DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info



Enemy at the Gates
Savant Blu-ray Review

Enemy at the Gates
2001 / Color / 2:35 widescreen (Super-35) / 131 min. / Street Date May 19, 2009 / 29.99
Starring Jude Law, Ed Harris, Rachel Weisz, Joseph Fiennes, Bob Hoskins, Ron Perlman, Eva Mattes, Gabriel Marshall-Thomson, Matthias Habich.
Robert Fraisse
Production Design Wolf Kroeger
Film Editor Noëlle Boisson, Humphrey Dixon
Original Music James Horner
Written by Jean-Jacques Annaud, Alain Godard
Produced by Jean-Jacques Annaud, John D. Schofield
Directed by Jean-Jacques Annaud

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

Jean-Jacques Annaud doesn't do things half-way, as can be seen in the obsessive excesses of his Quest for Fire, The Lover and even The Bear. His 2001 Enemy at the Gates is an expensive ($70 mil) WW2 war picture about Stalingrad, a subject with a limited mass appeal -- American audiences seem to require dashing Yankee or Brit heroes in their war movies.

Annaud opens the show with a desperate Russian attempt to retake the besieged city from the Germans. With plenty of manpower but few weapons, the Soviets order waves of recruits, many of them unarmed, against German machine guns. Their own officers warn them that they'll shoot any "cowards" that retreat.

Alive amid hundreds of fallen comrades, infantryman Vassili Zaitsev (Jude Law) knocks off five Germans with five swift shots, saving the life of propaganda Commisar Danilov (Joseph Fiennes). When General Nikita Kruschev (Bob Hoskins, quite convincing) needs a morale-boosting campaign, Danilov promotes Zaitsev to sniper duty and publicizes him as a hero of the Motherland. Zaitsev prowls the crumbling buildings in the still-active battlefield, lying in wait for hours to pick off Nazi officers with his long-range rifle. To be sure of a kill, Vassili always aims for the head. A lot of blood flies in Enemy at the Gates.

German General Paulus (Mathias Habich) responds by importing a deadly sniper ace of his own. The aristocratic Major König (Ed Harris) is also an experienced tactician; he's more than a match for Zaitsev. The Nazi and the peasant stalk one another in the shattered city, engaging in a murderous duel. Commisar Danilov builds his sharpshooter friend into a popular hero and proves to Kruschev that his morale campaign is working. But Danilov's attitude changes when he realizes that Zaitsev is romantic competition for the beautiful Tania Chernova (Rachel Weisz), a translator who would rather be fighting at the front. Tania sneaks to the forward positions to spend her nights with Zaitsev, sleeping with him amid hundreds of exhausted fighters.

Enemy at the Gates's avoidance of action-movie glitz should appeal to lovers of quality war movies. Young Vassili manages to survive a crossing of the Volga during a mass attack by German aircraft, a spectacular scene. But most of the film concentrates on intense sniper stand-offs that remind us of nail-biters like Ten Seconds to Hell. Both riflemen are such deadly shots that neither can risk exposing themselves for even a second; the idea is to sucker one's opponent into firing a lame shot that will reveal his position. In one encounter Vassili becomes trapped behind an iron stove, unable to reach his rifle only a couple of yards away. On another day König leaves a telltale trail by tracking yellow dirt from a factory slag heap. It's the little details that count.

The script by Annaud and Alain Godard lets occasional dialogue carry the weight of unseen mass executions and other atrocities. Instead of a history lesson, the film concentrates on what is really a mass suicide mission: every defender of Stalingrad knows his life isn't worth a plug ruble. Stalin orders that the Germans be turned back, so Kruschev forces his predecessor to commit suicide and threatens to kill any member of his staff who doesn't deliver results. When Commisar Danilov promises to rally the defense with a publicity campaign, he's gambling with his life.

Other war films (The Blue Max), (Flags of Our Fathers) have examined war heroes manufactured for publicity. Vassili Zaitsev is unaware that his friend Danilov has a secret personal agenda. The Commisar arranges for a civilian shoeshine boy, Sacha (Gabriel Marshall-Thompson) to feed König false information, but doesn't tell Zaitsev about it. When Danilov becomes jealous of Tania Chernova's affection for Vassili, we can't tell if the Commisar is trying to help Vassili or send him into a trap.

The acting is quite good. Jude Law and Rachel Weisz are appropriately idealistic in contrast to Joseph Fiennes' more intellectual Commisar. Ed Harris makes his German warrior an utterly ruthless elitist killer. Familiar face Ron Perlman shows up as Zaitsev's backup shooter, a man with a mouthful of replacement metal teeth. Perlman makes a fine impression despite being dubbed. Although the "sniper duel" is probably an historical exaggeration, we're told that most of the main characters are based on real-life Soviet combatants. A female Russian sniper racked up even more kills than did Zaitsev. His rifle is apparently now part of a Stalingrad exhibition.

Paramount's Blu-ray of Enemy at the Gates gives us Jean-Jacques Annaud's gritty battle film in a striking HD presentation. The art directors go for a clammy range of blues and grays punctuated by bursts of colored smoke from bomb hits -- black, dark green. Annaud's art directors and effects artists sketch a convincing urban battlefield, wisely avoiding show-off angles and camera moves -- the film has no CGI slow-mo bullets or impossible corkscrew trucking shots.

The disc's best extra is a selection of interesting deleted scenes. The featurettes Through the Crosshairs and Inside Enemy at the Gates are publicity-oriented interview bites illustrated almost exclusively with redundant clips from the movie. The only HD extra is the original trailer.

The Russians and the Germans mostly speak English, an affectation that doesn't become a handicap. Curiously, Enemy at the Gates reminds us of an entire genre of Russian films mostly unseen in the West. Throughout the Cold War the Soviets produced at least one or two massive "war glory" epics each year to commemorate the valor and sacrifice of the millions that died defending the Motherland. Many were filmed in 65mm and used vast Russian Army resources. Few if any of these films have been exported to the United States.

On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor,
Enemy at the Gates Blu-ray rates:
Movie: Very Good ++
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: Two featurettes, deleted scenes, trailer
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: May 5, 2009

Republished by arrangement with Film.com

DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2009 Glenn Erickson

See more exclusive reviews on the Savant Main Page.
Reviews on the Savant main site have additional credits information and are often updated and annotated with reader input and graphics. Also, don't forget the
2009 Savant Wish List. T'was Ever Thus.

Return to Top of Page

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. | Privacy Policy

Subscribe to DVDTalk's Newsletters

Email Address

DVD Talk Newsletter (Sample)
DVD Savant Newsletter (Sample)