DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns





not all great DVDs are in 5.1

Silent DVD Archive


Gay-themed Films of the Silent Era
A column on the world of early cinema by DVDTalk reviewer John Sinnott

In this Thankgiving week installment of Silent DVD, I'll be looking at three little seen movies that Kino is slated to release next month.  Their Gay-themed Films of the Silent Era series presents a trio of films that look at alternative lifestyles, and how that was treated at the begining of the last century.

A little bit of a shorter intro this time around, since I have a house full of guests.  Next week I'll have a look at The Buster Keaton Collection, a set of Keaton's first three films for MGM.  These include his last silent films along with his first talkie.  Until then, here's hoping that everyone has a safe and happy holiday.
 
 

Upcoming Silent Moves on DVD
Updated (11-14-2004)
Title (* denotes new additions) Studio Release Date  MSRP   Buy at Amazon
Legong: Dance of the Virgins (1935)  Milestone November 16, 2004 29.95
King of Kings  Criterion December 7, 2004 39.95
TCM Archives:  Buster Keaton Collection  Warner  December 7, 2004  39.95
Michael by Carl Theodor Dreyer  Kino December 14, 2004 29.95
*Different from the Others  Kino December 14, 2004 29.95
*Sex in Chains  Kino December 14, 2004 29.95
Edison:  The Invention of the Movies (4 DVD set with over 140 early Edison films) Kino February 2, 2005 99.95 (not yet listed)
Hindle Wakes (1927) Milestone February 8, 2005 TBA (not yet listed)
Through the Back Door (1921) w/Cinderella (1915) both staring Mary Pickford  Milestone  Febuary 8, 2005 TBA (not yet listed)
Little Lord Fauntleroy (1921) w/Mary Pickford Milestone March 1, 2005 TBA (not yet listed)
Piccadilly (1929) w/Anna May Wong Milestone  March 2005 TBA (not yet listed)
Heart oí the Hills (1919) and  M'Liss (1918) both w/Mary Pickford Milestone May 2005 TBA (not yet listed)
Suds (1920) and Birth of a Legend (1966)  featuring Mary Pickford Milestone May 2005 TBA (not yet listed)
Dragon Painter (1919) w/ The Wrath of the Gods (1914) w/ Sessue Hayakawa Milestone  2005 TBA (not yet listed)
Forgotten Films of Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle  Laughsmith Entertainment 2005 TBA (not yet listed)
Poor Little Rich Girl (1917) Maurice Tourneur film staring Mary Pickford along with the 1978 documentary on Pickford, Americaís Sweetheart. Milestone 2005 TBA (not yet listed)

 
 
Recently Released Silent Movies on DVD
Title (with link to review) Studio Releasae Date MSRP Buy at Amazon
Stan Laurel Collection Kino August 17, 2004 39.95
Charley Chase Collection  Kino August 17, 2004 29.95
Harold Lloyd Collection Kino August 17, 2004 29.95
Fractured Flickers - The Complete Collection  VCI  August 31, 2004  39.95
More Treasures from American Film Archives 1894-1931  Image September 7, 2004  79.95
The Parson's Widow Image September 21, 2004  24.95
Dr. Jekyll And Mr. Hyde  Kino October 5, 2004 19.95
Fritz Lang Epic Collection (Metropolis/Die Nibelungen/Woman in the Moon/Spies) Kino November 9, 2004 99.95

 

Gay-themed Films of the Silent Era


Kino video has released a trio of silent films under the banner of  ďGay-themed Films of the Silent Era.Ē  When thinking about movies made in Germany during the Weimar Republic, those with a homosexual content donít generally spring to mind.  However Kino has been able to illustrate that a wider variety of films were made at this time than Iíd previously thought.  The three films, sold separately, are Different from the Others (1919) staring Conrad Veidt (The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari,) Michael (1924) directed by Carl Theodor Dreyer, and Sex in Chains (1928) directed and staring William Dieterle (Faust, The Devil and Daniel Webster.)  While none of these films can be considered masterpieces, all three present an interesting look at homosexuality in the early part of the last century.

