DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds

Sponsored Links

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » Napoleon & Love
Napoleon & Love
Acorn Media // Unrated // March 1, 2011
List Price: $59.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Paul Mavis | posted March 24, 2011 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Printer Friendly

"So long as men are swayed by their passion, then women will have the power to change the course of history...for better or worse."

An entertaining look at the amours of the Little General. Acorn Media has released Napoleon & Love, a three-disc, nine-episode U.K. miniseries from 1974 starring Ian Holm, Peter Bowles, and Billie Whitelaw as Josephine. Focusing exclusively on the sexual politics that drove French society―and, apparently, Napoleon, as well―Napoleon & Love ignores cannon and gunpowder for conquests of a far more intimate nature, with pleasing results. No extras to speak of, but the performances are quite amusing.

Considering the length of Napoleon & Love (over eight hours), a complete synopsis isn't within the scope of this review...so let's just set the stage. Beginning in Marseilles, 1795, when Napoleon was a hungry, unemployed brigadier general, Napoleon & Love looks at the romantic steps Napoleon took to help achieve his exalted position as Emperor. Having made a name for himself during the Revolution, Napoleon Bonaparte (Ian Holm) is at a loss as to how to navigate the post-war peace and new "Reign of Pleasure." Born a second son behind brother Joseph (Edward de Souza), and recently jilted by the woman he loved because he couldn't access the Bonaparte family money, Napoleon can't enter society successfully since he's altogether too serious, too intense, to play the flirting games that are necessary for young men to ascend the ladders of political success.

Advised by future mentor Paul Barras (T.P. McKenna) to latch onto a successful, older woman ("The women of Paris are politics."), Napoleon settles on an old family friend who provides "practical sex" for the driven little general...but not a "yes" to a marriage proposal from the hasty, naïve Napoleon. Sensing that Napoleon will be of military use to him as he tries to consolidate power, Barras asks one of his mistresses, Rose (Billie Whitelaw), to be "nice" to Napoleon, a suggestion she finds distasteful...but one she agrees to when Barras picks another mistress as his favorite, dismissing Rose as too old and too expensive. Thus sets into motion one of the great love affairs of history...if you believe the movies and comic books. Here, however, Josephine is portrayed as a scheming, amoral temptress who cheats on Napoleon constantly before and after their marriage, and who eventually breaks his naïve, trusting heart, ruining him for all the other women who enter his life, including lovely actress Georgina (Nicola Pagett), officer's wife Pauline (Cheryl Kennedy), society mistress Eleonore (Diana Quick), Madame Duchatel (Stephanie Beacham), Polish countess Marie Walewska (Catherine Schell), and Archduchess Marie-Louise of Austria (Susan Wooldridge).


Just for the record, I'm in no way a historian on Napoleon; what I learned about that emperor/dictator, saint/devil, came from eighth-grade history class and various movie incarnations, from Brando, both in Desiree (icky) and as Stanley Kowalski in A Street Car Named Desire ("They got this thing called the Napoleonic Code!"), to Bondarchuk's stunning adaptation of War and Peace...and his stunningly bad take on Waterloo (you have not lived until you've seen that sweaty, florid Rod Steiger nightmare). So I have no idea if what's presented here in Napoleon & Love is accurate or not (and let's face it: double-checking on public-written Wikipedia offers no peace of mind, either). Historians and Napoleon buffs would very likely find fault with it (buffs always find fault with movie versions of their heroes), but speaking as just a relatively uninformed layman, I found Napoleon & Love consistently entertaining and frequently amusing.

By eschewing gunpowder and the 1812 Overture (frankly that's a relief, too) for the ballroom and the boudoir, Napoleon & Love rejects the spectacle that's so often associated with films about this subject matter and instead focuses on the psycho-sexual forces that first formed, then led, Napoleon through his meteoric rise to Emperor. Written by Philip Mackie (Raffles and the excellent The Rivals of Sherlock Holmes), Napoleon & Love, through its long format, is able to delve rather deeply into its portrait of Napoleon, who's shown to be alternately naïve, weak, irrationally romantic, heartbroken, cruel, sadistic, and ultimately, sadder and wiser about love. The open corruption of French politics, as well as the accepted games of flirtation deemed crucial to social intercourse (ahem) and political maneuvering, are highlighted with deft, cynical humor, contrasted nicely with the sincerity (and manipulation) of Napoleon's romantic misadventures. It's a clever script, as well, with funny, telling lines throughout (when Whitelaw puts her foot down and declares, "I will not stay married to a man I don't love," McKenna smoothly replies, "Most women do." Whitelaw counters with, "To a man I never see," which McKenna lobs back with, "Most women long for that.") As essayed by Ian Holm, Mackie's Napoleon is often times seen as a surprisingly foolish character, one who is brilliantly attuned to the politics of war, both on the field and behind the closed doors of power, but who is utterly clueless as to how to treat women, or how he comes across to the fairer sex, or ultimately how indifferent he is when he manipulates them once he's been wronged for the last time by the love of his life: Josephine.

Holm, a terrific supporting actor who's best when playing slightly gamey, slippery characters (everyone loves his role in Alien, and rightly so, but a particular favorite of mine is his insufferably callous adulterer in Woody Allen's 1988 Another Woman), came to his lead turn in Napoleon & Love right after he started to make a (minor) name for himself in several big-budget international films, such as The Fixer, Oh! What a Lovely War, Nicholas and Alexandra, Mary, Queen of Scots, and Young Winston (all of them, come to think of it, relative big-budget failures). So the chance for the diminutive actor to take the lead in a nine-part TV series about one of the most recognizable figures from Western history, must have felt to the actor that he had finally "arrived." And run with the character Holm does. I've never seen a "subdued" portrait of Napoleon on film, but Holm does manage to make him alternately icy, preoccupied, and focused, before he lets Napoleon go into one of his romantic rages, either trying to smother Billie Whitelaw with kisses, or raging and screaming at those who don't measure up to his herculean expectations. It's a strange performance, at once subtle (during the scenes of political intrigue) and delightfully hammy (anytime he goes overboard romantically, such as his grossly funny panting and mewling over Whitelaw), and it's a good precursor to some of his subsequent, more famous roles.

