"This is the DVD of Garry's show..."
At long last, the wait is over. Garry Shandling has been the star and driving force behind two of the most innovative comedies of the modern era, but for the last several years, neither show received the DVD treatment they deserved. His 1990s HBO series The Larry Sanders Show proved a non-starter on disc; we've seen only the first season thus far (though it's been released twice) and the well-produced but (of course) incomplete Not Just the Best of the Larry Sanders Show. (The idea that they're just sitting on the five remaining seasons while a full box set of the entire run of Full House is readily available boggles the mind.) But his earlier comedy "It's Garry Shandling's Show." remained MIA in any form... until now.
"It's Garry Shandling's Show.": The Complete Series collects all 72 episodes from the show's four seasons on Showtime (with re-runs later airing in the primetime line-up of the then-fledgling Fox network), and while it may not have been the most widely-seen comedy of the era (its stealthy audience was a frequent running joke on the show), it was certainly the most influential. The creative elements involved went on to become major players on several of the most critically praised (and frequently funny) shows of the years that followed, many of which share the show's hip, smart sensibility and humor: the aforementioned Larry Sanders Show, The Simpsons, Seinfeld, and Curb Your Enthusiasm, among others.
When "It's Garry Shandling's Show." began, television comedy was formulaic to a fault; sitcoms used the same tired template and the same clichéd conventions, relying on cute kids and pat situations and an unending cycle of flat set-ups and easy pay-offs. Shandling and co-creator Alan Zweibel made the show fresh and new primarily by reaching further back into the history of television comedy, with a show that mimicked the presentational storytelling and personal, character-based comedy of Jack Benny while utilizing the ingenious fourth-wall breaking of his contemporary George Burns.
Shandling plays "Garry Shandling" a neurotic comedian in his late 30s; the series begins with him moving into a new condo, where his neighbors include his "plutonic friend" (she's always referred to as such), Nancy (Molly Cheek); his best friend, nebbish family man Pete Schumaker (Michael Tucci); and Pete's son Grant (Scott Nemes) and wife Jackie (Bernadette Birkett). Garry's mother Ruth (Barbara Cason) is a frequent visitor, as is his condo president, the insufferable Leonard Smith (Paul Willson), who drops in whenever possible in a blatant bid for more air time on Garry's show.
While both George Burns and Garry Shandling break the fourth wall by talking to the audience and acknowledging the fact that they're on television (Burns would turn on the TV in his study to eavesdrop on scenes he wasn't in, an idea expanded by Shandling), the primary difference is in the show's overall self-awareness. Every character knows that they're on Garry's show and makes jokes to that effect, from little Grant making his first appearance at the end of an episode to complain scornfully, "Thanks for the big part in the show this week, Uncle Garry!" to Garry's mother doing a spontaneous live commercial on the air in order to drum up business for her pet shop. The show also makes ingenious use of its studio audience--Garry prompts them to join in to shout "surprise" at his mother's surprise party, hands out his winnings to them after a lottery jackpot, and, in a clever season three episode, takes the episode in a boring direction that prompts an audience walk-out. Perhaps the finest use of the studio audience comes in the second season episode "The Schumakers Go To Hollywood," where Pete and Grant go on a trip to Tinseltown and wind up in Garry's audience (Grant: "Hey, it's my room!").
Shandling and crew's love for old-school show business is clear in several ways, aside from the obvious links to older television shows; his guest stars (at least in early seasons) are more often along the lines of Norman Fell, June Lockhart, Norm Crosby, and Florence Henderson, almost invariably introduced with Garry's enthusiastic, "Hey everybody, it's (name of celebrity)!" That love for the lesser lights of show-biz reaches its pinnacle in the season one finale, "Force Boxman," which finds Garry leaving his show to front a cop series, leaving his show in the hands of Red Buttons. The new program ("It's Red Buttons' Show" ) is a hit, prompting Garry to return and beg for his old gig back ("We're finally on a hit show!" Leonard Smith tells him. "We're all gonna be famous!")
The show's construction is (often deceptively) simple: each episode begins with Garry's "opening monologue," where he comes out into his living room, tells some jokes, sets up the episode, and introduces the bouncy, impossibly catchy 41-second theme song ("This is theme to Garry's show/The opening theme to Garry's show/Garry called me up and asked if I would write his theme song..."). The plot then unfolds, often with commentary throughout by Shandling ("So here's what happening in the story now...") and clever time-passage gimmicks (in an early episode, fourteen newspapers are thrown at him during a transition; once they're done, he announces "Two weeks have passed!"). He'll then wrap the show up with a "closing monologue," which often sends up the moralizing of lesser sitcoms ("Well, I guess we learned something tonight.")
