We all make mistakes sometimes. This review is one of mine. When Ghost Protocol was opening in theaters, I was distracted by my love for Spielberg's Tintin, and still grumbling about the tepid reception of Mission: Impossible III (my then-favorite) thanks to Tom Cruise's nationally televised meltdown just before that film's release. Watching Ghost Protocol again on Blu-Ray, so many of the nitpicks and complaints I had when I saw it in IMAX seem irrelevant; this is easily the best of the series thanks to the efforts of Cruise and director Brad Bird to continually up the ante.
After a short prologue, we're reunited with IMF agent Ethan Hunt (Cruise), lounging around in a Russian prison. Fellow agents Benji Dunn (Simon Pegg, returning from III) and Jane Carter (Paula Patton) show up and spring him in the hopes he can help them stop a man named Kurt Hendricks (Michael Nyqvist), code named Cobalt, a former government expert on nuclear war who eventually concluded that peace can never be achieved without a little fallout. Hunt and his team go to gather intelligence, but Hendricks is a step ahead, bombing the Kremlin and pinning it on Ethan's team. A few hours later, the entire IMF is disavowed, the US and Russia are at each other's throats, and the three agents are stranded in the field with an analyst named Brandt (Jeremy Renner), armed only with one cache of equipment and a one-chance, race-against-time opportunity to stop Hendricks from inciting World War III.
The strengths of the third film were pacing and stakes. Nothing like an explosive charge in the brain to generate tension. Still, as logical as it sounds to humanize and dimensionalize Ethan Hunt, the Mission: Impossible franchise doesn't really need nor is designed to sustain the amount of sentiment Abrams brought to the table. Bird pulls back, losing some of the personal stakes, but he gains tighter pacing and more action-oriented tension. Long associated with Pixar (where he directed The Incredibles), Bird clearly embraces the technique disclosed on the Toy Story commentary: give your protagonist an easy solution, and then remove it from the equation and force the characters to scramble for something better. The entire Dubai sequence (practically a third of the film), is peppered with great examples of this lesson in action, with the IMF's fancy gadgets failing one by one.
For all he throws aside, however, Bird is also wise to keep the rough-and-tumble realism of Abrams' film. Ghost Protocol is a long way from the ridiculous stunts of John Woo's entry, in years and in style. Ethan takes a hell of a beating in Ghost Protocol, allowing the movie to keep pace with both the gritty realism brought on by the Bourne franchise and Cruise's advancing age. As much as Cruise's delivery of Ethan Hunt remains unchanged, the wrinkles and weariness sit well on the character, particularly with the group responsibility on his back. It also helps that Bird's sequences are practical stunners, like a chase sequence through a sandstorm, a down-and-dirty fistfight inside a futuristic parking garage, and of course, the heavily advertised sequence with Cruise really dangling on the outside of the Burj. Although this Blu-Ray doesn't include the expanding aspect ratio of the IMAX sequences (a real shame), Bird's top-down view is more than enough to inspire instant vertigo. Bird is wise to hang on to Pegg, and brings out even more humor than Abrams, something the other Mission films don't always offer.
There are a few speedbumps. Nyqvist makes enough of an impression as Hendricks, but he's still hardly there; his right-hand man gets more screen time than he does. Worse, Bird and his screenwriters Appelbaum and Nemec have only taken away the sentimental material from Cruise in order to pile it onto Patton and Renner. Renner does a decent job of elevating cliche into something watchable, but Patton flat-out fumbles the emotional scenes, doing little more than grimace. Her character is also stuck being "the woman" -- she's the one who has to seduce a businessman (Anil Kapoor), she's the one who gets emotionally overwhelmed, and worst of all, she ends up in a distressingly gender-based rivalry with an assassin (Léa Seydoux), or at least, she chooses to play it that way. That said, Bird's choices make enough sense: slimming Nyqvist's role keeps the pace up, Patton has an excellent (and important) scene with Cruise she couldn't have without her character's backstory, and the Brandt material ends up shining in comparison to other action movies who would be satisfied with half of what Ghost Protocol ends up revealing in an overstuffed but pleasing epilogue. It's not perfect, but it's easily one of the year's best and smartest thrill rides.
DVDTalk has been sent a copy of the Best Buy Exclusive Blu-Ray of Ghost Protocol, which features an alternate (and, frankly, worse) image of Cruise on the Burj Khalifa than the standard 2-disc set on both the internal art and the embossed foil slipcover. The back cover is taken up almost entirely by logos and a banner for Digital Copy, leaving very little room for text summarizing the film and a list of the special features. The case is a single-width 3-disc with a flap tray, and there is an insert inside with a code to download a digital copy of the film.