Different From the Others


Different from the Others is the earliest entry in this series.  In fact, it is the first film to depict homosexual activity in a positive light, and it discusses the issue in a very frank and straight forward fashion.  The movie is a rally against Paragraph 175 of the German Penal Code which made homosexuality between men against the law.

This film has an interesting history behind it.  Paragraph 175 had been a source of contention for a number of years.  Dr. Magnus Hirschfeld, a German sexologist and scholar, thought that homosexuals were actually a ďthird sex,Ē and they were just acting on their nature.    During WWI, Hirschfeld teamed up with director Richard Oswald to produce a series of films on sexual education.  They filmed stories on prostitution, VD and the like.  After the war the censor restrictions were lifted in German and Hirschfeld saw his chance.  He and Oswald made Different from the Others, part educational and part political, their film was very controversial when it was released.  It was banned in 1920, and all copies were burned by Naziís.  Today the film only exists in an incomplete form discovered in a film archive in Russia.

The film stars Conrad Veidt (Cesare from The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari) as a virtuoso violinist, Paul Körner.  He takes on a handsome young student, Kurt (Fritz Schulz,) and the two soon fall in love.  Unfortunately, Paul is being blackmailed by Franz Bollek (Reinhold Schünzel) a shifty crook who has found out that Paul is a homosexual.  Heís bleeding Paul for all heís worth, and though Körner could have Franz arrested for blackmail, he would be arrested too for violating Paragraph 175.  Why, the film asks, should someone, an artist no less, be condemned for just loving someone?

The main problem with this film isnít the subject matter or the way it is handled, itís the fact that it is incomplete.  The film runs less than 50 minutes, and roughly half of that is actual video.  The rest of the movie was recreated from production still incorporated into the film and long intertitles that explain the sections that are missing.  Unlike Metropolis however, which handles missing segments in a similar fashion, there is a large percentage of Different from the Others that is missing.  Whole subplot involving Paulís family are missing, as well as much of the film dealing with Kurtís relatives.  The film has no rhythm to it because of the frequent intertitles, and the synopses of the missing scenes are no replacement for the scenes themselves.  It is really hard to judge the quality of this movie because so much of it is missing.

One highlight of the film was Conrad Veidtís performance.  He did a wonderful job, and he is always a joy to watch.  His climactic scene was my favorite part of the movie.

The DVD:


Audio:

This DVD has the best accompaniment of any of the films in this series.  The piano score actually matches the action on the screen, with fast intense music during the fight scene and slower music during the somber sections.   A nicely matched score.

The intertitles to the film, as well as the letters and other text information are in English and contemporary creations.  There are no subtitles.

Video:

Taking into account that there is only one copy of this film left, the image isnít too bad.  The image is dark in places, and the details are lost in darker areas, but there is a good amount of detail.  The contrast isnít great, and there is a good amount of print damage, but the DVD is very watchable.

Extras:

Unfortunately, there are no extras with this disc.

Final Thoughts:

Unfortunately, the complete version of this film is lost to us, and this pieced together reconstruction, while better than nothing, only hints at what the complete movie would have been like.  While Conrad Veidt does a good job, there were just too many missing sections of film to really evaluate the quality of the script or direction.  A very interesting look at homosexuality in German between the wars, this DVD is would make a good rental.

Michael


The best film of this series is easily Michael by the Danish master, Carl Theodor Dreyer.  Thought lost for years, and eclipsed by Dryerís later films, Michael is a very interesting work.  In this film Dreyerís techniques that he would use in making his silent masterpiece The Passion of Joan of Arc are fully realized, and the film is a stylistic triumph.  Though the story itself didnít captivate me, Dreyerís direction made this an interesting film to watch.