Generally speaking, the show's first two seasons are its best. Season one finds Shandling, Zweibel, and the talented writing staff tinkering with television conventions like a kid playing with a new toy, trying new ideas and generally seeing what they can get away with. On "Fate" (penned by future Men In Black screenwriter Ed Solomon), Garry tries to stop the show to prevent Nancy from going on a bad date; he tells the audience, "We'll stay here, we won't go to scene four," and then bides his time by putting on a square dancing instructional video. On "Garry Met a Girl Named Maria," Garry finds out that one of the studio cleaning women is about to be deported; he contemplates a green card marriage, and goes out into the audience to get their opinion (he carries a handheld microphone and turns the whole thing into a Donahue/Oprah spoof). Most memorably, on "The Morning After," Garry has to find out how his previous night's party went wrong with the use of his handy "flashback booth" ("Yeah, it's my flashback booth. Like you don't have one!").
The show really hits its stride in season two, with the rules established and characters entrenched, and Shandling and the writers pushing the envelope even further. The season kicks off with the so-called "Name the Schmacher Baby Contest," a real promotion in which viewers submitted names for Pete and Jackie's gestating baby. "Nancy Gets Amnesia" is also a highlight ("All right, our first amnesia show!"), giving Molly Cheek the rare opportunity to give Nancy some extra layers; Jennifer Tilly guests on the two-part "Angelica" show, as Garry's first real live-in girlfriend (the title and theme song change once she moves in); and the gang all pays a visit to "Shandling-Land," Garry's theme park (Grant: "Dad, am I old enough to go into Garry's Haunted Bedroom?"). The Christmas episode is quite funny ("Hey, everybody, it's Santa Claus!") and the "Save the Planet" episode--and its revelations about Garry's mom--is one of their silliest and most enjoyable.
But three episodes from this, the show's best season, stick out most. The second show of the season, "No Baby No Show," begins with Garry excited ("This is a very special episode!") because Jackie has agreed to give birth on the air. But when Jackie and Pete arrive and the baby isn't coming yet, Garry's stuck for what to do with the time; once neighbor Tom Petty arrives ("Hey, everybody, it's Tom Petty!"), it slowly, subtly, and brilliantly morphs into an incredibly awkward talk show (shades of Larry Sanders), complete with a song by Petty, plenty of plugs, couch scooching, and Susan Anton. Perhaps the ballsiest single show of the entire run is "Garry Falls Down A Hole," in which Garry misses his entrance because of, well, see the title; it begins on the empty set, and the first five minutes of the show is purely people wandering around looking for Garry, and the theme song playing (twice). It's a rather exceptional bit of meta-comedy, an example of the show taking its premise right up to the edge, and then leaping over gleefully.
For sheer enjoyment, however, it would be hard to top the "Mr. Smith Goes to Nam" episode, which features guest star Gilda Radner in her final TV appearance--and she's wonderful, stealing looks into the camera, shamelessly soaking the audience for applause, and generally having a great time. She was so gifted, and clearly had so much more to give, that the episode's only drawback is that it's kind of heartbreaking.
Season three finds the show refusing to rest on its laurels, puttering with its now-established format--starting the show in new locations, toying with the monologues, even sometimes (gasp) skipping the theme song, or playing it in new ways. It also includes the show's only live episode (special coverage of the 1988 presidential election--"We're live... because I don't have enough godddamn stress in my life..."--with the help of special correspondent Don Cornelius) and an all-musical episode, done specifically for the entertainment of their special guest, Los Angeles mayor Tom Bradley ("I don't know why he's here, he only likes musical theatre").
Gimmicks like a live show and a musical episode would come to serve as red flags for shows jumping the shark, and to be sure, there are some clunkers in season three. The three-part "Save Mr. Peck's" episode, in which Garry and his show-biz friends put on a benefit for the comedy club that gave him his start, is kind of a misfire; it parades out celebrities (and pseudo-celebrities) without finding much of anything interesting to do with them, aside from letting them do their acts. "The Natural," an episode-length spoof of the Robert Redford film, wasn't even timely when it first aired (four years after the film's release), and shows that the weakest "Shandling's Show" episodes are those that are most conventional--specifically (with the exception of the first season episode "The Graduate") those that dabble simply in straight-forward parody.
But there are also moments of brilliance (in the "Worry Wart" episode, Garry throws in a tape of a previous, unaired show, commenting and fast-forwarding throughout), and shades of things to come for Shandling. The "Big Brother" episode begins with Pete waking up Garry, who tells him, "It's six a.m. The audience isn't even here yet!" and sure enough, they're not--there's no laughs heard, and as Garry ends up wandering through the empty seats and reflecting on his own loneliness and neurosis, we get a glimpse of him moving towards the themes he would explore in greater depth--and with great success--on The Larry Sanders Show.
