Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




First Daughter

Fox // PG // January 25, 2005
List Price: $27.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Jeff Paramchuk | posted January 14, 2005 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:
Movie releases tend to come in pairs, with two similarly themed movies normally being released around the same time.  And for some studios, being second to release lets you see how the first one did, then either capitalize on the theme or wait it out and hope everyone forgets the first and comes to yours.  The latter is what happened here with First Daughter and the similar Chasing Liberty.  First Daughter is the fifth movie from actor/director Forest Whitaker, and stars Katie Holmes, Marc Blucas, Amerie, and Michael Keaton.  Katie Holmes is the title character, Samantha Mackenzie, who is about to embark on that once in a lifetime journey known as leaving home for college.  Naturally, being the daughter of a President has its advantages and disadvantages, such as the benefit of having a beautiful roommate, played by Amerie and the disadvantage of having large men follow you every step you take, unless of course you put on a hooded sweatshirt and baseball cap so they can't recognize you.  

A running idea throughout the movie is how Sam wants to be treated like a normal college student.  She wants to go to class, attend parties, and meet normal everyday students without having the Secret Service follow her every move or being inundated with renditions of Hail to the Cheif when she moves about campus.  Of course, it wouldn't be a teen-centric movie without some romantic interest, and that is where Blucas comes in.  He and Holmes share a decent amount of screen time together in scenes ranging from a quite fun first date "get to know you" session, to an almost too cute scene in a boat with Ms. Holmes holding an umbrella to keep the sun off her. Who does that?

The supporting cast does a great job making this film work.  Keaton does a great job as a man who not only has a huge job to do, but also struggles with the parental side of things.  His only daughter is moving 3000 miles away to attend school, and he gets to spend less than 5 minutes saying good buy to her before being rushed off to another function.  As Keaton can do well, he does a lot of acting without having to say much, his emotion came across in the limit scenes he had to work with as a very caring father trying his best.  Amerie who plays Mia, Sam's roommate does a nice job of bringing some life to Katie's character who has gone through her life being quite sheltered and hasn't had a chance to experience the simple joys of adolescence.

Get ready for a self-described fairy-tale of a movie, with the princess actually becoming in touch with the little people.  I cna't find too much to complain about in the movie department, when I take the target audience into consideration.  But once you step out of the targeted section of humanity, there'll be a lot of issues that slip through like the aforementioned ability of a girl to sneak past the Secret Service for example.  Thankfully, movies area  choice, and if you feel that this might not be the best movie to suit your needs, then you can move past it in the aisle. 

The DVD:

How's it look:

First Daughter is presented in both a 1.85:1 widescreen, as well as a full screen presentation on the reverse side of the disc.  The widescreen version has the pleasure of being anamorphically enhanced for those of use who have the technology to make an enhanced disc look its best. However, some of the colors throughout the movie seemed a little washed out and slightly soft.  One scene in particular really made this apparent, and that was an exterior shot of the college that Sam is attending, with a brown brick building in the background and some bland looking green grass in the foreground.  However, when Amerie's character was in the shot, chances were good for some extra color, as her jaunt outfits really set up a contrast with the plain Jane color scheme of Katie Holmes'. 

I did however notice some slight dust and grain in the image.  Admittedly, the only time I noticed the defects was during a brightly lit scene and then the black outline of a speck is more noticeable.   


How's it Sound:

First Daughter contains the requisite Dolby Digital 5.1 with two supplemental tracks; 2 channel Spanish and French. Because of the type of movie this is, the surrounds were not used all that often for things other than ambiance.  And given that terribly mixed sound can really stand out, I did not notice that the speakers were poorly used at all so the effects were well mixed.

The score for the movie fit the tone quite perfectly, and that was the theme of a fairy tale which was intended by the original composer Michael Kamen.  Michael Kamen died shortly after composing the score, and a tribute to him is one of the extras on the disc.  His music was very well thought out and as I mentioned, fit in with the movie as a whole.  The composer who stepped in to fill the shoes of Mr. Kamen was Blake Neely, who I felt did a good job of taking someone's vision and keeping it intact. 

Extras:

As mentioned, a short featurette on Michael Kamen is on the fullscreen side of the disc.  This short clip features Blake Neely discussing what it was like to work with Michael on the score, and how he felt and sub-sequentially dealt with things after he heard about Michael's death.  The feature essentially discussed details of First Daughter and didn't really highlight much else of Michael's career, so it wasn't a complete tribute to his life, but more on the effect he had on parts of the production who work worked with him.

One other featurette is included that highlights some of the choreography in the movie.  While not a dance movie like some recent high energy movies, First Daughter did have some formal ballroom dancing in it, the predominant dance was the Foxtrot, which was highlighted in this short piece of fluff.  Not terribly interesting, but it showed some of the practice sessions that the actors had to endure to move as gracefully as they did on the screen.

 Two extended scenes are included, which lengthen some current scenes in the movie and look to be removed for slight pacing changes that they may have caused. A commentary is also included with the three primary actors who recorded it in a single session, so you do hear some of hte interaction between each other.  Not one of the more interesting commentaries I've listened too, as it was basically the three of them reminiscing about certain scenes like "I remember doing this at 5am", or "This was my first scene with Michael Keaton". 

Final Thoughts

While somewhat predicable as most movies of this type are, there were enough slight differences here to actually make this movie worth watching as a date movie.  It's got the romance part that the girls love,  and just enough cute women to make the movie bearable for the male crowd.  It's not going to win any best of DVD awards anytime soon, but the presentation is adequate for a movie of this type.  As a DVD, there isn't much here to warrant a purchase, as the extras included are your basic fluff piece and extended scenes, memorial tribute aside.  I'll give this a solid rental recommendation, as I felt that is was an OK time filler and one viewing will probably suffice.  

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Rent It

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links