Michael (Walter Slezak) is a model and apprentice to the wealthy master painter Claude Zoret (played by Benjamin Christensen who went on to direct Haxan.  This was his last acting role.)  Zoret dotes on his protege, and his most famous works are portraits of the young Adonis.  When a Russian Princess, Lucia Zamikoff (Grete Mosheim,) comes to have her portrait painted by the master, things start to change.  Michael falls in love with Lucia and as the two grow closer Michael pulls away from Zoret.  The master painter is deeply troubled by this, and when Michael rents an apartment of his own, and sees this as an act of betrayal.  Though when Michael starts selling the gifts Zoret gave him and even starting to steal from him in order to woo the Princess, the painter turns a blind eye to the exploitation.

The story itself, based on a novel by Danish writer Herman Bang who was popular in Germany at the time, didnít really grab me the way most of Dreyerís work does.  I never really was that interesting in the love triangle that at first glance is the driving force of the movie, nor the subplot of the Duke having an affair with a married woman.  Like the ogre Schrek though, this film has layers.  On the surface, the two plots are a little on the melodramatic side, but when placed against each other and examined, they give new meaning to the film.  The two romances involve love triangles an run through similar courses.  When you compare the two, they are very similar.  The Dukeís involvement with a married lady is a forbidden love though, and by implication so is Zoretís love for his model Michael.

Art plays an important role in this film, not only by being the backdrop to the drama, but because most to the characters are associated with art and interact through art.  The story itself is almost told through the various pieces of art that populate the film.  Zoret paint all three of the main characters, Michael, Lucia and himself in a fashion that reveals the role that they will play in the movie.  Michael and Luciaís romance first starts when he shows her a statue of a naked woman, just as Michaelís relationship with Zoret began when the young artist showed his sketches to the master.  The comparison of people to art objects, and how art connects people is hard to miss.

There is also the underlying theme of the role inspiration plays on artistic achievement which I found much more engaging.  The master can create brilliant images when Michael is posing for him, but when he tries to paint the Princess, he canít manage to fully capture her.  Michael on the other hand, can perfect his teacherís painting with a few brush strokes.

Dreyer obtains subtle performances from his actors in this film, as he often does, and this subtlety greatly adds to the filmís appeal.  The subject of a homosexual romance gone sour, told mainly through implication, is a tough idea to get across.  Even more so in 1924.   The strength of the actors and their willingness to tell the story through more natural means is a key ingredient to the success of this film.

The one aspect of this movie that appealed to me most was the way that Dreyer filmed it.  He uses a very interesting tableau for much of the film.  Many of the shots are Ďframedí by a doorway or an arch, and there is little depth to th image with all figures being in the same plane.  These shots are reminiscent of some 18th century art.  The figures themselves are not as important as their surroundings...the decor is what captures the eye.  He alternates these tableau images with many closeups, where a face fills the screen.  This is almost the opposite shot, where the decor is totally ignored and the focus is on a single individual.

This is an interesting and effective way to tell a story.  The tableau style shots are useful in moving the narrative forward and telling the story, but it is not very personal.  Dreyer solves this problem by intercutting closeups that are prefect for revealing emotion and giving the movie a personal and intimate feel.  The way he utilizes this technique is both masterful and artistic, making this an important film in his evolution as a director.

The DVD:


Audio:

The original piano score by Neal Kurz was technically sound but didnít enhance the film the way the best silent scores do.  The music for the Swan Lake scene had the same feel as the rest of the soundtrack and didnít set this trip to the theater apart from the rest of the film for example.  Kurzís performance is very good though, and his score is pleasing to the ear, it just doesnít mesh with the visuals as well as some other scores do.  There are English intertitles, but no optional subtitles.

Video:

The image was good for an 80 year old film.  While this restoration by the Murnau Institue is a quality effort, it doesnít look like their fill effort and resources were put into this effort.  While the image is clear, the picture is on the light side, and details are lost both in the shadows and highlights.  The range of grey tones is acceptable, but not spectacular.  It is very obvious that the film has been restored though.  Dirt and spots, while present, are not very frequent and the image is much cleaner than one would normally expect. A nice looking movie, even if it isnít outstanding.

