(Note: this review contains some minor spoilers; a thorough discussion of "Do the Right Thing" is all but impossible without talking about its controversial third act, which was described in full detail by most newspaper and television reports about the film when it was released twenty years ago. So I think I'm clear to talk about it, but if you haven't seen it and don't know how it ends, read on at your own risk, etc.)
Spike Lee was thirty-one years old when he made Do the Right Thing, but it was only his third feature film; his first, She's Gotta Have It, was an indie sensation, while its follow-up, School Daze, proved a profitable urban hit in spite of mishandling by Columbia Pictures. That film, and Do the Right Thing, were financed via the "negative pick-up" method--once the studio (this time, Universal) approved of the script, they agreed to finance and distribute the film, with the understanding that the director would stay within budget and basically shoot the script they had all agreed upon. The upside for the director was that this meant little to no studio interference during shooting, and the right to retain final cut. So the suits at Universal left Spike Lee alone, and he went off to paint his masterpiece.
And Do the Right Thing is just that: smart, nuanced, energetic, and entertaining, taking on giant issues on a miniature scale and with a sure hand. Set on one block in Bedford-Stuyvesant in the heart of Brooklyn almost entirely on a single day (the hottest day of the summer), its hub and focus is Sal's Famous Pizzeria, owned and operated by Sal (Danny Aiello), a gregarious Italian-American and father to Pino (John Turturro) and Vito (Richard Edson). They work in the pizzeria with him, along with Mookie (Lee), the delivery man and neighborhood crier.
In and out float a rich assortment of characters. There's Da Mayor (Ossie Davis), an older black gentleman who wants little more than to impart wisdom and enjoy a beer every now and again; his nickname is somewhat mocking, but he takes it seriously. Mother Sister (Ruby Dee) also keeps watch over the neighborhood from her stoop and front window--she and Da Mayor have an antagonistic relationship that hides real feelings. Mister Senor Love Daddy (Samuel L. Jackson, in one of his first roles), the disc jockey for WE-LOVE radio, broadcasts a running commentary from his windowed studio and provides the soundtrack for the block (and the film). That soundtrack is occasionally interrupted by the blasting boom box of Radio Raheem (Bill Nunn), who roams the streets like a panther, Public Enemy's "Fight the Power" the only song worthy of his speakers. Mentally challenged Smiley (Roger Guenveur Smith) walks around selling copies of the famous photo showing the only meeting of Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. Three middle-aged men (Paul Benjamin, Frankie Fasion, and the late, great Robin Harris) sit in lawn chairs on the corner and act as the film's Greek chorus (their patter and patois infuse a spirit of low burlesque comedy into the proceedings). And there's more, many, more: the girlfriend, the sister, the b-boys, the little kids, the cops, the Korean couple that owns the corner store, all there, all part of the tapestry.
And then there's Buggin' Out (Giancarlo Esposito), the rebel without a clue, who stumbles on a cause when he notices, for the first time, that the "Wall of Fame" in Sal's Pizzeria has no African-Americans on it (only iconic Italians). Sal and Buggin' Out do not see eye to eye on this point, and that minor disagreement, over the course of the long day, becomes about much more than pictures on a wall.
Watching that scene for the first time in several years, I was struck most by how much Aiello's brilliant work in the film has been taken for granted. Yes, he got an Academy Award nomination, but many saw that as an attempt to give the film some recognition (it was inexplicably shut out of the Best Picture and Best Director categories, though Lee's screenplay was nominated as well). But Aiello is superb--boisterous, earthy, natural, and believable. There's something just perfect in the texture of the pizzeria scenes, and in the way Aiello relates to his sons (and his employee) there. You buy his affection for the neighborhood and his pride when he notes that these people grew up eating his pizza, but he's also shown enough flashes of his temper that, when it gets the best of him at the film's end, it doesn't feel like a construct; it's heartbreaking and infuriating at the same time.
Lee juggles the rest of the large cast expertly. Turturro is spot-on in capturing the disgust and angry contradictions of the racist Pino, while Edson's more sympathetic Vito is engaging and casually funny. Davis and Dee are just plain marvelous; both effortlessly convey the weight of their characters' experience, and their off-screen marriage imbues their snippy encounters with just the right amount of subtle affection. The neighborhood kids are lively and fun to watch, though I'm not sure why Martin Lawrence (in his film debut) chose to play his character as if his tongue was swollen to twice its size. It's only in the female characters that Lee's screenplay fails him (as often happened early in his career)--aside from Mother Sister, they're pretty weak. Mookie's baby mama Tina (played by Rosie Perez in her film debut) is shrill and one-note (though some of that may be the actress), and the thin character of Mookie's sister Jade is given little flavor by Lee's real sister Joie (her weak performances were another ongoing issue in his early filmography).
