Comedians are always better live. They tend to be
looser, more relaxed, and more likely to improvise and do bits of crowd
work when they know they aren't being taped for the judgment of millions.
Stand-up comics spend the better part of each year honing a new hour
of material; from that hour, they cull five minutes to polish for the
late night talk shows, should they receive those highly sought-after
calls. When it comes to putting together a stand-up special for Comedy
Central (or HBO, or Showtime) the pressure is even higher: we're not
talking about five minutes of fine-tuned setups, but a full 60 minutes.
The challenge for comedians who find themselves at this watershed moment
in their careers is to cram as many jokes into that set as possible,
while retaining whatever personal qualities of delivery (a.k.a., style)
that got them the gig in the first place. But rapid-fire performance
and maintaining a distinctive persona do not always mix well. Usually
the latter is sacrificed to preserve the former.
I've seen Matt Braunger live two or three times,
and he is fantastic. He is quick on his feet and has a disarmingly scattered
presence that adds a lot to his act. Braunger's strength is a seemingly-improvised
delivery that forgoes most of the usual stand-up "filler" lines
- things like, "You ever wonder...?" and "Here's something
strange..." But, within the tightly-compressed and timing-phobic confines
of the taped TV special, Braunger's delivery loses a bit of that vibe.
This is, of course, part and parcel of the understood limitations of
this particular format.
Braunger's special is a solid hour, even though
some of the bits seem tailored to appeal to the broadest audience possible.
An extended bit on vomiting while drunk isn't vintage Braunger -
it has its moments, but it isn't the kind of material I think of when
I think of his live shows. On the other hand, it's exactly the kind
of material I think of when I think of "Comedy Central stand-up."
Other segments are much stronger, and Braunger's consistently energetic
delivery keeps things light and speedy.
Image and Sound
This brand-new special looks great on DVD. The enhanced 1.78:1
image is crisp with surprisingly rich colors. Braunger's stage is
lit in sumptuous reds and golds, which look terrific here. The stereo
soundtrack replicates the ambience of the taping at New York's Gramercy
- Lonelyman Dinners
(1:45): These three fake commercials for "Lonelyman Dinners" feature
Braunger as the "lonely man" doomed to eat dinner alone.
- The Pitch
(2:06): A comic interpretation of Braunger's pitch for the special
to Comedy Central.
- The Making
of the Open (2:28): A brief look at the creation of the animated
opening credits for the special, with optional commentary by Braunger.
I am a strong supporter of stand-up comedy as an art
form, and I attend shows and interview comedians whenever possible.
The DVD is good if not exemplary stand-up, but Matt Braunger is well
worth seeing live. The DVD is fine, but be sureto seek him out next
time he's in your neck of the woods. Rent it.
Casey Burchby lives in Northern California: Twitter, Tumblr.