10 Things I Hate About You
Touchstone // PG-13 // $29.99 // January 5, 2010
Review by Adam Tyner | posted January 21, 2010
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
R E V I E W S
Graphical Version
[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]
Okay, maybe there aren't all that many movies crammed into the Shakespeare-centric Teen Relationship Comedy endcap at Blockbuster, but that sub-sub-sub-subgenre did produce two of the best teen flicks to divebomb into theaters in the wake of She's All That's colossal success. One of 'em is Get Over It!, which swirls around a performance of "A Midsummer Night's Dream" and worms some of Willy's work into the narrative as well. The other is...well, obviously 10 Things I Hate About You, since otherwise this whole introduction would be pretty pointless, right?

10 Things I Hate About You takes its cues from "The Taming of the Shrew", and if you say the title of the flick really, really quickly, it even kind of sounds the same. Try it! I'll even wait for you to finish. This is me waiting. Okay, with that out the way, 10 Things... opens with perennial new kid Cameron (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) mooning over the most deliriously gorgeous girl in school: Bianca Stratford (Larisa Oleynik). Bianca doesn't exactly come across as the sharpest crayon in the box, vapidly rambling on about stuff like how she likes her Sketchers but lo-o-o-o-oves her Prada backpack, but Cameron thinks there's something more substantial lurking underneath all that froth and frosting. 'Course, he'll have a tough time finding out. For one, there's Joey (Andrew Keegan) -- the resident Bee-Emm-Oh-See -- an overfunded, double-digit IQ male model who's been sniffing around Bianca for a while now. There's also the whole thing about the Stratford sisters' hyper-uptight pop (Larry Miller), an obstetrician who's up to his elbows in placentas all day as he helps teenaged pregnant moms squirt out their mistakes. Not so keen on his daughters winding up spreadeagle on his operating table, Poppa Stratford lays down the law: no dating till after graduation. After some begging and pleading, he does back off a bit. Bianca can date, sure...as long as her sister Kat (Julia Stiles) is hanging off some guy's arm too.

So, no problem, right? I mean, Cameron still has to weave his way around Joey and all, but how tough can it be to line up a date for a skinny blonde high schooler like Kat? Well, it'd be a pretty short flick if the answer were something like "not very". See, Kat's the shrew. Barely-pubescent boys aren't her thing so much: chili fries, whatever's at the top of the Billboard charts that week, a crappy movie, and some kid awkwardly trying to cop a feel...? Nah. She'd just as soon curl up with Sylvia Plath, blast a riot-grrrl CD, and keep her fingers crossed for that acceptance letter from Sarah Lawrence. She doesn't like you and doesn't miss a beat to let you know it. Her interest in dating is absolutely nil, and...well, dating kinda feels the same way about her.

C'mon, though!
[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]
Cameron's too smitten to give up now. For cryin' out loud, the guy learned French so he could tutor Bianca and have an excuse to spend some time in her general vicinity. Besides, throw enough cash and determination at a problem and you can knock down pretty much any hurdle. Cameron is kind of tapped out as far as financial backing goes, but he and his pal Michael (David Krumholtz) cook up the perfect scheme: dupe pretty boy Joey into paying someone to date Kat, let Jo-jo think he's going to be the one doing the dinner-and-a-movie-and... thing with Bianca, and then swoop in and steal her away. Joey's game, and he rustles up the only guy on campus ballsy enough to take a shot at Kat: Patrick Verona (Heath Ledger). This Aussie import has a heckuva rep, and if he can devour a live duck, bill and all, or spend a year in the klink after torching a state trooper, a date with Kat Stratford can't be that tough to pull off, right? Right?!?

I've always had a soft spot for that glut of teen comedies from the tailend of the '90s: Get Over It!, She's All That, Can't Hardly Wait, Whatever It Takes, Drive Me Crazy, and, like, eighteen other flicks with generic, three word titles. 10 Things I Hate About You has always been my favorite of that bunch, and it's one of the few I proudly love rather than chalking it up as a guilty pleasure. Even just over a decade after it dashed in and out of theaters, 10 Things I Hate About You still holds up impressively well. Okay, sure, sure, the core of the story is pretty standard issue, but it's everything the movie sketches in the margins that makes it so much fun. I mean, some of the first words in the entire flick are a guidance counseler -- played by Allison Janney, even! -- writing a trashy romance novel about the "throbbing member" of some musclebound guy who may or may not be a pirate. Poppa Stratford won't let Bianca trot out on a date without trying on a rubbery preggers suit. A hefty chunk of the dialogue is sparklingly witty, and 10 Things... frequently doesn't seem as if it's talking down to fifteen year olds either. I mean, lines like "you're 18; you don't know what you want...and you won't know what you want 'til you're 45, and even if you get it, you'll be too old to use it" are definitely in a different class than something yanked out of the She's All That playbook, and 10 Things... has one of the more compelling stack of adults out of all these movies. The screenplay is really tight, and I'm impressed by how quickly it screams along. Sometimes plot points seem a little rushed -- characters definitely leap to conclusions faster than they probably ought to, and a couple of supporting players like
[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]
Susan May Pratt don't get enough facetime -- but there's not a wasted moment anywhere in the entire movie. Geez, even the soundtrack is infectious, and along with all the licensed late-'90s-poppy-alt-rock, you also score live performances by Save Ferris and Letters to Cleo.