There are a few other minor screenplay fumbles. Occasional scenes feel forced and overwritten, like Da Mayor's confrontation with Lawrence's crew or Radio Raheem's monologue explaining his four-finger LOVE and HATE rings (a too-winking homage to Night of the Hunter). Lee has an occasional tendency to signpost his dialogue; in this more sensitive screenplay, that's less of an issue with political views than it is with poor exposition (surely there's a better way to communicate Mookie and Jade's relationship than with a line as awkward as "Don't you love your brother Mookie?"). And while I appreciate his eleventh-hour decision not to have Mookie scream "Howard Beach" (an allusion to one of the recent episodes of New York racial violence that inspired the picture) before tossing that controversial trash can, playing a scene in front of graffiti reading "Tawana Told The Truth!" feels like he's stacking the deck; the film's strength is that it traffics in observation over judgment. And there is one moment of shockingly poor film technique, a walk-and-talk between Lee and Edson in which they start to talk before they walk (I'm not sure why this error wasn't fixed in editing).
But those are minor mistakes, and none detract from the overall punch of the picture. This is, by far, the most even, clean script Lee has yet written--it is episodic in nature, but it flows smoothly and effortlessly from scene to scene, building subtly to a cumulative effect. Lee says more than once in the bonus materials that this was the first time he really felt confident when making a movie, and that confidence shows; this is an assured, thrilling act of high-wire filmmaking, and he takes full advantage of the entire compliment of cinematic devices. There is the famous racial epitaphs sequence, in which characters deliver piercing inner monologues straight into a dollying camera; it's an ingenious way of moving bubbling subtext into the forefront. He uses montages throughout the film, but it never feels like lazy storytelling (as a montage can so easily be)--it's shading, adding to the feel, part of the fabric. And the climax concludes with one of the most effective cuts-to-black in all of film.
He also gets career-best work out of cinematographer Ernest Dickerson, whose images (full of tropical, fiery, vivid color) are lush and gorgeous. The film is pleasurable just to look at--the smooth camerawork, the knockout compositions, the jaunty dutch angles. But they're also not showing off; there's a quiet scene where Sal and Pino sit at a table in the pizzeria, in front of a large window, and talk plainly and simply to each other (you can hear the regret in Sal's voice when he asks his eldest son, "Why you got so much anger in you?"). There's no visual pyrotechnics here--it's done all in one, in a single, unbroken take that pushes in slowly and subtly on the two men.
That scene concludes with an unexpected and difficult altercation with passing Smiley, and underscores the film's other, perhaps most considerable strength: seldom have I seen a film that gives off such an impression of life happening outside the frame. So often, in disposable pictures, we can all but see the stars eyeing their off-screen trailers; Do the Right Thing was shot, interior and out, all on that one block in Bed-Stuy, and characters are constantly ambling through the backgrounds, passing through and engaging in offhanded interactions. Radio Raheem's boom-box battle with a group of Hispanic guys ends with a lovely boom up to a wide shot--and there's Da Mayor in the corner of the frame, grabbing a quick nap on a stoop. Smiley's always working the block, trying to sell his pictures (the character wasn't even in Lee's original screenplay; actor Smith lived nearby and kept coming to the set to try and work his way into more scenes). And it wasn't until this viewing, preceded by countless others, that I noticed Vito and Pino in the background of the fire hydrant scene, washing Sal's Caddy. Life is happening on this block; the camera is just trying to keep up.
But what is most remarkable about Do the Right Thing is how finely shaded each and every important character is, and how all of those shadings come into play by the time the film reaches its breathless conclusion. Any movie that can do that, and also contain as much warmth and humor and life as this one, deserves all of the accolades it has received, and then some.The Blu-ray Disc:
Do the Right Thing comes to us on a 50GB Blu-ray Disc, which thankfully allows room for both its surplus of extras and a first-rate VC-1 transfer. The 1.85:1 image beautifully captures Dickerson's bright, candy-colored photography, which utilizes warm and hot color tones to convey the burning heat of the sweltering summer day. There's an occasional speck of dirt here or there, but it looks considerably younger than its twenty years; black levels are deep and inky, contrast is excellent, and the image is clean and bright overall (I particularly loved the look of that fire-engine red wall behind the three corner men). Grain is good (if a bit heavy in a couple of shots late in the picture) and details are sharp--particularly in the slo-mo shot of Jade taking a cold shower and in Mookie and Tina's ice cube scene. This is a terrific transfer of a great-looking movie.Audio:
The English 5.1 DTS HD MA track starts off strong and never looks back; the iconic opening credit sequence pounds PE's "Fight the Power" in its entirety, and the full bass of the Bomb Squad's production is further complimented by the addition of Branford Marsalis' saxophone and the directional sound of choppers flying over. From that point on, Skip Lievsay's sound design is thick, dense, and layered, and this lossless track replicates it masterfully. The track is lively and atmospheric throughout, particularly at the climax, where the sounds of violence and unrest are sometimes disturbingly immersive. But my favorite audio moment of the film is Radio Raheem's boombox battle; the surround and LFE channels are used to marvelous effect in this wonderful, funny sequence. Bill Lee's score is occasionally mixed too hot and threatens to overwhelm the dialogue, but aside from that objection, this is an outstanding mix.Extras:
Collectors will be happy to hear that not only has Universal ported over nearly all of the bonus features from the excellent Criterion laserdisc and DVD (in fact, the only one that seems to be missing is the Lee-directed "Fight the Power" video), but they've added on some new material for this "20th Anniversary Edition". First up is "Do the Right Thing: 20 Years Later" (35:47), which was shot during an anniversary celebration at Lincoln Center. It alternates footage from a cast-and-crew Q&A with individual interviews (including Perez, Turturro, Edson, Dickerson, and Public Enemy's Chuck D). The interviews are something of a treat, because Lee conducts them himself; we hear his distinctive voice off-screen, hectoring and laughing. There's some funny back-and-forth between the director and Rosie Perez, and a nice homecoming vibe between Lee and Dickerson, who left the Lee company to direct his own films after Malcolm X ("That's what I liked about us working together," Dickerson says with a smile. "We tried shit"). Spike's participation in those interviews elevates what could have been a throwaway featurette into a must-see for fans of the director and this film.
