Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Man On Fire

Fox // R // January 8, 2008
List Price: $39.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by John Sinnott | posted January 30, 2008 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:


Ya gotta love revenge flicks.  Those movies where a highly trained
soldier/CIA Agent/mercenary gets pushed over the edge and goes after the
bad guys with a vengeance are always a lot of fun.  There's just something
about cheering for an anti-hero that is a bit liberating.  2004's
Man
on Fire
is such a film.  Filled with impeccable actors and a tense
script this is a good solid film that in another directors hands could
have been great.

John Creasy (Denzel Washington) is an ex-CIA agent who is barely holding
it together.  His years with the company and the things that he's
done have weighed heavily on him. He drinks to forget and reads the Bible
hoping to find salvation in its pages.  When an old buddy of his (Christopher
Walken) sets a job up for him, Creasy reluctantly agrees.  He's been
hired by a rich Mexican businessman (Marc Anthony) to be the body guard
for his daughter Lupita (Dakota Fanning).  It seems like an easy job
and though the pay's not high, Creasy discovers something he thought he
had lost:  his humanity.  The plucky and adorable 'Pita (as everyone
calls her) soon worms her way into the cold man's heart.  When something
happens to the girl however, Creasy discovers it's all too easy to fall
back on his training as an assassin and decides to take on the Mexican
underworld.




There's a lot that is right with this movie, starting with the casting. 
Dakota Fanning is just amazing as Creasy's precocious ward.  She has
a lot of screen presence and acts much better than a 9-year-old should
be able to.  She really makes it convincing that Creasy would find
some measure of peace watching over her.  The scene where Pita catches
her bodyguard smiling and confronts him about it is beautiful and she plays
it perfectly.

Denzel Washington is amazing as usual.  He's one of the greatest
actor's of his generation, and he brings all of his skill to this role.  
He's able to project Creasy's torment and anguish but also to make his
character three-dimensional and not a caricature.  An excellent performance.




The script was also pretty good though there were some flaws. 
The narrative drags in a few places, and the movie would be improved if
10 or 15 minutes was cut from its nearly 2 ½ hour running time. 
There were some nice twists in the story but those were overshadowed by
one really stupid, nonsensical twist that was tacked on at the end to give
the film a more upbeat ending.  In addition there were a couple of
minor plot holes that made the film less than perfect.   The
story did have a lot of suspense and some really excellent scenes (when
Creasy is training Pita to jump off the blocks for example) and it's easy
to overlook those imperfections.

Much harder to overlook was director Tony Scott's MTV-style of directing. 
Haven't we evolved past the shaky camera movements and hyper-kinetic editing
fad yet?  The frequent jarring camera movements, ugly double exposures,
and overly fast edits made it hard to just sit and watch the movie. 
Editing and effects like that should be invisible.  The viewer should
be so into the film that they don't notice the techniques used to tell
the story.  The film should just create a feel.  Scott fails
miserably at this.  Whenever he tries to use some fancy technique
viewers are reminded that they're just watching a movie.  It pulls
them out of the moment and they have to struggle to get back into the film. 
For a music video, those type of things are fine and work well.  They
don't for a feature film.


The Blu-ray Disc:




Video:

This
film comes to us with a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode that looks absolutely fantastic. 
The thing that first jumps out to viewers is the amazing detail that is
present.  The smallest objects are well defined and everything that
appears on screen is detailed.  The chapel in Lupita's house is a
good example.  The candle flames, the religious icons on the walls,
and the small alter itself are all strong and solid though this set is
always shot in low light.  The blacks are solid and deep too. 
The colors are a bit oversaturated in a scene or two, something that really
bugs me, but this is the exception rather than the rule.  Skin tones
look natural and the contrast is excellent.  On the digital side there
wasn't anything to complain about.  Aliasing, posterization, and other
common defects were absent.

Audio:

The film gets a DTS HD 5.1 Master Lossless Audio track that sounds wonderful
but has a problem.  First the good news:  the full soundstage
is used throughout the film to good effect.  The action scenes really
come alive with gunfire, explosions, and random noise filling the room
from every corner.  The sub gets a good workout too, especially when
the battles are raging.  After the action dies down the rears are
still employed, surrounding the viewer with ambient sound that really reproduces
the feel of Mexico.

The bad news is like the director's kinetic shooting style, the music
is overbearing.  It is often mixed so loudly that I had to adjust
the volume, and there was more than once when it obscured dialog. 
Honestly, do we really need blaring Linda Ronstadt in the film?  Aside
from this flaw, the movie had a great sounding track.

Extras:

Well, Fox decides to screw fans of the film by giving them a bare-bones
edition.  Earlier releases have been filled with commentaries, deleted
scenes and documentaries but none of that makes its way onto this disc. 
The only bonus material is a couple of trailers.   Though it
looks like Blu-ray will win the format war, it still hasn't won the hearts
of consumers.  Not bothering to port over previously released extras
won't help convince Joe 6-Pack to invest in the technology.  Why pay
more to get less content?

Final Thoughts:

A very good film that is marred by director Tony Scott's insistence
on shaky camera movements and ugly double exposures, in the hands of someone
else it could have been great.  Washington and Fanning do a magnificent
job and it's worth watching just to see their interaction.  The Blu-ray
disc does good job of reproducing the look and sound of the film, though
the music was mixed too high in several instances.  Not prefect, but
worth checking out.  Recommended.

Note: The images in this review are not from the Blu-ray disc and do
not necessarily represent the image quality on the disc.

 

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Recommended

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links