Van Gogh (The Films of Maurice Pialat: Volume 3)
Cohen Film Collection // R // $30.99 // July 12, 2016
Review by Justin Remer | posted September 4, 2016
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
R E V I E W S
Graphical Version

The Movie:

Much like Mike Leigh's unfairly neglected artist portrait Mr. Turner, Maurice Pialat's excellent 1991 film Van Gogh does not attempt to squeeze its subject into a typical biopic mold; instead, it uses slice-of-life vignettes to conjure the famous painter as a flesh-and-blood man. Pialat's version of Vincent Van Gogh is unsurprisingly similar to the prickly, emotionally detached, and somewhat debauched protagonists of his earlier fiction films -- which are, for the most part, semi-autobiographical. Whether or not Pialat has chosen to re-fashion Van Gogh in his own image is up for debate (and probably beside the point), but Pialat has definitely transmogrified the last two months of Van Gogh's life into another uniquely personal, bold, and unexpected narrative.

When we first see rocker-turned-actor Jacques Dutronc, as Van Gogh, getting off a train in rural Auvers-sur-Oise, he seems gaunt and quiet -- humbled, even. He's had his major breakdown. He's cut his ear (although Pialat wisely avoids giving Dutronc distracting prosthetic scars) and been hospitalized. Now he just needs to recuperate. When the proprietor of his boarding house offers him wine, he declares that he doesn't drink.

Vincent visits the home of Dr. Gachet (Gérard Séty), who is an art collector and amateur painter. The doctor claims that there is nothing physically wrong with him, and that some rest should do him good. The doctor has a petulant teenage daughter, Marguerite (Alexandra London), who sits for Van Gogh a few times and then commences to flirt with and seduce the far-from-rehabilitated painter. Before too long, Van Gogh is indulging in too much booze, painting up a storm, and pondering giving in to the young woman's advances. A prostitute with whom he had a prior familiarity, Cathy (Elsa Zylberstein), also reappears in Vincent's life, creating a love triangle that helps to muddy his already not-very-clear mindset.

Pialat pairs this triangle with another, even more turbulent one. Vincent's brother Theo (Bernard Le Coq) and his wife Jo (Corinne Bourdon) both find themselves alternately drawn in and repelled by Vincent, as he tries to play them off each other for sympathy. Influential art dealer Theo, as has been oft-dramatized, loved and supported his brother, but failed to find him any commercial success in his lifetime, and their interactions in the film are fraught with rarely addressed resentments and growing bitterness.

Although Pialat's storytelling style is elliptical and resolutely matter-of-fact, he manages to bring all of his threads together in a relatively tense and emotional third act where Vincent bottoms out and must confront the repercussions of the emotional games he has been playing, with Marguerite and Cathy, and with Theo and Jo. Since Vincent's final recourse is already well-known, it is not much of a spoiler to reveal that he essentially refuses to face what he has done to those around him. But unlike Vincent, Pialat never flinches from digging into the messy psychological and emotional terrain of his subject matter.

Jacques Dutronc won the César (aka the "French Oscar") for his performance as Van Gogh, and it is a strikingly nuanced (and no doubt emotionally draining) acting job. In fact, the whole cast does fine work, and they fit elegantly into Pialat's melancholy and slightly drab canvas. Van Gogh is probably not the most factually accurate depiction of the painter, but it beautifully represents the intersection of Pialat and Van Gogh's shared artistry.

The Blu-ray
Van Gogh (The Films of Maurice Pialat: Volume 3) comes in a 2-BD set, with the feature film on the first disc and all the bonuses on the second.

The Video:
A slightly soft, but overall quite pleasing AVC-encoded 1080p 1.66:1 presentation. In matching Pialat's matter-of-fact approach, Emmanuel Machuel's photography has a typically naturalistic feel. Some outdoor sequences are a bit lush, with greenery looking quite vivid in the dappled sunlight. Minimal digital compression issues.

The Audio:
I'm not sure what happened. The European Blu-ray of this title has a lossless audio track but, like the films in Volume 1 and Volume 2 of Cohen's Maurice Pialat collections, this release offers only a lossy (448kbps) French Dolby 2.0 mono track (with optional English subtitles). There are no other significant examples of damage or glaring flaws apparent in this transfer.

Special Features:

  • Jacques Dutronc Interview (HD upscale, 21:29) - Dutronc puffs on a big stogie, sips red wine, and reflects casually on working with Pialat. He's slightly resigned when discussing the difficulties the two of them had (Pialat apparently micromanaged Dutronc's performance), and Dutronc's tone is one of grudging respect for the late filmmaker.

  • Bernard Le Coq Interview (HD, 31:40) - The actor who played Theo Van Gogh talks about how he was apprehensive to work with Pialat because of his reputation as a moody, combative director. But he claims that his experiences were okay and that his boss, rather than being a tyrant on Van Gogh, was just restlessly searching for the perfect moments.

  • Emmanuel Machuel Interview (HD, 24:22) - Machuel's experience working on films by Pialat's hero, Robert Bresson, got him the job as director of photography on Van Gogh. He admits now that he was unprepared to deal with Pialat's mercurial temperament. He talks about being fired from the film, re-hired, and then quitting, before describing some of the creative decisions that he and Pialat collaborated upon to achieve the sometimes naturalistic/sometimes stylized look of the film.

  • Xavier Giannoli Interview (HD, 40:25) - The director of 2015's Marguerite talks about his admiration for Maurice Pialat.

  • Deleted Scenes (HD upscale, 46:10) - Film editor Yann Dedet discusses the post-production refinement of the final story of Van Gogh for roughly fifteen minutes, before we are treated to a half hour of material deleted from the finished film.

  • Trailers - the original French and new Cohen re-release trailers.

Final Thoughts:
French iconoclast Maurice Pialat puts a lot of himself into this screen version of Vincent Van Gogh. Purists might blanch, but Pialat has such a knack for uncomfortable yet understated drama that the film is nothing short of a triumph. We may not want to be friends with this Van Gogh, but we can't look away either. Highly Recommended.



Copyright 2017 Kleinman.com Inc. All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy DVDTalk.com is a Trademark of Kleinman.com Inc.