Next are eleven Deleted and Extended Scenes (14:14 total), and apparently a lot of good stuff hit the floor in the interest of staying under two hours. All are worth a look (and presented in HD, albeit without any print cleanup). We get a longer version of Mookie's scene in Love Daddy's studio (he wants to find a Stevie Wonder record, and the DJ advises him to "look under the blind artists"), a few interesting additions to Sal and Mookie's final conversation, and a scene that ends with an unexpected, breathtaking rooftop shot that includes the New York skyline--and the twin towers of the World Trade Center.
"Behind the Scenes" (57:58) is a compilation of Hi-8 video shot during pre-production and shooting, giving us a homemade, handheld glimpse at the read-through, rehearsals, improvisations, discussions of characters with actors, and a big on-set block party. It's a little lengthy, but there's some great stuff in it. More professional, but equally compelling is the documentary "Making Do the Right Thing" (1:01:01). In a brief (:48) intro, Lee explains that it's not a "bullshit EPK thing," and he's a man of his word; this detailed doc (shot on film by St. Clarie Bourne) is absolutely fascinating. The 16mm cameras capture how the cast and crew took over the city block, cleaning it up and protecting their "set" (with security help from the Fruit of Islam). Renovation and set-building is seen, as are production meetings and rehearsals (the cameras capture an amazing moment between Aiello and Esposito). But Bourne's doc is also about the community--they talk to the people in the neighborhood (and not all of them are happy about the film's production), and the film provides valuable context about some of the incidents that inspired Lee's story. The segment also includes the "Back to Bed-Stuy" (4:49) add-on, in which Lee and line producer John Kilik return to the block, pointing out locations and reminiscing about the shoot.
Next up is an insightful interview with "Editor Barry Brown" (9:38), in which Lee's longtime collaborator talks about how they met and shares his thoughts on the film and how it was constructed. "The Riot Sequence" begins with another Lee intro (1:30), in which he explains that he usually doesn't use storyboards, but elected to for the complicated sequence at the end of the film; it then goes to a viewer-controlled storyboard gallery. "Cannes 1989" (42:22) captures Ossie Davis, Ruby Dee, Spike and Joie Lee, and Richard Edson at the film's Cannes Film Festival press conference--this one is also a little overlong, but still worth checking out. The film's original, skillful Theatrical Trailer (2:12) is also included, as are a pair of TV Spots (:31 each).
The Criterion Audio Commentary, featuring Spike and Joie Lee, Dickerson, and production designer Wynn Thomas (along with distinctive audio introductions by Chuck D) also returns; as with many Criterion tracks, the participants were recorded separately and edited together, resulting in a solid, continuous commentary that touches on the themes and also contains some good technical nuts-and-bolts information. New to this disc is a solo 20th Anniversary Commentary by Spike, going solo this time. His tracks are always engrossing (in spite of his irritating verbal tic of saying "ideal" when he means "idea"), and he adds some new info for this commentary. However, there is a good deal of overlap between the two tracks, and Lee does allow some longish pauses in the newer commentary.
The disc is also BD-Live enabled, and although trailers are available for multiple Universal TV, theatrical, and Blu-ray releases, there was no content specific to this film available as of this writing.Final Thoughts:
Twenty years after its release, Do the Right Thing has lost none of its considerable power; in fact, from this vantage point, it seems strangely prescient of the riots that followed the Rodney King verdict three years later. But it's not just a polemic--Spike Lee's film is sharp, juicy, and thrillingly alive, and it pops so good in high-def that I'm afraid even those who owned the (previously) definitive Criterion disc may have to spring for the double-dip.