Release List Reviews Price Search Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise
DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info



The Phantom of Liberty

The Phantom of Liberty
Criterion 290
1974 / Color / 1:66 anamorphic 16:9 / 104 min. / Le phantome de la liberté / Street Date May 24, 2005 / 29.95
Starring Adriana Asti, Julien Bertheau, Jean-Claude Brialy, Adolfo Celi, Michael Lonsdale, Michel Piccoli, Jean Rochefort, Bernard Verley, Milena Vukotic, Monica Vitti
Cinematography Edmond Richard
Production Designer Pierre Guffroy
Film Editor Hélène Plemiannikov
Written by Luis Buñuel, Jean-Claude Carrière
Produced by Serge Silberman
Directed by Luis Buñuel

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie is probably more a more satisfying entertainment, but if one wants to understand the core of Luis Buñuel's take on surrealist playfulness, the picture to see is The Phantom of Liberty. Criterion's tidy package includes an interview and several text extras that clarify the rationale behind the unique wickedness that sparks Buñuel's best work.

Non-spoiler Synopsis:

An invading French officer seeks to resurrect a dead queen in Toledo, 1806. Schoolchildren are passed filthy postcards on modern-day French playground. A man's visit to the doctor is interrupted to follow a nurse's trip to the country, where she meets some odd monks and an S&M couple at an inn. A social gathering reverses the roles of the bathroom and the dining table. A young girl disappears and her distraught parents seek the help of the police. A mad sniper is apprehended by the police and put on trial. A prefect of Police receives a phone call from his dead sister, and goes to her tomb to see if she's really there.

After thirty years of melodramas and classical adaptations with undertones of surrealism, Buñuel returns to the roots of the movement with The Phantom of Liberty, a blatantly nonsensical non-narrative that resurrects an early surreal aim, the destruction of narrative forms. Young avant-garde enthusiasts in the twenties and thirties wrote that their idea of creative anarchy was to theater-hop between cinemas. They would arrive in the middle of a story in one movie. As soon as some interesting development came along, they'd leave and rush to the next theater to plop down in the middle of some other movie, and so on. In what now sounds like a primitive form of channel-surfing, they constructed their own illogical narratives that purposely made hash of artistic intentions and moralising messages. The essential content of the films was liberated by being pulled out of their original contexts.

The Phantom of Liberty follows this idea explicitly. Just as one character or story grabs our attention, Buñuel's camera opts to follow another character into a completely different narrative thread. Interesting characters are introduced and then dropped as arbitrarily as might a minor bit player.

Naturally, the tale teases with satirical jabs at social conventions and other mundane realities that the surrealists would have liked to see exploded. Some are simply wicked observations, such as the fairly uncomfortable sequence that asks why civilized humans eat together as a social gathering, while bodily eliminations are hidden away in private. Never mind that there's plenty of logic to back up the convention; the work of surrealists is to yank the rug out from under complacent givens.

Nothing thrilled the surrealists more than the idea of the fantastic erupting into everyday life, an obsession that politicos frequently link to ideological extremism. Some of the play-fragments of the 'story' deal explicitly with famous surrealist themes. Surrealists loved the idea of blurring the lines between fantasy and reality, between responsible action and 'liberated' instinct. They were mostly talkers and writers that proposed all kinds of shocking ideas but thankfully didn't carry them out. It's understandably difficult to grasp the intended purity of intention behind their talk about crazy violent acts, or doing things like showing pornographic films to children expecting a cartoon matinee. The Marquis de Sade merely wrote about obscene sex and tortures, but society equates dangerous thinking with dangerous acts.

According to the filmmakers, writing a surreal tale is not as easy as it might seem. If the idea makes sense, has a demonstrable purpose or needs to be premeditated, Buñuel claimed that it wasn't any good from the surrealist point of view. A mad killer like Whitman on his Texas tower doesn't qualify, even though The Phantom of Liberty shows a similar shooter following a similar impulse. Buñuel's mass murderer isn't crazy and shows no reaction to being served a death sentence for his crime. The kicker comes when he's unaccountably released. His judges light his cigarette and autograph seekers run to him. It's as if the definition of 'death sentence' had been changed to mean 'forced to live in human society' - just as Hell turns out to be a discotheque in Buñuel's Simon of the Desert.  1

By Buñuel's definition, Orson Welles' trick of (presumably) purposely seeing if he could start a panic with his War of the Worlds radio show doesn't qualify either. Whether or not he intended to vault to Hollywood on the basis of a stunt, it was a calculated effort for personal fame and gain. Like the wholly mysterious reason that Buñuel's sniper is let off the hook, the surreal act needs to be gratuitously irrational.

In the film's most maddeningly amusing sequence two parents, teachers and the police frantically search for a lost child, who is among them all the time and is simply being ignored. When the policeman asks for the child's description so the cops will know what they're looking for, the girl's mother has her stand up so the policeman can see for himself!

In another 'basic' skit, a man gives a schoolgirl what we think are pornographic postcards. Her parents look at with horror and then seem to be turned on by one of them. I won't give away the punch line except to say that it's essentially identical to the premise of the first episode of the 1963 The Addams Family TV show, the one where Morticia and Gomez are scandalized to find out what filth is being taught their children at school - Grimm's fairy tales. Surrealism is where you find it.

Elsewhere Buñuel gets in side digs about insects, grave-robbing (which might lead to necrophilia), indifference to sexual provocation, incest between a young man and his aged aunt, and the expected jabs at organized religion. A gallery of actors famous and unknown fill out the large cast - Jean-Claude Brialy, Michael Lonsdale, Michel Piccoli, Jean Rochefort, Bernard Verley and 'friendly guest star' Monica Vitti.

Elaborately filmed and presented, The Phantom of Liberty presents every scene from a serious, level-headed standpoint, even its historical opening in which a statue comes to life to deliver a blow to an amorous French officer. Amusingly, a scene in which a man is given a traffic ticket has no satirical or illogical aspect whatsoever - Buñuel and his writer Jean-Claude Carrière obviously think the situation is sufficiently bizarre without further elaboration. The only organizing principle is the title, said to be a quote from the Communist Manifesto. A famous painting of a massacre of rebels is repeated once or twice as a motif. The purest expression of the filmmakers' artistic intent comes when Jean-Claude Brialy shoves aside a clock on a desk-top to make room for an inappropriate decoration, a huge preserved tarantula. "I hate symmetry," the man says. I think Buñuel's approach is correct. Even after many years, the events in his provocative movies are impossible to forget.

Criterion's fine DVD of The Phantom of Liberty is an excellent enhanced transfer to join their equally pristine editions of Discreet Charm and That Obscure Object of Desire. Jean-Claude Carrière is interviewed on camera with his viewpoint on his collaboration with Luis Buñuel, and the insert booklet reprints a fascinating interview with the director addressing the finer points of surrealist interpretation for the cinema. Gary Indiana offers an essay as well. The disc was produced by Jason Altman and Heather Shaw.

On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, The Phantom of Liberty rates:
Movie: Excellent
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent English (Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono)
Supplements: Introduction by screenwriter Jean-Claude Carriere; Trailer; essay by culture critic Gary Indiana
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: May 26, 2005


1. Of course, the celebrity of real criminals given heavy media coverage seems just as surreal ... with atrocious crimes leading to book deals, etc. As Ed Neumeier said, "Kill a kid, go to Beverly Hills ... it's the Law!"

DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2007 Glenn Erickson

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

Release List Reviews Price Search Shop SUBSCRIBE Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise