|Reviews & Columns|
TV on DVD
Reviews by Studio
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
The M.O.D. Squad
DVD Talk Forum
DVD Price Search|
Customer Service #'s
Strike: Remastered Edition
Russian filmmaker Sergei Eisenstein's 1925 debut Strike is an auspicious arrival for the man who is largely credited with establishing the art of the montage. This silent tour-de-force is a political drama, part historical document and part propaganda device. Scripted by four different writers and originally intended as the beginning of a larger series detailing the workers' struggle in early 20th-century Russia, it re-creates a real factory uprising from 1903, but the filmmaker inflates the terrible battle to an epic scale, making history into filmic art.
In terms of plot, though Eisenstein divides the story into six different chapters, it's actually far more simple than that. Strike can pretty much be broken down into three acts: the events leading to the walk-out, the long wait for the people's demands to be considered and the toll it takes on the striking families, and the final clash after the demands are rejected. Within this, Eisenstein details all facets of life, from the homeless criminal to the common working family and all the way up to the fatcats that pull the purse strings. The director even takes time for the smallest creatures among us: pets and stray animals, and also children. The footage of poverty could almost be passed off as documentary; Eisenstein and his trio of cinematographers stage the scenes with an eye toward realism, photographing all the squalor in order to make their case for better conditions for the common populace. On the flipside, Strike's depiction of the upper classes borders on caricature. The bosses embody a cartoon villainy, wasting food while their underlings starve and laughing at their misery.
While the young filmmaker displays an extraordinary facility for visual metaphor, at this stage in his development, Eisenstein is also prone to overdoing it. Whether this was the result of youthful folly or a conciliation to the propaganda machine is hard to say. Strike paints the picture of a vast conspiracy amongst the government and men of means. Undercover agents sneak through the workforce, spying on them and reporting any questionable activities. Eisenstein gives each of the covert infiltrators an animal code name and then proceeds to not only have the actors embody their monikers, but also cross-cuts their activity with images of the actual animals, layering their faces using double exposure and fades. It oversells the point a little, especially when one agent, nicknamed "Bulldog," is shown panting and drooling as if he were an actual dog. In other instances, when the animal imagery is better integrated into the story--the starving kitten scavenging amongst the suffering masses; the slaughter of livestock as tempers flare--the juxtaposition packs way more punch.
Strike doesn't follow too many central characters. The spies, the factory owners, and a few of the workers make regular appearances, but Eisenstein treats each group of people within the clash as if they were individuals, underscoring the rallying cry for unity amidst the classes. Some of the large-scale crowd scenes are breathtaking. A brutal raid on an impoverished tenement plays out on a variety of physical levels, as police on horseback drive residents from the top floors down to the bottom. Likewise, the scenes of crowds moving on the factory are astonishing. The orchestration of such a massive cast shows how vital cinema was as an art form right from the get-go. There were no limits.
Eisenstein also tries out many different camera tricks and experimental effects, favoring cross-fades and images within images to tie different aspects of his tale together. This affinity for transitions lends Strike an editorial agility, infusing the realistic storytelling with a sense of peril and melodrama. The director's reliance on exaggeration also gives Strike occasional notes of surrealism. In one sequence, a diplomat has midgets dancing on a table as background entertainment; in another, a whole community of squatters reveals themselves by popping out of holes in an underground shantytown Eisenstein pointedly dubs a "graveyard." These touches ensure that not only is Strike visually inspiring, but also that its intended message never overshadows its primary role as entertainment. Strike is as vivacious today as it must have been nearly a century ago.
Please note: The screen images are taken from Christopher McQuain's review of the standard definition DVD, not the Blu-Ray. Read his take on Strike here.
The Blu-Ray edition of Strike has been made using the original 35 mm elements from a restoration of the movie put together by the Cinematheque de Toulouse, and the job Kino has done transferring the material to home video deserves much praise. The black-and-white photography is given a gorgeous showcase in high-definition. The image is a crisp 1920x1080p, shown in full frame, with very little visible damage--certainly far less than we could have ever expected previously for a film this old. Details are rendered sharply, and the cinematography is shown to have incredible depth. There are likewise no signs of digital enhancement or pixilation.
Strike is accompanied by a two-channel orchestra soundtrack put together by the Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra using material from classic Russian composers. The music sounds remarkably fresh and accompanies the image well. Title cards are presented in English and are nicely designed so as not to appear anachronistic. Onscreen text is translated via subtitles.
Bonus features on Strike are not high in number, but the content is strong.
Leading the charge is the first film Eisenstein ever shot, a 4-minute short subject from 1923 called Glumov's Diary. It's a playful short, primarily concerned with experimenting with special effects, but also showing Eisenstein's knack for commentary and satire. The bigger meaning of his comparisons between clowns and weaponry has maybe been lost between cultures and across the span of time, but at such a brief running time, the gleeful presentation doesn't wear out its welcome.
The second bonus is a 37-minute documentary from 2008 called Eisenstein and the Revolutionary Spirit. It features historian Natacha Laurent from the Cinematheque de Toulouse talking about the historical and artistic confluences that established the cinematic arts in Russia, leading up to Eisenstein and Strike. She lays out the arc of his career and his lasting influence, as well as some of the lingering misconceptions regarding his work under Stalin. The piece features a ton of clips not just from Eisenstein's films (and showing just how good the restoration of Strike is by comparison), but also his contemporaries.
Also on the disc are the trailer for Kino's release of Battleship Potemkin. Strike is housed in a standard Blu-Ray case with an outer slipcover.
Highly Recommended. Strike isn't just an important piece of cinema history, it's also a damn good movie. Sergei Eisenstein's epic portrayal of the working class rising up against their factory bosses spans the lines of fiction and propaganda, making for a moving docudrama that shows the innovative young director stretching the boundaries of silent film. The restoration job on this Blu-Ray is exceptional, and the extras are well chosen. Strike is a definite must-have release.
Jamie S. Rich is a novelist and comic book writer. He is best known for his collaborations with Joelle Jones, including the hardboiled crime comic book You Have Killed Me, the challenging romance 12 Reasons Why I Love Her, and the 2007 prose novel Have You Seen the Horizon Lately?, for which Jones did the cover. All three were published by Oni Press. His most recent projects include the futuristic romance A Boy and a Girl with Natalie Nourigat; Archer Coe and the Thousand Natural Shocks, a loopy crime tale drawn by Dan Christensen; and the horror miniseries Madame Frankenstein, a collaboration with Megan Levens. Follow Rich's blog at Confessions123.com.