Head writer/ exec producer Steven Moffat's sophomore season on Doctor Who is
finally available in a complete set.The
BBC previously released the Christmas special and the first half
of season six
(the second half was released concurrently with this set) but it's
good to have
the whole thing in one place.Moffat's first
season in charge of the show was brilliant (read my review here)
and while this one doesn't quite hit the heights that one did,
it's still
pretty good (and light years past any other SF show currently in
production.)The season starts out with
a cracking mystery
that last the whole season and ends with a clever twist that was
very satisfying.
(Warning: The first episode sets up the major plot
for this
season, and I'll reveal a spoiler that takes place in that
episode. If
you don't want to read it, skip down to the technical part.)
Amy and Rory are back on Earth enjoying married life without The
Doctor until a
mysterious blue card arrives. It has a time, date, and place
(the middle
of the American desert) listed on it, but nothing else. The
pair show up
to find River Song (who received a similar post card) and The
Doctor wearing a
cowboy hat. ("Stetsons are cool!")
The quartet go down to a lake and have a picnic, where the Doctor
lets it slip
that over 200 years have passed since he's last seen them, and
that their next
mission has to do with the Moon landing in 1969. Just then,
someone in a
60's era NASA space suit walks out of the lake. The Doctor
warns his
friends not to interfere, and walks down to greet the anomalous
being.
They talk for a minute then the person in the suit shoots The
Doctor
dead. He starts to regenerate but he's shot a second time
interrupting
the process. His friends rush to his aid (River unloading
her gun into
the back of the suit that's walking back into the lake) to find
him totally
dead (presumably) permanently. Just then an old man shows
up, bearing
another blue envelope, and gives the three grieving friends a can
of gasoline
before leaving. They burn the Doctor's body and retire to a
café to
figure out their next plan when they see a fourth blue envelope
lying on an
empty table. Out of the bathroom walks the Doctor and warmly
greets them
all. It turns out that this Doctor is 200 years younger than
the one who
was killed. In other words the Doctor will die, but not for
a while. (But
he will die on that date eventually... it's a fixed point in time,
one that can
not be altered.At
all.There's nothing
that can be done to stop the
events from happening without destroying the universe.)
Amy desperately wants to tell The Doctor what
happened, but
River forbids her. He can't learn anything about his own
future, since
that would set up a paradox. (If she tells him and he avoids
being
killed, Amy won't see him die. So she can't warn him.
Which will
lead to his death. Which means she'll warn
him....) Just who or
what was in that space suit and why did they want to kill The
Doctor?
Their only hint they have is The (older) Doctor's clue about going
back to 1969
and the NASA Moon landing. So off they go to 1969 where they
discover
something odd is happening... to President Nixon. With his
help, and that
of a discharged Fed, they start to unravel a complex story which
involves an
alien invasion of Earth that succeeded.It's just that no one remembered.
The rest of the season has River, Rory, and Amy
trying to
figure out just who killed The Doctor and why, all while keeping
the
information from him.The
Doctor has his
own worries however... It seems that Amy is pregnant, only she
isn't.The TARDIS
scanners show her both with child
and without.It's a
mystery that covers
the first half of the season and ends with one of the best Doctor episodes ever:A Good Man Goes to
War.In this
epic The Doctor discovers that an
enemy is trying to get to him through the people he loves... and
that makes him
very, very angry.To
combat this
organization The Doctor does something he's never done before:he calls in all the
favors that people (and
entire races) owe him.It's
a scary
thing to see just how much power he can wield if he chooses to.
The second half is interesting too, and it
mainly contains
stand-alone stories leading up to the climactic resolution of the
season, which
is witty, unpredictable (though they give you all the clues you
need), and very
satisfying.
Steven Moffat has always had interesting ideas, his crack in the
universe storyline
from last season was great, and he's come up with a few great
plotlines for
this season. The only problem is that the subplots are a bit
convoluted,
with different time-lines intersecting and a new creature "The
Flesh" that can
make exact duplicates of anybody, it can get a bit
confusing. They also
seem to drop the mystery of the person in the space suit for a
large part of
the season and focuses on other odd events. The stand alone
stories in
the second half are all a bit similar too.Night Terrors, The
Girl Who Waited,
and The God Complex all
seemed to be
variations on the same theme.The TARDIS
would land and strange events would take place:Large dolls would chase characters through rooms were all
of the furnishing
were made of wood; someone goes into a room and disappears after
the door
shuts; a hotel where the rooms constantly change and people just
drop
dead.While none of
these were horrible
episodes, watching them back to back got to be a bit repetative."Oh, another strange
world where nothing is
as it seems."