Extras:

This disc has a commentary by Danish film scholar Casper Tybjerg from the University of Denmark.  He gives a very through and scholarly talk.  He discusses the background for the making of the film, the careers of people involved, Dreyerís style and the differences between the novel and the movie.  Though it sounds like English isnít Tybjergís first language, his commentary is very clear and easy to understand, though his presentation is a little on the dry side.  Even with that flaw, this was a very informative audio track.

There is also a text listing of Dreyerís films.

Final Thoughts:

While story itself was not as engrossing as some of Dreyerís other films, if you examine this movie a little it has some interesting things to say.  There are several layers to the film, and Dreyer includes a lot to interpret.  Dreyer has a lot to say about the relationship between art and the artist and the role of inspiration.  I havenít even touched on the religious aspects of this work, a subject that runs through most of his films.  Technically the film is masterful.  Dreyer has constructed with mainly closeups and long shots and it is quite effective in telling the story and keeping the film intimate and subtle.  Recommended.
 


Sex in Chains


The most salaciously titled film is the group, Sex in Chains, was directed and stars William Dieterle.  Dieterle had played in German films for years, even having a role in Murnauís Faust, and drifted into directing.  This was the fourth film that he directed and while not a classic, it does have some strong moments and does not flinch from its subject.

Franz (Dieterle) is an out of work engineer, who just canít seem to find a job.  His young wife Helene (Mary Johnson) manages to land a job as a cigarette girl in a nightclub to help them out financially until Franz can get back on his feet.  While working one night, a patron starts to  harass Helene.  When Franz sees whatís happening he tells the man to leave his wife alone and a fight breaks out.  Franz punches the man who is knocked down and strikes his head on a concrete step, a wound that eventually kills him.  Franz is arrested and sentenced to three years in jail.

While in jail, Franz can not stand the lack of sexual relations with his wife.  The otherwise pleasantly depicted prison is a hell for him, and it nearly drives him mad.  Only the arms of an attractive cell mate allows Franz to retain his sanity.   Little does he know, but Helene has also found comfort while her husband is imprisoned, in the form of her employer who has taken an interest in her well being.

Iím not sure that this film would be remembered today if not for the subject matter.  It plays like a typical silent melodrama, with the characters displaying exaggerated emotions and feelings.  While Iíll admit that an extended period of time without sex wouldnít be pleasant, I canít see people going crazy or killing themselves over it as happens in this film.  Franz reaction to the depravations while in prison are almost comical today.

The actors do give good performances though, with the overacting being kept to a minimum.  Dieterle does a convincing job as Franz, and also does an admirable job directing.  While the film isnít prefect, there are some very good sections to it.  The reeling camera and quick cuts when Franz is near madness from lack of sex was very effective.  As where the superimpositions used to show what characters were thinking.

The DVD:


Video:

The restoration was built off of a censored 1930 print from the Gosfilmoford collection in Russia along with a French print of the film that contained the censored scenes.  The Russian parts of the film look very good, though not spectacular.  There are still some spots and scratches on the image, but the detail is fair, and so is the contrast.  The French print is noticeably inferior, with more grain, a softer picture and much less contrast.  This print was only used for a few scenes though and overall the DVD looks fine.

Audio:

The original piano score by Pasquale Perris while technically proficient, was uninspiring.  There wasnít a lot of effort to have the music being played match the mood on the screen.  A slow and steady piece played during the scene in a  nightclub where a jazz band was playing, and during the fight that lands Franz in jail the music lacked excitement and tension.  A song also gets cut off at the end of act II.

This film in presented with the oridinal German intertitles with optional English subtitles.  The intertitles presented during the French sections of the film are in a different typeface which is very evident.

Extras:

There are no extras on this DVD.

Final Thoughts:

While this film would be of interest to individuals studying the depiction of homosexuality in early cinema, I donít think it has a much wider appeal.  The script was too heavily laden with melodrama to be interesting to todayís audiences and while the direction is good, it doesnít make up for the sometimes plodding plot.  This would be a good rental.

Comments?  Suggestions? Feel free to send me an e-mail.


Archives

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © DVDTalk.com All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise