Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info


Fantastic Four

Fox // PG-13 // December 6, 2005
List Price: $29.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by John Sinnott | posted December 4, 2005 | E-mail the Author
In a Nutshell:  A fantastically mediocre adaptation of the Fantastic Four comic book.

The Show:

In 1961 Marvel Comics writer Stan Lee and artist Jack Kirby created a new type of superhero, ones that were more human than the usual god-like heroes that other companies published.  At the time, Marvel was mainly publishing western and sci-fi comics, but with the publication of Fantastic Four #1, they started to craft a world of heroes that would eventually turn the small publishing company into a multimedia giant.  Now Marvel's first and foremost superhero book gets the big budget treatment in Fantastic Four.  Unfortunately this exciting comic gets turned into yet another not-so-great superhero movie joining the ranks of the Incredible Hulk, Daredevil, and Electra.

Reed Richards (Ioan Gruffudd) is a brilliant scientist who isn't that great at handling money.  Bankrupt and turned down by every institution that he's approached, Reed along with his friend Ben Grimm (Michael Chiklis) approach his multi-billionaire college buddy and fellow scientist Victor Von Doom (Julian McMahon).  They want to use his space station to study the effects of a radiation storm that is heading towards Earth.  Victor agrees, and the three take the next shuttle into space along with Reed's old flame and Von Doom's current squeeze Sue Storm (Jessica Alba) and her young brother hot-shot space pilot Johnny Storm (Chris Evans.)

While in space, the storm hit earlier than was expected and everyone save for Victor is caught outside the station's shielding.  A few days after returning to Earth they discover that the four of them have changed: they all have super powers.  Reed can stretch, Sue can turn invisible, Johnny can ignite his entire body, and Ben has turned into an incredibly strong rocky monster, The Thing.

Reed spends his time trying to turn Ben back to normal, but everyone's forgotten about Victor.  He's been effected by the radiation too, but it has warped his mind as well as his body.  Slowly turning into a person made totally out of metal, he decides to get even with the one person who is smarter than he is once and for all: he decides to kill Reed Richards and the Fantastic Four.

This movie has a really weak script that just didn't work very well at all.  It was apparently penned by writers who have heard of the comic, but never actually read it.  The simplistic plot just doesn't capture the charm and sense of adventure that the comic books have.

One of the problems is that there is too much exposition at times that really slows the film up.  Even if it wasn't for that, the pacing is very poor.  Not a lot happens in the first half hour, and then after the accident and the public revelation that New York is home to a family of superheroes there's another 30-45 minutes of plodding.  Heck, it's an hour into the movie before they get their hero names and Sue uses her force field.  On top of that, the Human Torch doesn't even really fly until the movie is nearly over.

This is a superhero movie without the superheroics.  The fight scenes and cool action that you'd expect from a summer big budget popcorn movie like this just doesn't come into play until the last 20 minutes.  The villain isn't that interesting either.  Dr. Doom in this film just isn't a very formidable foe for the FF.  His powers are ill defined, and he doesn't really seem to be that much of a menace because of it.  (He can make lights flicker... ohhhhh scary.)

That wouldn't have been a bad thing if the script was any good, but it's fairly wretched.  I didn't mind that they don't capture the comic book characters accurately, I can look past that.  (Reed is supposed to be a smart and distracted scientist but also a good leader, not the sensitive but clueless guy that he is portrayed as here.)  The problem that there are many plot holes and a lot of bad writing.  Some of this is just silly things that would just never happen in real life, like a woman going outside in only neglige, but a whole lot of the script didn't make sense.  How does Sue going invisible help get Reed and Johnny past a police cordon?  Or why does the press dub the group the Fantastic Four when only two of them publically exposed their powers.  Then there's Ben's wife who leaves him cold at the beginning of the film and then is never mentioned again, he certainly seemed to get over her quickly.  Of course the police don't investigate any of the murders that Victor commits earlier in the film, and the film (and I use the term loosely) also has the slowest heat seeking missile ever launched.  I could go on and on, but suffice to say that this script is rife with flaws and errors that become incredibly distracting.

