Black Girl: Criterion Collection
Criterion // Unrated // $39.95 // January 24, 2017
Review by Justin Remer | posted February 9, 2017
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
R E V I E W S
Graphical Version

The Movie:

Ousmane Sembčne is a name that, sadly, is known only to the most hardcore fans of arthouse film. In the early '60s, Sembčne switched from writing novels to making films as a conscious effort to try to reach a non-elite audience. But local bans, plus bans from the French government, often kept the Senegalese filmmaker's work from reaching its intended audience.

Watching Sembčne's first feature from 1966, Black Girl (La Noire de...), it's easy to see why this director might end up on the wrong side of a government censor. With Senegal only a few years into its official independence, the film boldly refuses to paint a rosy picture of post-colonial life. The film tackles racism with powerful simplicity, by telling the tragic story of a young Senegalese woman who takes a job in France as a white couple's governess but ends up as a put-upon near-slave.

Diouana (Mbissine Thérčse Diop) is young, naive, and proud. When Diouana arrives in France at the beginning of the film, she is dressed in a flashy dress (a hand-me-down from her French employer, it turns out) as though she is ready to sample nightlife on the Riviera. Diouana encounters the first of many unpleasant surprises when she discovers the children she is meant to be watching are nowhere to be found. Her bosses, referred to only as the "Madame" and the "Monsieur" (Anne-Marie Jelinek and Robert Fontaine), never explain the children's absence but put Diouana to work, cleaning and doing household chores.

Diouana says very little to the Madame and the Monsieur, but Sembčne fills most of these quiet moments with Diouana's charged inner monologue. As she mops the floor, pointedly wearing jewelry and one of her party dresses, Diouana protests internally that she was not hired as a maid. As if as a rejoinder to this unheard complaint, the Madame tells Diouana to make a "nice" lunch for some guests who will be arriving shortly. She wasn't hired as a cook either, but why should that make a difference to the Madame?

The lunch scene is jaw-dropping in the way it portrays French whites flippantly discounting and degrading Diouana for being a black African. A lot of virtual ink has been spilled about whites asking to touch black women's hair, but those interactions pale when compared to the moment in this film where one of the lunch guests stands up and kisses Diouana in front of everyone because he's "never kissed a Negress before." Later, Madame lies when one of the guests asks if Diouana can speak French, and she implies that Diouana just intuits commands like an animal. Sembčne stages these interactions so off-handedly that they create a momentary disconnect: did I really just see that?

The film's action sticks largely to the confines of the tiny apartment, except for flashbacks to Diouana's time in Senegal. Sembčne creates an ironic juxtaposition between Diana's happy acceptance of work from the white family, plus her anticipation of moving to France, with the soul-crushing reality that she faces once she actually arrives. In Senegal, Madame is gracious, and Diouana is satisfied keeping an eye on her three kids. In France, Madame becomes a mercurial tyrant, and Diouana is forced to perform whatever tasks she decrees. (The Monsieur meanwhile seems more down-to-earth, but he chooses to pour himself into a bottle of cognac rather than confront his wife about her despicable behavior.) Sembčne does not use these flashbacks to portray Senegal as some kind of paradise lost, but one instead feels him gently implicating Diouana, and her impetuous decision to leave her family and friends for the promises of the white world, as a contribution to her own downfall.

Black Girl is powerful not just because it has a strong political viewpoint, but because Sembčne is an elegant storyteller. Not to be a cynic, but it's not hard to get angry when presented with social injustice. Sembčne's film hits hard because he successfully translates his righteous anger into a compact, compelling narrative that vibrates with acutely observed reality.

The Blu-ray
Black Girl is packaged with a fold-out booklet featuring an essay by Ashley Clark.

The Video:
Sourced from a 4K scan, it is little surprise that this AVC-encoded 1080p 1.37:1 transfer is an enormous improvement over the 2005 DVD. Christian Lacoste's cinematography feels of a piece with the half-stylized/half-off-the-cuff work of his contemporaries in the French New Wave, and this transfer translates the more exquisitely sculpted images and the more run-and-gun shots with equal effectiveness. Detail, depth, and contrast are all impressive. Some shots shows signs of irreparable spotting and damage, but the image is stable and clean for the most part.

The Audio:
The French LPCM mono audio (with optional English subtitles) is as crisply remastered as the video. Much of the dialogue was dubbed in later, so there is sometimes a bit of disconnect between the actors and their supposed voices, but there are no significant issues with damage or general audibility.

Special Features:

  • Samba Gadjigo on Ousmane Sembčne (HD, 19:52) - Gadjigo, who co-directed the documentary Sembene!, talks about Sembčne's place in history as the first major international filmmaker originating from Africa, and as a filmmaker driven by opposing the status quo.

  • Interview with M'Bissine Thérčse Diop (HD, 12:32) - Diop talks about acting in her first film for Sembčne, who was highly opinionated and exacting. Diop was focusing on being a dressmaker at the time and designed her own wardrobe for the film.

  • Manthia Diawara on Black Girl (HD, 21:37) - Cultural theorist and filmmaker Diawara talks about the tricky cultural place that the film occupied when it was originally presented, as a groundbreaking prestige picture originating from Senegal that also showed a lot of unpopular hard truths about Senegal and racism.

  • Color Sequence (HD, 1:09) - The original version of Diouana's opening car ride from the airport through France. It was shot in color but was later changed to match the rest of the black-and-white film

  • On the Prix Jean Vigo (HD upscale, 2:02) - An excerpt from the French TV show, JT de 20h, where Sembčne discusses winning the Prix Jean Vigo for Black Girl.

  • Borom Sarret (HD, 20:01) - Sembčne's directorial debut is an eloquent look at the day in the life of a poor cart driver, who hopes to bring home money for his wife and new baby and ends up going flat broke. It's a quiet tragedy that plays out casually, driven by the cart driver's internal monologue as he toughs it out through a day at work.

  • Manthia Diawara on Borom Sarret (HD, 12:36) - Diawara talks about the way Sembčne managed to create a thorough cross-section of life in African cities with a seemingly simple short film.

  • Sembčne: The Making of African Cinema (HD upscale, 1:00:38) - A feature-length documentary from 1994, directed by Manthia Diawara and Ng?g? wa Thiong'o, that follows Sembčne around, as he discusses the political situation in Senegal and how his body of work has been a reaction to that.

  • Trailer

Final Thoughts:
This beautifully restored and thoroughly supplemented release of Black Girl serves as an excellent introduction to the fiery filmography of Senegalese director Ousmane Sembčne. Highly Recommended.



Copyright 2017 Kleinman.com Inc. All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy DVDTalk.com is a Trademark of Kleinman.com Inc.