Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Gilgamesh, Tablet 5: As Truth Breaks Like Glass

ADV Films // Unrated // February 28, 2006
List Price: $29.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by John Sinnott | posted March 2, 2006 | E-mail the Author
The Show:

More teen angst, more pointless battles, a few surprising (and not so surprising) revelations and a plot that is rolling forward ever so slowly. That what's in store for viewers of the fifth volume of Gilgamesh. While the series started off with a lot of promise, it has gotten bogged down with long exposition and plot lines that seem to go nowhere.

Series Background:

Fifteen years ago the Heaven's Gate project, a scientific organization with unknown goals and methods was about to be shut down. A lone scientist who was working on the project and also lobbied for its termination, Dr. Madoka, enters the inner core of the project and sets off a reaction that has global implications. A wave of energy races across the planet and alters the sky, making it shimmer and reflect lite, blocking out most of the sun, and making computers and other technological equipment useless. This happened on October 10th, or X - X in roman numerals, and it's now referred to as Twin X.

Now, fifteen years later, the "Sheltering Sky" as it is called is still encircling the Earth and technology still doesn't work. Two orphans, Kiyoko and Tatsuya, are trying to stay ahead of debt collectors and find enough food to eat in this bleak future. Running to avoid being caught by some bad men they owe money to, the pair hide in a house were they meet some interesting children who have amazing powers. These young adults, known as Gilgamesh, fend off the hoods easily, but then they are attacked by a second group of teens called the Orga. After a pitched battle with no clear winner, the leader of the Orga, the mysterious Countess of Werdenberg asks Kiyoko and Tatsuya to join her cause in fighting Gilgamesh. When they refuse, she buys their contract from the debt collectors and in effects owns them. The Countess says that the members of Gilgamesh are evil, but they say the same about her. Could these two groups be interested in these kids because they are the children of the infamous Dr. Madoka?

As Tatsuya discovers that he has special powers just like the Orga, Kiyoko finds out that she doesn't. The Countess has no use for the powerless sister who is starting to cause trouble, so she kicks her out of the Hotel Providence the she and the other Orga live. Kiyoko still has to pay back the money that the Countess paid for her though, and the monthly payments will keep her in poverty for the rest of her life.

Not everyone is willing to just accept the Sheltering Sky though. The Mitleid Corporation has constructed a mechanical computer inside of a huge spiral tower. They plan to use the device to reverse the events of Twin X. Gilgamesh has sworn to stop them, but the Countess pledges that her Orga will help protect the tower.

This volume:

After the Mitleid Corporation's tower has fallen, chaos ensued and Tatsuya is arrested. He is interrogated at length before being released, but learns something about his origins that comes as a complete surprise to him: He's a clone of his father. Shocked and shaken by this revelation, he runs away from both the Countess and Gilgamesh and holes up with his sister for a time. Just until the Countess wants him back again.

As Orga come to get Tatsuya, there's a battle with Gilgamesh, yet again. Kiyoko's home is destroyed as she accompanies everyone to the Hotel Providence. Surprisingly, she's attacked there by government agents and discovers that she now has power to use Dynamis and defends herself. This ability comes from an unexpected source that might not be the boon that she first thinks it is.

I never liked the character designs for this show, and the animation is very crude and unappealing. The story started out pretty interesting, but isn't being developed at a good pace. The plot is really creeping along and is filled with way too many teens feeling sorry for themselves. When Tatsuya finds out he's a clone he freaks out and mopes for days. Why? So what if you're a clone? That doesn't really change anything in your life.

The show started out with the concept that the viewer doesn't know which side is good and which side is bad. That was fun and a little different but they took it too far. The plot just seems to recycle over and over again with Tatsuya thinking that Orga is looking out for his best interest and then Gilgamesh. Repeat. In between the two sides fight and fight without either of them achieving a decisive victory. Now the series is starting to wrap up and things are coming together a bit, but it's a case of too little too late. I really don't care anymore.

The DVD:



Audio:

This disc offers the option of the original language soundtrack in stereo or an English dub in 5.1. I alternated between the tracks with every episode, and thought they were both very good. I preferred the Japanese track, but only slightly. The English 5.1 dub made very good use of the rear channels, for example it had the children's psychic voices echoing from behind the viewer which was very effective. There were no distortions or other audio defects in either track. A solid sounding disc.

Video:

The anamorphic widescreen image looks pretty good overall. The color palate consists of mainly blacks, whites and greys and these are reproduced faithfully. The lines are a little on the soft side, but not too much so. The level of detail was fair and the contrast was good. Digital defects are nonexistent, even aliasing doesn't show up.

Extras:

There were a good number of extras on this disc. The disc starts out with a clean opening and closing, two galleries of production art and character art, a glossary of terms, as well as some previews.

Revelations: A Gorgeous Puzzle is a 25-minute featurette that examines the nature and origins of the Gilgamesh creatures using clips from the show. It was a nice recap if you've forgotten some of the details.

The other featurette on this dies is Going, Going, Goth. Running about 25-minutes, this covers the release party at the Alamo Draft house and has a lot of interviews with the English voice cast.

Finally there are two "tables" labeled "04: History" and "06: Future." These are two minute reels of clips that show scenes from the earlier and later episodes respectively. I didn't find these very interesting, and the future one gave away some plot points.

There is also an insert that gives a recap of episodes 8-14.

Final Thoughts:

Sitting through the first four volumes of this show, I kept thinking that it would soon start getting better. Now that I've seen the fifth, I realize that it isn't. The show had a lot of promise, but it never delivered. There are too many scenes of young men and women feeling sorry for themselves and pointless fights and not enough real plot development. Though some things that have been hinted at in previous shows are confirmed in this volume, it's not all that exciting. They dragged it on too long and now I really don't care. If you've stuck with this series this far, this disc would make a good rental.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Rent It

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links