Adaptation of Sondheim's fairy tales is two-thirds great
Loves: Movie musicals, Anna Kendrick
Likes: Broadway musicals, fairy tales, Chris Pine, Johnny Depp
Dislikes: Inconsistent tone, unbalanced musical structure
Hates: Dull climaxes
The core of the story is the Baker (new The Late Late Show host James Corden) and his wife (Emily Blunt), a childless couple tasked with a quest by the witch next door (Meryl Streep.) If they ever hope to add a baby to their family, as she cursed their house for a long-ago wronging on the part of the Baker's father, they have three days to acquire four items for her: "the cow as white as milk, the cape as red as blood, the hair as yellow as corn, and the slipper as pure as gold." Anyone with a decent knowledge of fairy tales should have an idea of who these items relate to, especially after the film's opening prologue introduces you to three of them--Anna Kendrick as Cinderella, Daniel Huddlestone's Jack and Little Red Riding Hood, played by Lilla Crawford (the fourth isn't hard to guess.) The Baker and his wife act like the connective tissue of the film, bringing together all the well-known characters during the course of the plot.
The film is somewhat episodic, moving from meetup to meet-up, with songs acting as punctuation, and the witch's quest lending the action a natural structure. This is especially true in the film's first act, where the movie moves smoothly and comfortably, and the first 75 minutes or so fly by quickly, with a mix of fun and emotion, as the players are introduced, we learn their motivations and watch the characters make their way through the woods and their own specific stories, like Cinderella's visit to the Prince's ball and Little Red Riding Hood's trip to Grandma's house. There are a number of stand-out musical numbers in this portion, including the epic prologue "Into the Woods," "Agony," a fun, silly song about princely problems sung by the two princes (Chris Pine and Billy Magnussen, both quite funny) and "On the Steps of the Palace," an introspective tune from Cinderella, that lets Kendrick unleash her pipes. Even Johnny Depp, who has a small, but memorable part as the Wolf, acquits himself well in putting a creepy spin on "Hello Little Girl." No one is bad in anyway, with Corden making a big impression in his first big-time starring film role, Christine Baranski being a great choice as Cinderella's evil stepmother and the two kids, Huddlestone and Crawford, delivering pitch-perfect, classic Broadway-style performances.
The problem is the film doesn't end at the 75-minute mark, despite reaching a somewhat natural conclusion. There's a lot of story left from the show, exploring the consequences of the characters' actions in the first act, with Jack's well-known foes playing a big role. The film takes a hard left turn into much darker territory. The remaining 45 minutes are incredibly slow moving, and lack the highlight musical numbers of the first act, with the exception of the beautifully layered "Your Fault," which sees the characters turn on each other in groups, and some of the ending numbers. Because of how the plot progresses, which sees characters do unfavorable things and features some truly bummer revelations, the second act is far less enjoyable, and the fact that it moves like it's unreeling through molasses makes for a disappointing conclusion after the great first act. It's hard to blame that on director Rob Marshall (Chicago) who did a fine job in adapting the show, making some tough decisions and avoiding being slavishly faithful to the Broadway show. The problems that remain in his film version may be the reason why it took so long to bring Into the Woods to film.
The 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track is equally impressive, with the moments involving Jack's nemesis offering some of the best home-movie bass effects ever, with room-rocking low-end that truly drives home what's happening on-screen. The mix takes full advantage of the soundfield, moving effects and ambient sound around the surround speakers with pans and positioning in concert with the visuals to put the viewer right in the middle of the action. The voices are all excellently reproduced, along the powerful music, making for a first-class experience.
A great extra that should be included with every musical is the Music and Lyrics section, which lets you cue up any of the 17 songs in the film, with on-screen lyrics, or watch the film in its entirety with on-screen lyrics for the songs. For anyone who likes to sing along or who wants to revisit some classic musical numbers, this is a great inclusion and will certainly not result in dozens of consecutive viewings of Kendrick singing "On the Steps of the Palace."
For musical fans, particularly those who enjoy Sondheim, the inclusion of an all-new song written by the musical master is an exciting addition. "She'll Be Back" (4:48) sung by Streep as the witch, was intended to show the witch's emotions after she experiences a loss, but was cut when it negatively affected the film's already problematic pace. The song, which is fine, but no better than songs that made it into the film, is offered with a non-optional introduction from Marshall.
The remainder of the extras are featurettes, starting with "There's Something About the Woods" (13:23). This overview of the film, focusing on the titular woods and their importance to the story and film, includes interviews with all the major players and several members of the crew and covers everything in broad strokes.
The rest of the featurettes go into more detail, with "The Cast as Good as Gold" (10:10) naturally looking at the actors, using on-set footage and more interviews to talk about auditioning, rehearsing and Tracey Ullman's love of the cast's resident cow. The four-part "Deeper Into the Woods" (a combined 29:57) breaks down your usual behind-the-scenes material, with "From the Stage to the Screen" (the adaptation), "The Magic in the Woods" (a look at the creative process), "Designing the Woods" (the production design) and "The Costumes of the Woods" (the costumes, natch.) The majority of these pieces are made up of interviews, with some on-set clips and production documents. There are a few interesting notes to be found in these featurettes, including how new lyrics were written for some of the nearly 30-year-old songs and the inspiration for the various wardrobe designs.
Inside the package there's a download code.
The Bottom Line