Richard Linklater's Bernie begins with an irresistible disclaimer: "What you're fixin' to see is a true story." It sets the table appropriately for the picture that follows, which has the inquisitiveness of a true crime story, but a documentarian's fascination with time and place. The setting is Carthage, a small town in East Texas, and in a wonderful early scene, a local resident explains how you should really think of Texas as five different states, including East Texas and the People's Republic of Austin--and that's not counting the panhandle, he explains, which nobody does.
A couple dozen locals appear in the film, which uses their documentary-style talking heads to introduce the characters and the location (which is like another character). Linklater mashes up those interviews with his recreated scenes, telling the story of Bernie Tiede (Jack Black), the probably-gay assistant funeral home director who became the companion of a rich, mean widow (Shirley MacLaine), but was driven by her cruelty to put four bullets into her. He then proceeded to cover up her death for nearly a year, while continuing to spend her money. When he was finally found out, the local district attorney, Danny Buck Davidson (Matthew McConaughey), had to petition for a change of trial venue--because he was worried no one in Carthage would convict good ol' Bernie.
It's no exaggeration to say that the picture hinges on Black's beautifully modulated comic performance. It's not a subtle piece of work, but it's believable; I've known men like this, and I'll bet you have too. He approaches caricature in his voice, his gait, his rolly-polly mustache, but he doesn't cross the line--Bernie is a high-energy character, sweet and infectiously good-natured, and there's something about the gusto with which he sings along to the gospel tune on his car radio early on that tells us most of what we need to know about the character. (For those interested in such things, the actor does more singing in this film than he has in any since Tenacious D: The Pick of Destiny.) Later on, in a key interrogation scene, Black invests in Bernie's humanity and still gets the big laugh provided by the script, which is no easy trick.
MacLaine is a welcome presence, though she's not given many notes to play here. The role is primarily one of grouchy antagonism, a slightly more mean-spirited version of her Ouisa in Steel Magnolias, but she does have one transcendent moment outside of that mold: when she listens to her Bernie sing, and for the first (and perhaps only) time, a big, happy smile spreads slowly across her face. McConaughey's performance is appropriately outsized; in an ill-fitting suit and big, terrible glasses, his skin the color of a honey-smoked ham, his is an ingeniously silly turn.
Linklater's always had a wry comic sensibility, and his direction here is like a motor, equally smooth on a purr or a rev. The interview scenes allow him to indulge a pure enjoyment of the regional patter ("her nose was held so high, she'd drown in a rainstorm"), and there are amusing little splashes of color here and there--I wouldn't dream of revealing the circumstances for the line "Straight to Dallas, and no stoppin' for coffee," but it gets one of the heartiest laughs in the picture. The filmmaker is negotiating a tricky line between comedy and drama (the crime itself is played straight--mostly), and he gets the mixture right, most of the time.
Video & Audio:
The MPEG-4 AVC-encoded transfer nicely captures director Linklater and cinematographer Dick Pope's warm, small-town color palate; it's a crisp and attractive image, and the saturation is just lovely. The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 mix is mostly center-channel--in fact, some opportunities for immersion are missed--but the dialogue is entirely clean and audible (even through those thick East Texas accents) and the numerous music and score cues are well modulated.
An English Stereo 2.0 track is also included, as are English SDH and Spanish subtitles.
Bonus features are a little slim; unfortunately, there is no Linklater commentary, and the featurettes are interesting but boilerplate. "Amazing Grace" (7:16) is an EPK-style look at Black's performance, with clips from the film, behind-the-scenes footage, and interview snippets with Black, MacLaine, director Linklater, and other collaborators. "True Story to Film" (9:27) looks at the tale's long evolution from a print story by Skip Hollandsworth to a feature film, via interviews with Hollandsworth, Linklater, Black, MacLaine, and McConaughey. "The Gossips" (12:59) picks up where the previous featurette leaves off, focusing on the filmmaker's decision to use real people for the doc-style interviews and showing clips from several of their initial audition tapes.
The Deleted Scenes (10:44 total) are mostly short and non-essential, though there are a few gems in there, as well as a slight extension to the ending that works rather well. The film's original Theatrical Trailer (2:09) and trailers for four more Millennium releases close out the bonus features.
Bernie runs out of gas a bit in the third act, as it begins to rely too heavily on its talking heads and gets bogged down in the conventions of the courtroom scenes and resolution. But if it overstays its welcome a bit, that's forgivable; it's still an entertainingly playful documentary/narrative hybrid, and finds a couple of our scrappier actors doing some vivid and interesting work.
Jason lives with his wife Rebekah and their two cats in New York and holds an MA in Cultural Reporting and Criticism from NYU. He is film editor for Flavorwire and is a contributor to Salon, the Atlantic, and several other publications. He blogs at Fourth Row Center and is yet another critic with a Twitter feed.