10 Things I Hate About You also piles together a really great cast. Larisa Oleynik is just about the most endlessly adorable girl the world over, and I like how the movie doesn't overplay Bianca hiding how sharp she really is. They don't pull out anything ridiculous like her turning out to be a master artist, an impossibly brilliant mind, or anything; Bianca's just a normal, bright girl rolling along in the part she thinks she's supposed to play. She's done some not-particularly-nice things as the reigning It Girl and is stuck having to deal with it. I've liked Joseph Gordon-Levitt and David Krumholtz in pretty much everything I've ever seen 'em in, and Andrew Keegan makes for one of the better Teen Movie Sleazy Bad Guys I've ever come across. Julia Stiles is a remarkably accomplished actress even in this very early stage in her career, and her emotional reading of the titular "10 Things..." list packs a surprising wallop. The mix of comedy with just a little bit of drama is extremely effective in the last act of 10 Things I Hate About You, both with that sonnet of Kat's along with some fatherly confessions by Larry Miller. 10 Things... also marks the arrival of Heath Ledger onto these shores. He's definitely a charmer as the bad-boy-turned-good lead, and the movie wouldn't be nearly as compelling as it is if not for the gleaming spark between Ledger and Stiles.

10 things I love about 10 Things I Hate About You...? Its effervescent wit. A really great cast. Characters with more dimension and personality than the usual paint-by-numbers teen movie crowd. I really dig the soundtrack. A clever mix of comedy and a smidgen of drama. A parade of adults who are even more off-beat than the gaggle of kids around 'em. Larisa Oleynik is so indescribably cute that she deserves her own bullet point. A breezy pace that never drags or meanders. Even with just over ten years in the rear view mirror, it still holds up really well. Am I at ten yet? I'm too lazy to count. Anyway, I'll 'fess up to being a teen movie connoisseur, and seeing as how 10 Things I Hate About You has always been by far my favorite of that bunch, it's kind of a thrill to have this tenth anniversary edition on a shiny new Blu-ray disc. I'd have slapped it with an even more giddily enthused recommendation if this disc had won me over as much as the movie has over the years, and I'll tear into all that in a bit. The short answer, though...? Recommended.


Video
"I know you can be overwhelmed, and you can be underwhelmed, but can you ever just be whelmed?"

Yeah, I guess "whelmed" sums it up well enough since 10 Things I Hate About You really doesn't look all that great in high-def. I wonder if Disney dusted off an older HD master for this Blu-ray disc rather than giving the movie a fresh pass through the telecine bay. The image is pretty soft, and although there's a decent sense of texture when the camera's closed in fairly tightly, clarity and detail never really impress. The usual atmospheric stuff like grassy lawns look kind of mushed together. The grain structure tends to be indistinct from a normal viewing distance, and...well, it just looks dated. At its worst -- the opening and closing titles; the paintball and paddling sequences as Kat and Pat fall for each other -- 10 Things... is soft and muddy, and its best moments don't rank much higher than "oh, that looks pretty good, I guess". It doesn't look shamefully bad, but the smart money says you won't be scraping your jaw off the floor or anything either. On the upside, 10 Things... has enough room to stretch that no hiccups in the compression ever sneak in, and there are only a few tiny flecks of dust that creep up.

10 Things I Hate About You is lightly letterboxed to preserve that theatrical aspect ratio of 1.85:1, and its AVC encode spans both layers of this BD-50 disc.


