Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Penance

Music Box Films Home Entertainment // Unrated // November 18, 2014
List Price: $34.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Ian Jane | posted December 5, 2014 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:

Based on a book called Shokuzai by Japanese author Kanae Minato, Penance, directed by Kiyoshi Kurosawa was originally made as a TV mini-series before it was readjusted to work as a long feature film. The series revolves around the murder of a girl named Emili and how it affects her mother, Asako (Kyoko Koizumi), and those around her in the small village where the heinous crime took place. Although there were some witnesses, the crime goes unsolved by the local authorities. The four classmates who found Emili's body swear they can't recall the murderer's identity.

Understandably Asako is very upset over all of this, but it's what she does to cope with this grief that gives the series its backbone. When what would have been her daughter's birthday rolls around, Asako gathers up the four former playmates and tells them in no uncertain terms that if they don't spill it in regards to who killed her daughter, she will get penance from each and every one of them. A decade and a half later Asako tracks down these four girls: Sae (Yu Aoi), Maki (Eiko Koike), Akiko (Sakura Ando), Yuka (Chizuru Murakami), all now young women and each dealing with various issues of their own. Asako, however, has not forgotten her promise and in her own strange way almost literally becomes a black clad angel of vengeance.

As the storyline progresses over the five episodes that make up the entirety of Penance we learn how each of the four school girls grew into women accurately described as troubled. Going into too much detail as to the specifics of their own individual issues would give away a bit too much so we won't go there but they are flawed, just as everyone else on the planet is. They don't always cope with their flaws in the most appropriate ways though. While they may appear to have it together on the surface but as we spend a bit of time with them in each of their respective chapters we learn that things aren't quite as hunky-dory as they first seem. Character traits come into play here that, without wanting to spoil things, tie into Asako's quest in interesting and sometimes fairly surprising ways. The way in which the young women are tied into Asako, by this one event that binds them whether they like it or not, becomes important as Penance moves towards its conclusion.

Penance has its strong points and its weak points, but despite some flaws the good does outweigh the bad here. Working for the mini-series is some very strong acting. Each of the four woman who play those that Asako is after do fine work and manage to give their respective characters enough of their own personality and character quirks that we never have any trouble distinguishing them despite some obvious similarities in the beginning of the storyline. Not surprisingly though, given how things are weighted, Kyoko Koizumi is the actress that really stands out here. As Asako she is occasionally frightening, often quite tragic and always relatable and her work in front of the camera here is pretty believable. The story keeps things very grounded, so some of the credit for that goes to the writing, but Koizumi is very good in the lead and she ably carries the film.

The movie also benefits from the style that its director has essentially made his trademark. Those familiar with Kiyoshi Kurosawa know that he's not a particularly flashy director, at least in the sense that he doesn't rely on a lot of fast cutting or unnecessary camera tricks. He is a director who works very much ‘in camera' and while his style can sometimes be a little cold and sometimes a bit too clinical, here it suits the material. Asako herself has become cold and clinical in her methodology and the pacing of the material and the way in which it is shot and edited reflects this.

Where Penance loses a few points is with its ending, which we won't spoil, doesn't quite give us the payoff that the earlier chapters allude to. As such, sitting through a series/movie of this length might seem a bit arduous to those who want something a bit more visually arresting or action oriented. There's plenty of suspense to be had here, however, and there are enough eerie moments, interesting directorial choices and genuinely terrific performances to definitely make this worth watching if you don't mind the slow burn approach to storytelling Kurosawa employs.

The Blu-ray:

Penance arrives on Blu-ray from Music Box Films in a 1.78.1 widescreen transfer presented in AVC encoded 1080i high definition. This was shot in high definition digitally and as such, the image is clean and print damage, heavy grain and what can't ever be an issue. The image is a little flat looking. There's definitely more detail here than you'd get on DVD, but the colors are a little drab (some of which is due to the color scheme used in the production, this is an intentionally bleak looking production to begin with) and the blacks aren't quite as deep as you could hope they would be. With that said, the image is perfectly stable and free of compression artifacts (thankfully the three hundred minutes of material is spread across two discs). There are a few scenes where contrast runs a little hot but otherwise this looks okay, just not amazing.

Sound:

The only audio option for the film is a Japanese language DTS-HD 2.0 Stereo Master Audio track with options subtitles provided in English only. This is a quiet, dialogue driven presentation so the stereo mix suits the content just fine and it's hard to imagine a surround mix adding a whole lot, at least outside of the few scenes that are a bit more involved in that regard. As such, the track suits Penance just fine. Dialogue is well balanced and comes through without issue while the score and effects are mixed in at appropriate levels to ensure that the performers aren't ever buried in the mix. Hiss and distortion are never a problem, this track is fine.

Extras:

The main extra feature for this release is a selection of twenty-three minutes of interviews featuring director Kiyoshi Kurosawa, Kyoko Koizumi and Teruyuki Kagawa, Yu Aoi, Eiko Koike, Sakura Ando and Chizuru Ikewaki. There's some discussion of the actors' respeective characters here as well as some input from Kuorsawa as to what he was going for and hoping to accomplish with this production. Aside from that we get a trailer for Penance, menus and chapter selection. There's also a booklet inside with essay from Tom Mes and David Borwell.

Final Thoughts:

The resolution to the actual mystery that drives Penance isn't particularly satisfying but the buildup in certain chapters leading up to it can and sometimes does work quite well. As a whole, it's uneven but there's enough here that does successfully pull us into the longer storyline and this is helped by some strong performances, some coy directorial choices and a fair bit of style. The Blu-ray isn't reference quality but it looks and sounds decent enough with most of the issues seeming to be source related, a few moderately interesting interviews help out here too. Is this something you'll watch more than once? Tough to say, cautious buyers may want to rent first but Kurosawa should feel pretty confident with a recommendation.

Ian lives in NYC with his wife where he writes for DVD Talk, runs Rock! Shock! Pop!. He likes NYC a lot, even if it is expensive and loud.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Recommended

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links