Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Paul McCartney - The Music & Animation Collection

Walt Disney Studios Home Entertainment // Unrated // April 13, 2004
List Price: $29.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Matthew Millheiser | posted April 19, 2004 | E-mail the Author

The Program

You know, I gave Sir Paul's creative endeavors a right ribbing in my review of Give My Regards To Broad Street, his 1984 pet project that emerged as both a critical and financial flop. The soundtrack did pretty well, but then again the music was pretty much the only memorable element from the movie. So call me unreasonably apprehensive if you want, but the fact that the next DVD on my review queue happened to be Paul McCartney - The Music and Animation Collection filled me a little bit of trepidation. I was hoping that I didn't have to rip apart yet another McCartney project... especially since I've been a fan of Paul's since even before I was a raging, swooning, hyperventilating Beatles fan.

The collection is a series of three animated shorts in which McCartney, animation director Geoff Dunbar, and a host of many other creative talents collaborated over the last several years (Paul's late wife Linda also contributed to one short before her death.) But Paul's contributions to the shorts aren't merely cursory; he didn't "sign off" on them, lending the cartoons his name and pasting a barely-deserved Executive Producer label on himself. Paul was an active contributor. He composed the music, wrote the lyrics, contributed his voice to many of the characters, and oversaw the entire production. Like the aforementioned Give My Regards To Broad Street, his Music and Animation Collection is also a pet project in which McCartney takes an active, center-stage role.

And unlike Give My Regards To Broad Street, The Music and Animation Collection is, for the most part, simply wonderful. The three shorts in the collection vary in quality, from very good to fantastic, but each of them is charming, enjoyable, witty, and good-natured. The entire program runs a scant 42 minutes, shockingly short if you ask me but yet maintaining its quality throughout.

The collection consists of three shorts:

Tropic Island Hum - (1997) Ostensibly a thinly-veiled treatise on animal-rights activism (it was dedicated to "Animal Welfare Organizations Throughout The World") and "Can't we all just get along"-styled musings, this is a simple and good-natured little tale about Wirral the Squirrel. Fleeing from hunters in the forest, he finds himself in Froggo the Frog's hot-air balloon. They whisk themselves off to a tropical island, in which they meet dozens of other hunted animals, and sing and dance in celebration of their newfound freedom. I thought Tropic Island Hum was a bit lightweight but fun, a sweet little tale that featured a toe-tapping title tune by McCartney.

Tuesday - (2000) Simply put, this is the collection's showstopper. Based on the book by David Wiesner Tuesday is a lush and beautifully animated tale about a group of frogs in a swamp who, one Tuesday night, find themselves levitating on their lily pads as if they were miniature flying carpets. The frogs float throughout the local town as the other animals stare in amazement, creating mischief and havoc wherever they go. This short is simply magical, a breathtaking piece of work that hearkens back to the best of Disney's Silly Symphonies. In fact, Tuesday could easily have been a segment of either of the Fantasia movies. It's that good.

Rupert and the Frog Song - (1984) More realized than Tropic Island Hum but not quite reaching the greatness that is Tuesday, Rupert and the Frog Song is another sweet, good-natured tale featuring a bear named Rupert as he spends his day in play. Failing to find a playmate, he ends up following a group of frogs into their underground kingdom, and witnesses as the frogs put on a centenary celebration. Meanwhile, an evil barn owl follows in his wake, determined to make a meal out of tasty frogs. I enjoyed Rupert and the Frog Song quite a bit. It displayed a wealth of imagination from start to finish, especially anything and everything that occurs in the Froglands.

The DVD

Video:

Paul McCartney - The Music and Animation Collection is presented in its original fullframe aspect ratio of 1.33:1. The shorts vary in quality but all look reasonably well. The oldest short - Rupert and the Frog Song - suffers from a bit of fading and some slight debris on the print, but image remains reasonably sharp and the colors are richly rendered. Strangely enough, Tropic Island Hum seems the fuzziest of the three, although it was produced a good thirteen years after Rupert. It could have looked a little sharper, but for the most part the dazzling colors will keep you enthralled. Tuesday, the best of the shorts, also retains the best appearance. Set mostly at night, the short relishes in its deep blacks and fine contrasts, with rich purples, blacks, and blues looking deep and well-delineated.

Audio:

The audio is presented in both Dolby Digital 5.1, and is a surprisingly peppy and satisfying affair. Paul's songs and compositions are well-served by the soundtrack. Fidelity seemed strong and deep, with excellent dynamic range providing for a pretty engaging experience. There is solid use of LFE to keep the bottom end sounding thorough and booming. Surrounds are used appropriately for score enhancement, directional effects, and background/ambient noise. There is enough immersive activity and strong fidelity to keep this soundtrack sounding quite winning and enjoyable.

Extras:

Paul talks about the Animation Collection is a seven-minute interview with Sir Paul, as he discusses his involvement with each of the animated shorts. There is no question that Paul's dedication to these shorts was quite heartfelt; he really explains his love of animation, especially the innate charm and warmth of cel-drawn features. His enthusiasm about his work in this collection is pretty infectious, and Paul remains energetic throughout the piece.

There are two "making-of" featurettes included: The Making of Tropic Island Hum and The Making of Tuesday. They run for twelve minutes each, and providing some exclusive behind-the-scenes looks at the origin and creations of each piece. We see how the stories and characters were developed, live action tests and footage, models, line-tests, and the evolution of the animation.

Coming up next is the 11-minute Rupert & The Frog Song: Line Tests. Here we get to see line tests, layouts, and storyboards for the entire short, providing a "rough look" at the work in progress, using various earlier stages of animation to complete the story. The similarly styled Tropic Island Hum: Layouts, Storyboards & Line Tests (11 minutes) and Tuesday: Line Tests & Storyboards (10 minutes), also provide similar treatments.

Final Thoughts

The only disappointment about this series is its running length. At forty-one minutes, this collection could have just kept going and you scarcely would have heard a complaint from this reviewer. Nevertheless, I thoroughly enjoyed Paul McCartney - The Music and Animation Collection from start to finish. Tuesday is an absolute masterpiece and all by its lonesome justifies the purchase of this disc. Throw in the charming Rupert and the Frog Song as well as the slight but sweet Tropic Island Hum, and you have a fine collection that will win the hearts of anyone who enjoys the warm pleasures of traditional cel-animated features. The bonus material runs over an hour and will help offset the short running time of the main feature. This is a fine disc and well worth the time of any McCartney or animation fan.
Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Highly Recommended

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links