Most fans remember season four as the "girlfriend season," since it focused on his courtship and eventual marriage with Phoebe, played by Jessica Harper (who was immediately made a regular, which must have infuriated actors like Willson and Birkett who never made it, throughout the four seasons, into the opening credits). As an actor, Harper is likable as hell, but the trouble is that she's not very funny--even when they writer her some decent lines. The idea of shaking up the show by giving Garry a continued romantic interest wasn't a bad one, but Harper unfortunately doesn't prove quite strong enough to tackle it.
On the other hand, there are more appearances by the late, great Bruno Kirby, whose characterization of Gary's manager Brad Brillnick is a perfect synthesis of yes-man and snake. And there are plenty of truly funny episodes; Andy Griffith Show fans will love "The Day Howard Moved In," which features Jack Dodson as his Mayberry character, Howard Sprague, while "The Wedding Show" features a garish on-air wedding thrown by the network, complete with production numbers, dancers, and guest stars like Charles Nelson Reilly and Connie Stevens. "Shandling Vs. Mull," with uproarious guest-star turns by Martin Mull and Joy Behar, is killer, as are the episodes dealing with Garry's failed tour opening for Guns N Roses (specifically "Chester Gets a Show," a clever satire of what was then the norm for TV comedy). And "The Family Man," in which Gary and Phoebe take a home pregnancy test (the results take 23 minutes, "just enough time for a show") makes ingenious use of a new prop, Gary's "time flies clock," which sends him into the future.
Unfortunately, they rather muck things up towards the end; the episode titled "The Last Show" is, strangely, not the last show. It brings the series to a fine conclusion, with clever cameos by Dabney Coleman, Tony Danza, and Bob Newhart (whose own Newhart was signing off as well), a darkly funny funeral for Garry, and a hilarious Grant callback ("Thanks for the big part on your funeral show, Uncle Garry!"). But then, at the end of the episode, network head Mr. Stravely (Richard Fancy) appears, furious at the dark ending, and demands two more episodes, "and I don't care what they are!" The show's writers apparently didn't either. Shandling is nearly absent from the penultimate "The Talent Show" episode, and the few shows that focus on the supporting cast are always among the weakest (this is the primary difference between the two Shandling series; he had a flawless supporting cast on Larry Sanders, including Rip Torn, Jeffrey Tambor, Jeremy Piven, and Janeane Garafalo, but Willson is about the only truly memorable member of this show's ensemble). The final episode is another parody show, "Driving Miss Garry"--it's an awfully weak ending, and while the final moments are nice, they feel tacked-on, disconnected from the subpar episode that precedes them. (A listen to the commentary track confirms that it was, in fact, not intended to be the show closer.)
In its last two years, "It's Garry Shandling's Show." was still awfully funny, but became subtly less subversive and more conventional (as with the in-law shenanigans of "The Proposal"), less edgy and more goofy (as in the broad Hitchcock parodies of the "Nathan's Sheer Madness" episode). But in even its weakest episode there are moments of greatness, whether it's an inspired storytelling device (Gary's "dream hat"), a throwaway bit of business (Gary stops a scene to ask, "Can we use the camera angle into the mirror? I think the scene will play much more dramatic"), or a well-utilized guest star (when Carl Reiner finds that he's only getting "cold spaghetti and one little scene," he picks up a phone and announces, "Think I'll make some long distance phone calls!"). Some of the references are dated and some of the links in the supporting cast are weak, yes. But those flaws don't add up to much. "It's Garry Shandling's Show." was an innovator, and the best comedies of the intervening years owe much to it, both in terms of style and format (the influence on Seinfeld is particularly obvious, from the broad outlines down to several parallel characters: Nancy and Elaine, Pete and George, Leonard Smith and Newman, etc.). It was a series that showed how inventive TV comedy could be, as long as its creators were willing to think outside that square box.THE DVD:
"It's Garry Shandling's Show.": The Complete Series is a 16-disc set, with each of the four seasons taking up four discs, four to six episodes per disc. It comes housed in a thick, sturdy cardboard case, with a cover that pulls off to reveal eight plastic ThinPak cases (each holding two discs). Bonus features are spread out across all of the discs, and a 36-page booklet (with an episode guide, photos, quotes, and essays by Judd Apatow and the recently-departed Larry Gelbart) is also included.Video:
The show is presented in the 1.33:1 aspect ratio of its original Showtime airings, and the low budgets that were often (and hilariously) worked into the show were also apparent in the look of the series itself, which was shot on videotape. As with about any 1980s analog video, the picture quality doesn't hold up so well in our high-def digital age; we have all of the expected artifacts, including softness, light flickering, some smearing, and occasional comet trails. But saturation levels are fairly good, and the set isn't plagued with any of the compression issues of the first Larry Sanders set. It's not a particularly stellar video presentation, but fans of the show surely won't mind.Audio:
The audio is likewise underwhelming; the 2.0 stereo track is fairly thin and sometimes leans towards tinny. However, again, they presumably had only so much to work with, and while the audio may not blow you away, it is also refreshingly free of tape hiss, distortion, or the other issues that sometimes infect shows from this period.
