The Cranes are Flying
The Criterion Collection // Unrated // $29.95 // April 30, 2002
Review by Matt Langdon | posted May 1, 2002
DVD Talk Collector Series
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Graphical Version
The Soviet film The Cranes are Flying is one of the most cinematically compelling films in the history of cinema but for some reason it is not yet well known. Perhaps it is because it was made in the Soviet Union in 1957 – a few years after the death of Stalin – a time when the United States was deeply distrustful of anything that came out of a Communist country: Especially a film, which could potentially have a message involved.

The film – directed by Mikhail Kalatozov – is a tragic tale about a young love that is interrupted by World War II. Veronica (Tatiana Samoilova) and Boris (Alexei Batalov) are madly in love and engaged to be married but when the war comes along Boris decides to volunteer. He reluctantly leaves and Veronica pines for his return. She waits a long time and when she doesn't hear from him after a year she begins to assume that he may have died. So she halfhearted marries Boris' cousin. Yet, she still longs for his return.

The plot is pretty straightforward but the highly stylized way it is told through fabulous cinematography and sharply expressive editing makes the film a must see for anyone interested in landmark foreign films. The cinematography was done by Sergei Urusevsky who shot four films with Kalatozov (the most notable of which is I Am Cuba). Together the director and the DP impressively use chiaroscuro black & white, deep focus cinematography along with wide angle lenses, long handheld tracking shots, crane shots, low, high and Dutch angles. It's as if they set out to wow the audience as much as Orson Welles and Gregg Toland did with Citizen Kane.

But the visuals do more than astound the audience; they tell the story too. The long tracking shots add a certain tension that cannot be achieved through normal editing. And, quite often, the editing is used to pointed effect to create a particular mental state that the characters are feeling. The style in this case is enough to keep the film from being bogged down in its otherwise slight story.

Some of the splendid handheld and camera crane work is done in Chapter 6 when Veronica looks for Boris in a large crowd of people. A striking lighting sequence is on display in Chapter 8 when a bombing raid and a domestic quarrel take place simultaneously. And Chapter 10 has battlefield scenes that utilize both long tracking shots and triple super-imposed shots. A dynamic experimental film sequence is used in Chapter 14 when Veronica runs in a mad dash, considers suicide and then saves a young boy from being hit in the street by a truck.

Other than the cinematic style there are two things about The Cranes are Flying that make it rise above its simple plot. One is the fact that Veronica – who is the main character of the film – is not loyal to her fiancι. Where most films would put her in a bad light this one is sympathetic to her betrayal. The other – and most remarkable – thing about the film is that it was made at all since it takes such a stance against a lot of the Communist nationalism of the Soviet Union. The film takes a stab at blind patriotism and clearly shows that such a stance can ruin individual relationships. Chances are though the censors were so besotted by the cinematic splendor (as well as the half-hearted nationalistic ending) that they let it pass.

The audio track is in Russian 1.0 Dolby Digital mono track and was mastered using 24-bit restoration. Many of the cracks and hisses that are prone to build up on old films have been removed. Overall the audio sounds very good. The music is very full when it soars and swells and the dialogue is clear and there is no detectable background hiss.

The DVD is presented in the original format 1.33:1 and was struck from a 35mm fine-grain print made in Russia. The transfer looks great and it shows off the high contrasts of the black & white cinematography. The print was also cleaned up removing many nicks and scratches. There is very little detectable edge enhancement or compression artifact.

There are no extras on the disc. There is however a four page essay on the inside cover written by Chris Fujiwara.

The Criterion Collection's DVD of The Cranes are Flying is a must for anyone interested in Soviet Cinema or landmark foreign language films. It tells neither a Communist nor a Capitalist tale but instead a simple (some would say simplistic) human story albeit in extraordinary ways. It looks great, sounds very good and is impressive enough to watch again and again - especially if you are into dynamic film editing and breathtaking cinematography. This is the kind of DVD that you use to impress your friends. Just invite them over on a rainy night place the DVD in the player, fill everyone's glass with vodka and their bowls with borscht, then kick back and enjoy.

Copyright 2020 Inc. All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy is a Trademark of Inc.