DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
HD DVD / Blu-ray
International DVDs
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds

Sponsored Links
Search: For:
Reviews » Blu-ray Reviews » Peter Pan (1924) (Blu-ray)
Peter Pan (1924) (Blu-ray)
Kino // Unrated // July 9, 2019 // Region Free
List Price: $29.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Adam Tyner | posted July 26, 2019 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Printer Friendly
1924's Peter Pan is not only noteworthy for being the first film adaptation of J.M. Barrie's legendary play about a boy who couldn't bring himself to grow up – it's also the only of these many adaptations to have been produced in Barrie's lifetime. And the playwright indeed was closely involved in the project, having supplied extensive notes to Famous Players-Lasky about his vision for the film and even selecting the actress who'd don Peter's iconic tights. And while there's something to be said about being first, about its extraordinary success at the box office, and that it's rather a miracle that we're able to watch the film at all these many decades later, by far the most remarkable thing about this Peter Pan is its enduring magic.

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

For those best acquainted with the story of Peter Pan courtesy of Disney's animated adaptation, elements of the silent classic that predates it may come as quite a shock. I've grown accustomed to adaptations being in a breathless rush to leave the Darlings' home and soar to Never Never Land as quickly as possible. Here, the entirety of the first act is set in and around the children's bedroom, not flying anywhere near the second star on the right until after the half hour mark. We get to spend quite a bit more time with Mr. and Mrs. Darling (Cyril Chadwick and Esther Ralston), and it's especially intriguing to see what a prankster the irascible father can be, with a lengthy series of gags revolving around decidedly unpleasant tasting medicine.

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

And while Mr. Darling still very much takes issue with Nana ruling the roost, other elements would change significantly in the animated version with which I'm most familiar. There's never any talk of Wendy (Mary Brian) having grown too old to continue sharing a room with her young brothers. As many bedtime stories as Wendy has told, none of them involve Peter Pan (Betty Bronson) or the fantastic land he calls home. None of the Darling children had so much as heard of Peter until he flies into their nursery in search of his shadow. Here, we even get to see how distraught Mr. and Mrs. Darling are as they watch their children soar off towards the horizon.

And while those who know and love Peter Pan will recognize many of the beats of the plot from there – Tinker Bell (Virginia Brown Faire) duping The Lost Boys into shooting down that Wendy Bird! Captain Hook (Ernest Torrence) and his band of pirates kidnapping Tiger Lily (Anna May Wong)! Mermaids! A ticking crocodile! A climactic battle aboard the Jolly Roger! – this adaptation is infused with its own distinct brand of magic, never feeling like something I've already watched time and again.

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

It's fascinating how Peter Pan's effects work continues to endure after nearly a century, adopting many tricks from the original stage performances. I can't help but be charmed by George Ali's exceptionally memorable performance as Nana, the family dog-slash-nursemaid, aided greatly by a costume allowing for such expressiveness. Even if I can occasionally see the wire harnesses that allow Peter and the Darling children to take flight, there's something remarkably smooth and elegant about the way they soar in the air. Given how terrific it looks all these decades later, I can easily imagine wide-eyed children at the time marveling at the sight. You will believe a boy can fly! The wee fairy Tinker Bell is realized at times by a living, breathing actress, thanks to some inspired camerawork, production design, and optical wizardry. But it brings such a smile to my face to see that even a light bobbing around on a fish line can be so utterly convincing. That there's something tactile there makes Tink feel all the more present.

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

I love nearly everything about Peter Pan: the entrancing effects, the beautiful set design, the size and scope of the battle royale aboard the Jolly Roger, the intertitles that incorporate so much of Barrie's brilliant dialogue, and especially its delightful performances, even if the two Darling boys aren't left with particularly distinct personalities. Much like the the original play, those in the audience aren't just passive onlookers – we're part of the story too! Tinker Bell needs our help, and Peter breaks the fourth wall to draw on the power of our belief. At the same time, the heavy-handed American patriotism is rather at odds with a story I think of as being so inexorably British. And golly, there sure is a lot of kissing! One of the chief conflicts of the film is that Wendy is enamoured with Peter, but despite her best efforts, he looks to her only as a substitute mother. Peter's backstory and emotional tumult are a more significant part of this adaptation as well.

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

Though this silent adaptation runs nearly a half hour longer than Disney's animated classic, the pacing is exceptionally nimble for much of Peter Pan. It certainly doesn't feel as if we don't leave the nursery for more than a half hour, in particular. The energy does languish in the unnecessarily extended finalé, disappointingly, though I suppose any return to normalcy would be a steep comedown after the awe and adventure of Never Never Land. But such concerns are remarkably few in number. I can't recall the last time I was so wholly entranced by the magic of a film as I found myself with this adaptation. As wholly and completely as the medium has changed over these past 95 years – from the advent of sync sound to modern-day digital sorcery – the awe and wonder that Peter Pan inspires hasn't diminished in the slightest. Highly Recommended.