There are no subtitles available.Extras:
The bonus features aren't quite as innovative or exhaustive as those on Not Just the Best of the Larry Sanders Show, but Shout Factory has still put together their usual stellar plate of extras. Eighteen episodes (about a quarter of the run) have Audio Commentary by various combinations of writers. Shandling and Zweibel comment on "The Day Garry Moved In," "The Graduate," and "No Baby, No Show," while they're joined by Tom Gammill and Max Pross for "Dial L For Laundry," "What's Happening To Me," "Worry Wart." Gammill and Pross also comment on "Mr. Sparks" and are joined by Ed Solomon for "The Schumakers Go To Hollywood" and Solomon and Shandling for "Goin' Places," while Solmon goes solo on "Fate." Al Jean and Michael Reiss chat through "Garry Acts Like A Moron" ("I'm relieved to not be doing a Simpsons commentary," Jean notes), "Firehose," and "Driving Miss Garry," and they're joined by Shandling for "Garry Goes Golfing" and "The Natural." Zweibel flies solo for "Family Man" and "Mr. Smith Goes to Nam." All of the commentaries are funny and insightful, though those that pair Shandling and Zweibel tend to be most entertaining; they talk in the featurettes about how well they worked off each other even in conversation, and you can hear that in their tracks. Zweibel's memories of Gilda on the "Mr. Smith" show are also well worth a listen.
Also spread across the discs are the show's outtake reels, "It Only Looks Easy," each attached to their corresponding episode and running anywhere from a minute or two to nearly ten. There is some great, funny material here--aside from the expected flubbed lines and crack-ups, there are some amusing technical glitches, with Shandling usually improvised amusing reactions (many of those mistakes actually made it to the final versions of the shows, when his ad-libs seemed part of the loose structure). We also get some wonderful outtakes from Gilda's episode, and terrific interplay with Martin Mull ("You can't tell when we're acting and we're not!" he notes to the audience. "That's the beauty of it!").
The real attraction, however, is the extensive retrospective featurettes. The first, at the end of season one, is "Getting There: The Road to the Show" (19:10). It intercuts interviews with Shandling and Zweibel about their backgrounds, how they arrived at the show, and how it all came together, supplemented with clips from earlier projects (including Shandling's first time guest-hosting The Tonight Show). Both men are funny and fascinating; perhaps the best section is Shandling's recollection of how he tried to pitch the show to NBC, but the future home of Seinfeld was sour on the idea of a sitcom centered on the life of a comedian (they also disliked him talking to camera, and suggested he talk to a dog instead). "Being There: The Cast Remembers" (26:03) intersperses clips from the show with the memories of most of the primary cast (save for the late Barbara Cason), while "Still There: The Writers and Crew Remember" (26:16) gathers up several of the writers and members of the staff, including director Thomas Schlamme (now best known as the frequent directorial collaborator of Aaron Sorkin). The final extended featurette, "Try To Remember: A Conversation with Gary and Alan" (19:47), puts the two men together for a chat about the show; some of the material is repeated from the commentaries and other featurettes, but it's still quite a bit of fun.
In "Getting There," Shandling talks about how his brief appearances on Michael Nesmith's short-lived but innovative 1985 summer series Television Parts led rather directly to the style of the show. Two of those clips are included: "Garry Dates Miss Maryland" (4:19) and "Garry Shandling's Car" (5:29). Both are more odd and off-balance than genuinely funny (and appear to be rough cuts, since they're missing music and sound effects), but show the Shandling persona in its embryonic state. Also included are several Original Promos (5:32 total), all for the run on Fox (or, as Shandling calls it in the promo, "the so-called Fox network").
"Show and Tell with Tom Gammill and Max Pross" (7:45) shows the two writers going through some of their old mementoes from the show, including several issues of "Shand-Lines," the show's official fan newsletter; several issues of that publication are included on the disc, with a viewer-controlled scrolling option. Finally, "Bruce Grayson: The Man Behind the Brush" (3:19) is a brief and funny interview with Grayson, the make-up artist for the show and Shandling's good friend; Shandling also pops in to share some laughs.FINAL THOUGHTS:
Though there is a noticeable drop in quality between first two seasons and the last two, "It's Garry Shandling's Show." more than earns its reputation as one of the great comedy shows of the modern era. The price tag for The Complete Series is a hefty one, but for those who are serious about their comedy, it is a must-have.