Whitelaw may not at first fit your image of what you think Josephine should be like (I guess I had a more idealized, slightly Maria Antoinette-ish image of her in my mind: younger, more innocently sensual...but I guess that comes from all the romanticized hogwash about the great lovers in the popular culture). However, she's perfect as to how scribe Mackie finds her: deliciously amoral and scheming, sexually adroit (she laughs to her friends about how bad Nappy is in bed), a consummate liar, and finally, a rather pathetic figure that clings in vain to the notoriety that once came with being Napoleon's wife. While not a classic beauty, Whitelaw does have a mean, nasty eroticism to her slinky eyes and cruel mouth that fits Mackie's version of Josephine well. And she's a match for Holm's under/overplaying, pitching her performance to match his perfectly. Other turns are equally accomplished here, including my favorite, Nicola Pagett, who's wonderfully playful with Holm, Stephanie Beacham, who's sexy as Napoleon's mistress who wanted too much from him, and cool, collected, beautiful Catherine Schell as "the Polish wife" who may have succeeded in reaching Napoleon emotionally (as well as succeeding in carrying his child)...only to be thwarted in happiness by politics (and let's not forget another favorite, Peter Bowles, who's delicious as the horndog Murat, whose sly line readings kill every single time).

Here are the nine episodes of the three-disc set, Napoleon & Love, as described on the on-screen episode menus:


Episode 1: Rose
Marseilles, 1795. Broke and unemployed, Napoleon seeks the hand of Desiree, a relative of his sister-in-law, who possesses a substantial dowry. When her parents reject him, he leaves for Paris, where he secures an important position and meets Josephine.

Episode 2: Josephine
While Napoleon wages a brilliant campaign in Italy, Josephine conducts an affair with a handsome captain in Paris. When Napoleon demands that she join him in Milan, she replies that she can't travel, but Napoleon's passion for her grows greater each day.

Episode 3: Pauline
Campaigning in Egypt, Napoleon hears of Josephine's infidelity. Heartbroken, he embarks on an affair of his own with Pauline, the wife of a French lieutenant, and promises to marry her after divorcing Josephine.


Episode 4: Georgina
Now first consul of France and on the brink of becoming emperor, Napoleon takes a series of mistresses. The greatest threat to Josephine is an ambitious young actress, Mademoiselle George, whom Napoleon calls Georgina.

Episode 5: Eleonore
Napoleon is the emperor of France but still has no heir. Is he infertile, or is Josephine too old? Napoleon's sister Caroline arranges a new mistress for him, Eleonore, who soon becomes pregnant. But is the child really his?

Episode 6: Marie Walewska
The Emperor frees Warsaw from the Russians and falls in love with Marie Walewska, who spurns his advances until Polish patriots convince her otherwise. If she becomes Napoleon's mistress, perhaps she can curry favor for Poland.


Episode 7: Maria-Luisa
Napoleon needs a son and knows that Josephine can never give him one. Josephine's final desperate ploy-spreading rumors of Napoleon's impotence-fails. Napoleon divorces her and demands the hand of the Austrian emperor's daughter.

Episode 8: Louise
Napoleon weds the Archduchess Marie-Louise of Austria, a young woman with large sexual appetites. Before long, she is pregnant. Following a difficult labor, she delivers a son and immediately wants another, but Napoleon has world domination on his mind.

Episode 9: The End of Love
When Napoleon's Russian expedition fails, he is forced to abdicate and retreat to Elba. Josephine takes ill and remains faithful to the end. Napoleon returns to France in triumph, but soon faces Waterloo and his ultimate destiny.

The DVD:

The Video:
The full-screen, 1.33:1 video transfers for Napoleon & Love is right on par with similar U.K. video offerings from this time period: slight flaring, some video noise, and slightly muddy colors on a medium-sharp image. It looks exactly the way you would expect it to look, if you have previous experience watching this kind of British TV fare.

The Audio:
The Dolby Digital English mono audio tracks are adequate, with low hiss audible, and some squelchy patches from time to time: again, this is to be expected for a show from this time. English subtitles are included.

The Extras:
Text extras including a timeline of Napoleon's exploits, and some limited cast filmographies are the only extras here.

Final Thoughts:
Fast-paced despite its length, Napoleon & Love is an entertaining look at the love affairs of Napoleon, minus any battlefield considerations: the only skirmishes here occur in the boudoir. Ian Holm paints a complex portrait of Napoleon, both weak and wounded, while the ladies in his life are perfectly cast, particularly Billie Whitelaw as the duplicitous Josephine. A knowing, witty script helps, too. I highly recommend Napoleon & Love.

Paul Mavis is an internationally published film and television historian, a member of the Online Film Critics Society, and the author of The Espionage Filmography.

Popular Reviews
1. Jabberwocky: Criterion Collection
2. Planes, Trains & Automobiles (Re-release)
3. Kill and Kill Again
4. Rock-a-Doodle
5. Cease Fire - 3D
6. The Philadelphia Story: Criterion Collection
7. Misery: Collector's Edition
8. Le Samourai
9. An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth To Power
10. The Glass Castle

Sponsored Links
DVD Blowouts
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
Sponsored Links
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2017 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use