Tales from the Script
is documentary that consists solely of interviews with prominent (and
a couple of not-so-prominent) screenwriters exploring the triumphs and
tragedies of being a writer in Hollywood. The interviewees'
comments are cut together in thematic groups that cover everything from
making a pitch to working with superstars to the role of the writer
on a film set. This compendium of anecdotes and insight is an
excellent record of the writer's perspective on the film production
process, and will be an invaluable document for those considering any
kind of career in the movies.
Participants include Oscar-winners
William Goldman, David S. Ward, and Bruce Joel Rubin; writers who have
experienced huge commercial success such as Shane Black and John August;
independent writers of more personal material like Ron Shelton and Paul
Schrader; as well as writer-directors like John Carpenter and Frank
Almost each and every interviewee
in this documentary talks about the positive and the negative - the
dark and the light in screenwriting. Their experiences have almost
all been roller-coaster rides - and we're talking about some of
the most successful writers in the business. This was the most
surprising thing I learned from the documentary: that all of these writers
have had markedly similar experiences - although well-paid and having
a relatively good time, they all must confront the insurmountable frustrations
of studio executives, their "ideas," and the vast unpredictability
of the studios' decision-making process.
William Goldman expounds upon
his theory that, in the film business, no one really knows anything.
Paul Schrader explains why his Dutch Calvinism has gelled so well with
Martin Scorsese's Italian Catholicism. Ron Shelton claims that
all of his screenplays derive from his own personal background and interests.
Shane Black talks about early successes (Lethal
that left him blocked for several years thereafter. David Hayter
explains how he essentially fell into screenwriting while working on X-Men. Guinevere Turner pulls no punches
discussing Uwe Boll's hijacking of her screenplay for Bloodrayne; on that project, Turner wrote only
a single draft before it was accepted, heavily modified, and shot by
Although there is much to glean
from the documentary, especially for those interested in pursuing a
writing career, several of the interviewees (particularly Carpenter
and Goldman) are adamant about the unpredictability of it all - that
there are no hard and fast rules and that the ground is constantly shifting
beneath a writer's feet. A need to stay agile, motivated, and
informed seems to be one of the few substantial "rules" for Hollywood
writers - and a key to maintaining one's creativity and sanity.
Tales from the Script
was a parallel film and book project (see the above image), and First Run Features generously
sent a copy of the book along with the DVD screener. The book
is more thorough than the film, running about 350 pages. But the
whole is a straightforward, well-organized set of material. The
film alone is alternately inspiring and discouraging, although the discouraging
parts grow out of a sense of realism rather than being merely depressing.