The Video and Audio
This 1080p MPEG-4 AVC 2.35:1 widescreen presentation of the film is predictably flawless. On the Best Buy exclusive set, where the feature is allowed a disc all to itself, there's no expectation of any kind of compression issues, and there's not much else I would expect to stand in the way of a new release of a new film. Fine detail is incredible, allowing the viewer to see every line and wrinkle on Tom Cruise's face. Colors are bright and vivid, from the rich blues of the parking garage to the orange shades of the Dubai desert. I detected no edge enhancement, artifacts, digital noise reduction, or aliasing. A reference-quality transfer...although, I have to admit, again, that I would've liked it if the film opened up to the 1.78:1 aspect ratio for the IMAX sequences.
Although I don't have the equipment to decode the audio in full Dolby TrueHD 7.1, the sound is on par with the video. Every crunch and crack of glass during the final fight is crystal clear. The scene where Ethan and Benji infiltrate the Kremlin (which is mostly silent) is a wonderful example of the track's exceptional ambience and detail, picking up every quiet shuffle of the character's feet and providing a nice "deafening silence." The track also gets a chance to do the opposite during the sandstorm sequence, which whips and howls through the speakers with a detailed, realistic ferocity that is pretty much unrivaled. If I had one minor complaint, it would be that some of the music cues seemed much louder than the dialogue, but it's an insignificant nitpick, really. French, Spanish, and Portuguese Dolby Digital 5.1 tracks are also included, as well as English, French, Spanish, and Portuguese subtitles, and English captions for the deaf and hard of hearing.
This Best Buy Exclusive edition of Ghost Protocol boasts over an hour of additional content that the standard 2-disc edition doesn't include, and it's worth tracking this set down over the standard one for the extra material. The bonus material is divided into two major sections: "Mission Accepted" (47:35) and "Impossible Missions" (51:37). Most of the additional content appears in the latter. Both of these headings can be watched as if they were two documentaries via Play All options, or as individual featurettes ("Suiting Up in Prague" - 17:58, "Heating Up in Dubai" - 17:36, "Vancouver Fisticuffs" - 12:01; "The Russian Prison" - 11:49, "Shooting in IMAX" - 3:33, "Art Department" - 2:56, "A Roll of Film" - 2:33, "Life Masks" - 1:40, "Stepping Into the Storm" - 2:02, "The Sandstorm" - 3:06, "Dubai Car Crash" - 8:15, "Lens on the Burj" - 0:57, "Props" - 3:07 and "Composer" - 10:42). These featurettes, directed by a Giacchino (Michael's brother, perhaps?), are presented almost like a Picture-in-Picture commentary track, utilizing almost entirely B-roll and behind-the-scenes footage with the voices of Bird, Cruise, and other cast and crew members laid over it, without any on-screen interview segments. It's a very interesting approach, and makes these featurettes easy to watch. My only complaint? The music choices for these pieces is quite odd, giving it a slow pace and almost a tense or nervous feel. The way the featurettes are divided up also feels awkward; if we are to look at the first section as an overall documentary, it feels like it's missing the heart of filming, focusing only on the first few days of filming, the Burj Khalifa sequence, and the ending.
Deleted Scenes (15:02) include a few interesting tidbits. An alternate version of the post-jailbreak van conversation reveals the trials and tribulations of shooting an action movie -- what do the characters know, and when? It's interesting to look at this sequence and compare it to the one in the finished film, which plays so much better and must be the result of several people with their thinking caps on. Not surprisingly, there's some more of Hendricks here as well, including an extended, alternate scene where Hendricks picks up Leonid Lisenker that gives the audience more of an insight into his head. Interesting, but the film really is okay without it. I also really liked some of the details in an alternate plane scene between Patton and Cruise, some callbacks to which remain in the finished film. Brad Bird provides brief optional commentary on the deleted scenes explaining the reasons they were cut; it's a shame he doesn't comment on the entire film.
Two original theatrical trailers are also included. All of this footage is presented in HD.
In his live-action debut, Brad Bird effortlessly juggles the thrills of the first film and the best style and tone elements of the third into one highly entertaining stew that takes into account Tom Cruise's age, the hard-edged realism of many of today's action movies, and leavens the concoction with a strong sense of humor. Pair that with Best Buy's exclusive Blu-Ray edition (the only strike here being the omission of the IMAX version, especially when the set has a whole featurette about filming in IMAX) and you've got a package that is highly recommended.
Please check out my other DVDTalk DVD, Blu-Ray and theatrical reviews and/or follow me on Twitter.