Peter Pan was for many years believed to have been lost – the same unfortunate end as untold thousands of other films from the silent era – until a 35mm print was unexpectedly rediscovered in 1971*. (Though some sources cite the date as being in the early 1950s, including the "American Cinematographer" article reproduced in this release's liner notes.) That print, coupled with a 16mm print later unearthed in Disney's archives, formed the basis for a restoration in the mid-'90s. Despite being generations removed from the original camera negative, this presentation of Peter Pan is frequently stunning:

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

Though the elements available prevent Peter Pan from soaring to the same heights as the most striking silent films on Blu-ray, its limitations never detract from the overall experience. The image is still sufficiently crisp and detailed to be immediately recognizable as high definition. Its filmic texture is as fine as could be reasonably hoped for, given the circumstances, and I'm not left with any concerns about digital artifacting or the like. A myriad of light scratches are often visible, though the eye is primarily drawn towards them on the intertitles. Though very much present, wear isn't terribly intrusive otherwise, as you've likely already noted in the screenshots throughout this review. The vignetting around the edges of the frame is, of course, to be expected, nor does the flickering pose a meaningful distraction. And while the original tinting isn't to my tastes, it does help to visually distinguish between locations, especially when cross-cutting between, say, the Lost Boys' Forest of Make-Believe and the camp of Tiger Lily's tribe.

To even assign a 'Video' score to Peter Pan seems unfair, given how miraculous it is that, nearly a full century after its original release, we're able to experience the film at all. Yet despite these unavoidable limitations, I don't feel the need to grade on much of a curve. This is a lovely presentation, and I have no doubt that it's a deeply rewarding upgrade over the previous DVD release as well.

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

Peter Pan arrives on a BD-25 disc at an aspect ratio close to 1.37:1.

The score that Philip C. Carli composed and conducted with the Flower City Society Orchestra in 1996 is presented here in 16-bit, uncompressed stereo. The instrumentation is impressively clear and distinct, and I can't help but marvel at how deftly Carli captures Peter Pan's whimsy and sense of adventure. It's especially fun in the aftermath of the pirates' siege on the "redskin" camp, mirroring Hook pounding on the tom tom drum and the faux-tribal victory whoops. Another highlight is the wood block that cleverly represents the clock presaging the crocodile's appearances. Woven in with Carli's original compositions are elements of Sir Henry Bishop's "Home! Sweet Home" – diagetically, as Mrs. Darling plays it on piano – and a triumphant "America (My Country, 'Tis of Thee)".

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

Being a silent film, it follows that there are no English subtitles. Those in need should note that Peter Pan's intertitles have not been translated into any other languages. Also included is the feature-length commentary discussed below.

  • Audio Commentary: The thesis statement of Kat Ellinger's commentary is that, as entertaining and enduring as these numerous incarnations of Peter Pan have proven to be for over a century, they're more impactful still when viewers understand J.M. Barrie as a man. And that is very much the primary focus of this discussion, to a far greater extent than the film itself. Indeed, Ellinger brilliantly establishes just how much Peter Pan owes to Barrie's difficult childhood, troubled marriage, and unconventional bond with the Llewelyn Davies boys. Also discussed are the expensive production of a play that Barrie was effectively offering to give away, producers' concerns about its conflicting tones and lack of tailoring towards any particular demographic, why young women were traditionally cast in the title role, and the etymology of Peter Pan's name itself.

    When the conversation turns towards this first feature film adaptation, Ellinger lays the groundwork into the disreputable state of the industry at the time, a particularly disastrous episode while filming the Jolly Roger exteriors, its staggering success at the box office, and how little is said about the film in Barrie biographies. Casting is a frequent touchpoint, from Mary Pickford having to publicly dismiss rumors that she was starring in the film to the all-but-unknown Betty Bronson being cast in such an iconic role. This is such an outstanding commentary, though it's worth reiterating to potential listeners again that the film itself is not the dominant topic of discussion.
[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]
  • Esther Ralston Interviewed by Robert McKay (31 min.; audio only): Peter Pan is discussed only briefly in this half hour interview, which prefers instead to paint a vivid picture of the Silent Era and Hollywood's Golden Age: what distinguishes Ralston's favorite directors from those best forgotten, the recording of dialogue in the nascent days of talkies, her salaries throughout these years, her brushes with some of the industry's biggest names, and being blacklisted industry-wide by MGM. And even if Peter Pan is not a focal point, the film is a part of one of Ralston's most memorable – and painful! – stories.

  • Esther Ralston Remembers Meeting Mary Brian (1 min.; audio only): The second of these audio-only conversations revolves around Ralston being so charmed by Mary Brian at a beauty pageant and how surprised she was when they were soon co-starring in Peter Pan.

The enclosed booklet features "Peter Pan Escapes Cinematic Neverland", which Frederick C. Szebin wrote for "American Cinematographer" back in 1995. Among a variety of other topics, the article touches on some of the fantastic elements Barrie originally envisioned for this film adaptation that ultimately didn't make it in.

Also of note is that Peter Pan is an all-region release.

The Final Word
Even after nearly a century, the first of Peter Pan's many film adaptations remains among its greatest – boasting charms, thrills, and a boundless imagination that continue to dazzle these many decades later. Highly Recommended.
Find the lowest price for 'Peter Pan (1924) (Blu-ray)'
Popular Reviews
1. Bruce Lee: His Greatest Hits
2. The Lady Eve: Criterion Collection
3. Clueless Anniversary Limited Edition Steelbook (Blu-ray + Digital)
4. Soldier Blue
5. Black Rainbow
6. The War of the Worlds (1953)
7. Beanpole
8. Spaced Invaders (Special Edition)
9. Deanna Durbin Collection (100 Men and a Girl / Three Smart Girls Grow Up / It Started with Eve)
10. Sorry We Missed You

Sponsored Links
DVD Blowouts
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
Sponsored Links
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2020 All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use