enjoy seeing him date future CBS Saturday morning superstar, Isis (lucky bastard), while those who only have eyes for Chad will wilt at the sight of him in his safari jacket (his turtleneck matches his eyes), or watching him visiting the hippies with a daisy in his hand, or hearing him admitting he owns a Donovan record (he knows Donovan's last name, just to prove it), or listening to him telling a young patient, "A lot of groovy vitamins going into your veins," as he adjusts the drip, or simply watching him falling in love...with a dying woman

(Click here to see how quickly Dr. Joe's life goes from joyous to tragic!) .

As per an A-level effort from CBS at the time, the supporting players are all heavyweights: O.J. Simpson, Cicely Tyson, Edward Asner, Dana Elcar, Dyan Cannon, Robert Lansing, Gerald S. O'Loughlin (who's remarkable in Emergency in Ward E), Barbara Rush, John McMartin, Jayne Meadows (in a recurring role as snappish Nurse Chambers), France Nuyen, Harold J. Stone, Tim Considine, Corrine Camacho (in a recurring role as shrink Dr. Jeanne Bartlett, sometime love interest of Dr. Joe), Brooke Bundy, Michael Brandon, John Ericson, John Marley (excellent in a controlled performance), Lloyd Bochner (who gets the crap beaten out of him by "Blue Boy" himself, Michael Burns), Viveca Lindfors (who's lovely with Walter Pigeon), Linden Chiles, Lee Grant (always overdoing it...), Belinda Montgomery, Christopher Stone, Pat Hingle, Greg Mullavey, Carrie Snodgress, Inga Swenson, Tyne Daly (thanks, Dad!), Simon Oakland, Richard Thomas, Steve Ihnat (another great performance from this criminally neglected actor), Bruce Davison ("Tear 'em up!"), Martin Sheen, Mercedes McCambridge (love it when she's gobbling pills...), Cliff Potts, Shelby Grant (delicious), Forrest Tucker (in probably the best performance I've seen from him), Slim Pickens, Jo Ann Harris (doll), William Shatner (set to "9" and jumping around like a speed freak on a hot skillet), Carl Betz, Wendell Burton, the always great Tim O'Connor, Ben Murphy, David Cassidy, Georg Standford Brown (terrific, as usual), Will Geer (ditto), Sharon Farrell, Walter Koenig, and Tom Skerritt, right before M*A*S*H broke through. Whew! That's a supporting cast of players!

CBS wasn't screwing around when it came to slotting Medical Center in its Fall, 1969 schedule: they sandwiched it inbetween a group of up-and-comers and proven veterans. Settled in the sweet spot at 9:00pm on Wednesday nights, Medical Center's lead-off at 8:00pm was The Glen Campbell Goodtime Hour (the smash mid-season replacement series from January, 1969 that rocketed to 15th for that 1968-1969 season), once-king The Beverly Hillbillies (which would chart for the last time with a still-impressive 18th for this 1969-1970 season), with follow-up Hawaii Five-O in its sophomore season, benefiting from the schedule move, where it would chart an impressive 19th for the year―a solid night of family viewing. With no real direct competition from NBC's Kraft Music Hall one-offs, or ABC's Wednesday Night Movie (neither of which charted in the Nielsen Top Thirty), Medical Center handily won its time slot...but failed to rank in the Top Thirty, either, in this first go-around. That wouldn't be the case next year, when it would catapult into the Nielsen Top Ten...for it's only time.

The DVD:

The Video:
The full-screen, 1.33:1 color transfers for Medical Center: The Complete First Season look gorgeous, with rich, full color, a sharpish image, and only minor scratches and dirt. TV looked like the big-screen movies back then...I only wish I had grown up with a color set!

The Audio:
The Dolby Digital English mono audio track is another story. Re-recorded at a tinny, low volume, the fluctuating levels are hard on the dialogue. Close-captions and subtitles might have helped, but no-go on these Archive discs.

The Extras:
No extras.

Final Thoughts:
One of the 1970s best TV dramas plays just fine today. Medical Center: The Complete First Season features well-crafted, thought-provoking writing presented in a refreshingly serious-minded fashion, with Chad Everett and James Daly ably anchoring the excellent supporting casts. Some of the context may be necessarily dated...but the core is as relevant now as it was 40-some years ago. I'm highly, highly recommending Medical Center: The Complete First Season.


Paul Mavis is an internationally published film and television historian, a member of the Online Film Critics Society, and the author of The Espionage Filmography.

Popular Reviews
1. Fargo: Remastered Edition
2. Paranormal Activity: The Marked Ones
3. Criminal Minds: The Eighth Season
4. Little House on the Prairie - Season One & The Pilot Movie
5. King Kong Escapes
6. Star Trek: Enterprise - Season Four
7. Demons
8. Ride Along
9. Equus
10. Interior. Leather Bar.


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use