The acting wasn't much better.  Julian McMahon spends the film trying to channel Kevin Spacey without much luck, and Ioan Gruffudd finds an emotion for Reed and pretty much sticks with it the entire time.  The worst offender was Jessica Alba though.  She was apparently cast for her physical beauty and not her acting ability because she is horrible in the role.  Some of her delivery is atrociously bad and bland.  I couldn't believe that the director didn't ask for more takes.
Michael Chiklis did an acceptable job as Ben Grimm, maybe a little too angst-filled in some scenes, but within the margin of error.  The one really good performance was by Chris Evans.  He was able to update the character of Johnny Storm while staying true to the comic and making the character fun.  Whenever he was on the screen the movie was much more enjoyable.

That's not to say that this is a totally worthless movie.  It isn't.  There are a few good scenes scattered throughout, and the battle at the end is pretty fun.  For a mindless summer movie though it should have more action and excitement or a better script.

The DVD:


This DVD has the choice of a 5.1 Dolby Digital track and a 5.1 dts soundtrack.  I viewed this movie with the dts track but spot checked the DD also.  They both sounded very good and reproduced the sounds from the movie faithfully.  There's a good amount of dynamic range, with the background music sounding full and forceful, and the dialog was clean and clear.  The big explosions and other loud noises will give your sub a workout too.  The only thing that is a little irritating is that for some odd reason it isn't possible to change audio tracks with the remote while the movie is playing.
There is also a Spanish dub in Dolby Surround, as well as optional subtitles in English and Spanish.


The widescreen anamorphic (2.35:1) image looked very good, as you would expect from a recent big budget film.  The colors were strong and the flesh tones accurate.  The black levels were spot on, and the level of detail was excellent.  There did appear to be a little light edge enhancement in a couple of scenes, but it was applied very lightly.  A nice looking disc.


This disc also comes with a commentary with Jessica Alba, Michael Chiklis, and Ioan Gruffudd.  It nice to find out that Michael Chiklis was a big comic book fan (at least that's what he claims) but the rest of the commentary was pretty average.  Jessica's comments are mainly limited to "do you remember when we filmed this?", but they did talk about things that happened behind the scenes and what the shoot was like.  I would have enjoyed it more if I had liked the movie.

In addition to the commentary there are a few other bonus items, none of which are very exciting.  The making-of featurette is a five-minute reel which is pretty much a fluff piece advertising the movie.  Fantastic Four: Making a Scene is an eight-minute look at how they filmed the wreck on the Brooklyn Bridge scene.  About 2 or 3 minutes of this is devoted to explaining who the FF are and what they are doing on the bridge, and then they finally talk about building the 200 ft section of bridge on a soundstage.

The three deleted scenes that are included were short, running about three minutes total.  The last one was pretty cute.

Fantastic Four: Video Diary is a 20 minute feature that has Jessia Alba taping some of the appearances that the cast did to promote the movie.  This is all jerky hand held camera footage that has very little substance and really isn't worth watching.  Fantastic Four: Casting Session is another back slapping piece where everyone involved with the film says how happy they are with the casting.  I can only assume that they filmed this before anyone saw the movie.
There are also a couple of trailers for the movie and a pair of music videos.

Final Thoughts:

It is possible to make a good film based on a comic book; just look at Spiderman and X-men.  It's even possible to make a great comic book movie.  Sin City is proof of that.  It is pretty hard to do though.  There are many more failures that there are successes, and unfortunately this is one of the failures.  The plot is weak, the acting is poor and the pace is uneven.  It does have its redeeming moments, just not enough.  If you feel like watching some eye candy and a couple of good action scenes, this would make a good rental.  If you are looking for a truly good movie though, keep on looking.

Buy from






Rent It

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links