Audio
This
[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]
Blu-ray disc is lugging around a 24-bit, six-channel DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack, but it's kind of a mixed bag. Straight off the bat, though, the music sounds pretty amazing. Not only is the selection of songs a delirious amount of fun -- Madness, Save Ferris, Letters to Cleo, the less poppy side of The Cardigans, and Air, to rattle off a few -- but it's rendered remarkably well. Biggie's "Hypnotize" is packing the sort of low-end that rattles everything in the room, natch, but otherwise, bass response is impressively tight and punchy. The clarity, the distinctness in the instrumentation...it all really takes advantage of the extra headroom that Blu-ray has at its fingertips, and it just roars from every speaker. Reinforcing the music is just about all 10 Things... bothers to do with the surrounds, though. There's zero ambient color in the rear channels, even in bustling scenes that scream out for it like breezing through shop class with drills whirring from every direction or Cameron and Michael awkwardly making their way through a crowded dive bar. The one and only exception that grabbed my attention is an exercise band that zips from one end of the soundscape to the right rear speaker, but otherwise, it seems that if there's no music to blare, the surrounds are dead silent. Stereo separation across the front mains and the center is pretty strong, though. Also, the overwhelming majority of the film's dialogue is rendered cleanly and clearly throughout, with just a few scattered, shouted lines marred by some light clipping. This is a tough track to review because it fields some things exceptionally well, but for there to be essentially nothing but music in the surrounds...I can't help but wonder if something got lost somewhere down the line.

10 Things I Hate About You also sports Dolby Digital 5.1 dubs in French and Spanish along with a stereo track in, um, some language I couldn't actually decipher. Subtitles are served up in English (traditional and SDH), French, Spanish, Portuguese, Romanian, and four streams with symbols I'm too culturally limited to identify, I guess.


Extras
  • 10 Things I Love About 10 Things I Hate About You 10 Years Later (35 min.; partially HD): The flipside
    [click on the thumbnail to enlarge]
    of the case mentions a reel of deleted scenes, and there's a sticker on the front that boasts about Heath Ledger's original audition footage being tossed on as well. Those aren't offered up as individual extras, though; they're all pieced together as part of this half-hour retrospective. I was hoping for something more like the look back on Can't Hardly Wait; this one's oriented around some of the talent behind the scenes -- director Gil Junger and writers Kirsten Smith and Karen MucCullah Lutz -- and the only peeks we get of the cast are from decade-old EPK-style interviews and murky deleted scenes. Junger, Smith, and Lutz are all likeable enough, but their newly-recorded chats never really drew me in. They tackle the "10 things..." diary about a guy named Anthony that kickstarted the whole thing, drawing from Shakespeare, pretty much everyone involved diving headfirst into their first feature film, lining up the cast, and putting together all the music. Some of the most interesting notes -- Larisa Oleynik originally eyeing the role of Kat, lugging the 35mm cameras to Seattle to shoot in a sprawling-luxury-hotel-turned-high school, and Julia Stiles nailing the heartfelt "10 things..." sonnet in her first and only take -- are covered in the audio commentary too. Even with the deleted scenes, the vintage interviews with a ridiculously young looking cast, and Ledger's audition footage in here, it all just seems really cursory. It's okay but inessential.

  • Audio Commentary: The retrospective commentary track, on the other hand, makes up for it and then some. Writers Lutz and Smith pop up again, joined here by actors Andrew Keegan, David Krumholtz, Larisa Oleynik, and Susan May Pratt. It's giggly, hypercaffeinated, and just infectiously fun, generally focusing more about how much of a blast this half-battalion of young, wide-eyed first-timers had making the movie than anything else. Some of the highlights...? Krumholtz' stunt man diving in the path of a runaway motorcycle to stop it with his body, Heath Ledger's massive cologne stash, director Gil Junger redlining his Ferrari, the two co-writers gabbing about their first screenwriting collaboration with girls killing Navy SEALs with their bare hands, and 10 Things... inexplicably being blamed for school shootings. There's a little bit of discussion about the new TV series on ABC Family, and they do, of course, mourn the loss of Heath Ledger. The six of 'em are clearly having an unbelievable amount of fun reminiscing together, and even if it's not teeming with insight into the art of filmmaking or whatever, that energy and enthusiasm make this track about as much of a blast to listen to as I'm sure it was to record.
There are also high-def plugs for When in Rome, Extract, and Surrogate. Oh, and 10 Things I Hate About You comes packaged in a glossy, slightly embossed slipcase.


The Final Word
I hafta admit to feeling a little letdown by this Blu-ray disc, but for longtime fans of 10 Things I Hate About You, it's still an easy recommendation. This has always been my favorite from that glut of teen flicks from the late '90s, and thanks to some sharp writing and a terrific cast, 10 Things... still holds up ridiculously well more than a full decade later. A slicker transfer and maybe cramming more of the cast in the retrospectives would've scored a more enthused nod, but 10 Things I Hate About You is a movie that's definitely worth rediscovering on Blu-ray. Recommended.


No, Really, These Are Just Leftover Screengrabs; It's Not an Excuse to Keep Posting Pictures of Larisa Oleynik


Copyright 2014 Kleinman.com Inc. All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy DVDTalk.com is a Trademark of Kleinman.com Inc.