Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info



Columbia/Tri-Star // R // November 8, 2005
List Price: $24.96 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Svet Atanasov | posted October 21, 2005 | E-mail the Author

The film

She (Joan Allen) is a lonely middle-aged American wife living a life full of lies and disappointments. He (Simon Abkarian) is a dark and handsome Lebanese man working as a chef in a local restaurant. She is tired of patching up a marriage where illusions are the only thing left to share. He is no longer capable of staying quiet when people question his religion. She is bound to meet him. He is bound to meet her. What follows up is a love story between two people willing to test what fate has to offer.

YES is simple, beautiful, and poetic. It is a film that asks many questions yet it hardly offers any answers. Love, God, sex, politics, and racism, are all entangled in an explosive mix where the viewer is asked not to expect a logical climax but to observe. The viewer is asked to analyze. And I did. I followed the innocent rendezvous between She and He, I listened to the rhymed dialog the film is built upon, and I laughed on the subtle yet aggressive statements director Sally Potter has snuck in attempting to enrage the dormant idealist in me.

YES is without a doubt a film of contrasts. You would either love the fact that it plays with your senses provoking edgy comments or you would hate it for the sake of being different, being a film that defies standard clichés. After all no one talks in rhymes, why would the director imitate Shakespeare in a film that deals with contemporary issues? Maybe because they are not so contemporary after all, maybe because Shakespeare still has something to teach us, or maybe because every once in awhile we need to see a film where the acting, the plot, the way the actors talk, are meant to wake up an audience accustomed to the typical for our cineplexes ninety minutes of "unpredictable storytelling" a.k.a boredom.

This is a film that reminded me a lot about Baz Luhrman's rendition of Romeo and Juliet and I am sure I am not the only one that liked its witty style. The unusual approach which Sally Potter has used to put together a story where two people learn to love each other by beating the odds fate has to offer really struck a chord with me. Imagine how boring of a picture YES would have been if we had yet another "updated" version of When Harry Met Sally where a bored and sexually frustrated woman in her early 40s meets a foreign man working as a chef in London? We would get the usual talk, the predictable "he is willing, she is not", and of course the favorite for Hollywood lesson of "we told you so, having an affair with a single man with an accent is bad". O, yes I think I've seen this film before. Instead we are introduced to two characters that think and more importantly speak with their hearts…using the verses Shakespeare would.

I do not wish to make outrageous parallels with classic visual directors such as Antonioni and Kar-Wai but Sally Potter's YES certainly offers something we don't get to see that often in our local theaters. The film blends together the audaciousness of a genuine theater play with the visual power of a timeless classic extremely well. Add to the mix an excellent group of actors that transforms YES into an intelligent modern tale of love and survival and you have a film that certainly should make your "most-wanted" list this month.

Sally Potter's YES is the winner of the Seattle Golden Space Neelde Award which was granted during the Seattle International Film Festival earlier this year.

How Does the DVD Look? Presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 and enhanced for widescreen TV's YES looks very good offering tight image, great color palette, and only a small degree of edge enhancement. Blown-out via a digital projector the print shows a few minor problems such as macro-blocking which is not overly distracting but it is certainly there. I don't think you would notice it if you view the DVD on a regular tube but it is there and for those of you with more sensitive equipments you might occasionally spot it. Aside from that, which I regard as a very minor issue with this transfer, I am extremely pleased with the picture quality offered on this disc. Overall, a good if not excellent presentation from SONY.

How Does the DVD Sound? Presented with its original English track (5.1 Dolby Digital) the audio presentation is certainly on par with the video quality. I don't have anything to report in terms of audio drop-outs or any other faults that might distract your viewing of the film. With optional French subtitles. Well done indeed!

Extras: The following extra materials are included on this DVD:

Finding Scene 54- a semi documentary feature following the filming of YES-

Behind the Scenes photo gallery- a few selected shots from the filming of YES-

Previews for other SONY releases-

Final thought: A witty, original, and extremely sensual film YES offers a unique cinematic experience with a very interesting narrative. I especially liked the fact that Sally Potter has chosen to structure the dialog in a manner evoking parallels with Shakespeare and his work. This is certainly a film that will raise a few eyebrows among those that like their cinema with a few extra drops of unconventionality. And of course there will be those that will disregard it as a pretentious and too challenging attempt in creativity. I certainly belong to the first group…I love it when films such as YES ask intelligent questions and force their viewers to second-guess the actions of the main protagonists. RECOMMENDED.

Buy from







E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links