Okay, not that I'm done picking at nits, let me
mention that
there are some excellent adventures in this season with some great
monsters.The Silence
is a fantastic
race (yes, I know they're technically not a race...).Once you look away from
them, they disappear
from your memory so you don't know what they look like, or even
that they
exist.They are
insidious
creatures.I really
enjoyed the
swashbuckling stand-alone story The Curse
of the Black Spot which takes place on a pirate ship and
also has a unique
antagonist.The
Doctor also pays a visit
to Craig Owens (James Corden, who appeared in the episode The Lodger last season.That's the one where The Doctor rents a room while Amy
tries to land the
TARDIS) in a hilarious episode that involves Cybermen.(Viewers also discover
that The Doctor can
speak baby.)The
final episode is
amazing too, but there's little I can say without giving things
away.
One thing I really enjoyed about this season is
that they
wrapped up a lot of mysteries that have been mentioned in earlier
seasons.Just
who River Song is, how she learned to
fly the TARDIS better than The Doctor, and why she's in jail are
all explained,
though it does take some time.It's also
revealed just why the Doctor prefers human companions, and the
explanation
makes sense too.
When all is said and done, this was a great season with some
memorable episodes
and some great snappy dialog."No,
Colonel Manton, I want you to tell your men to run away."
The
DVD:
This season set contains fourteen episodes (all thirteen from season
six and last
year's Christmas Special) on six Blu-ray discs. Like the
previous
seasons, it comes in a book-like package with each disc getting
its own page.
Video:
Like the previous Doctor Who HD releases, this set comes
with a VC-1
encoded 1080i image which did look good overall. The level
of detail is
nice, and the colors are strong and vibrant. There is a
little banding,
but nothing too significant. Overall a nice looking set.
Audio:
The show comes with a DTS HD audio track that suited the show
well. There
is a lot of aural action in the show; the TARDIS taking off,
various battles
with monsters, etc., and those sequences were engulfing and
forceful.
There's a good amount of subwoofer action in some of the more
dynamic scenes
too. The dialog was crisp and clear and well placed in the
soundstage.
Overall I was very happy with the why this set
sounded.
Extras:
I was disappointed with the lack of extras on the half-season
release of this
sixth year of the reboot series, but the full-season set has a lot
of goodies,
most of which are found on the last Blu-ray disc.First off there are five
commentary tracks
for The Impossible
Astronaut, The
Doctor's Wife, The Rebel Flesh, A Good Man Goes ToWar and The
Wedding Of River
Song.I was
especially excited to
see that one of my favorite authors, Neil Gaiman, contributed a
track for his
story, The Doctor's Wife.There
were a
few dead spaces where the scribe didn't have much to say, but it
was a good
track never the less.There
are also 13
installments of Doctor Who
Confidential,
a wonderful look behind the scenes of each episode, and a special
hour-long
episode for A Christmas
Carol
special.
But wait, there's more!The set includes two funny Comic Relief sketches, Time and Space,
six
episode prequels that are required watching, over 40-minutes worth
of Monster Files that
look at the various
no-goodniks that the Doctor encounters and television promos for
series six.
My favorite bonus items however are the five Night and the
Doctor comedy shorts.They're clever and
funny and a very welcome addition to the set.There's even a Doctor
Who Confidential about their creation that's about
as long as all the shorts put together (15 minutes.)
Final Thoughts:
From start to finish this was a fun set that passed way too
quickly. Matt
Smith is still doing a great job as The Doctor and his companions,
Amy and
Rory, are wonderful too. The season's larger story was
really great, and
the resolution was highly satisfactory.This season set comes Highly
Recommended.
Copyright 2013 Kleinman.com Inc. All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy
DVDTalk.com is a Trademark of Kleinman.com Inc.