Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info


Fish Story

Pathfinder Home Entertainment // Unrated // December 27, 2011
List Price: $24.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Tyler Foster | posted February 23, 2012 | E-mail the Author
This is the story of my solitude / If my solitude were a fish

Fish Story represents an evolution in a problem I feel is becoming more prevalent in movies, which is that directors have an idea but not a story. An idea is enough to begin a film, but unless you have a story, you don't have a driving force, and often no beginning, middle, or end, resulting in too many films that have plenty of great moments reinforcing or playing off of the idea, and a bunch of filler surrounding those moments, all leading towards a less-than-satisfying conclusion that's not so much a resolution as it is a stopping point. Fish Story trumps those films in that the resolution of the story may be its most satisfying aspect, but there's an inherent disconnect in the structure of the film and the way it builds to its finale that hurt it more than help it.

The film takes place in 2012, five hours before a giant comet will crash into Earth and wipe out the human race, and flashes back to 1975, 1982, 1999, and 2009 to fill in crucial blanks. The lynchpin of the stories is a song called "Fish Story," which a record store owner in 2012 (Nao Omori) is convinced is the secret to survival. "Champions of justice will save humanity," he says calmly, putting on the record for the shop's one increasingly frantic customer (Kenichi Takito), and the pessimistic old man who's wandered in off the street to warn them of the impending crisis (Kenjiro Ishimaru). "This song will save the day." Over the course of the four flashback sequences, we are introduced to the band who recorded the song (Atsushi Ito, Kengo Kora, Toshimitsu Okawa, and Kiyohiko Shibukawa), concerned more then with creative differences with their record company and the likelihood that the band is about to break up; to Kentaro (Takashi Yamanaka), Satoru (Kazuki Namioka) and Masashi (Gaku Hamada), who are off to meet Haruko (Mai Takahashi) and some other girls for drinks; and to Masami (Mikako Tabe), a schoolgirl who falls asleep on a boat and meets a justice-minded chef (MIrai Moriyama) and ends up in the middle of a hijacking.

Without spoiling the film, the joy of Fish Story is the resolution, executed by director Yoshihiro Nakamura like a bit of cinematic sleight of hand, producing something from what appeared to be nothing at the last minute. Nakamura's direction within each of these segments is also effective, creating a palpable bit of horror movie tension in 1982 when Kentaro, Satoru and Masashi listen to "cursed" cassette tapes, or a bit of romantic tension and action thrills between Satoru and Masashi in 2009 when the hijackers make their move. The longest segment, 1975, drags a little in dealing with the band's internal struggles, but there's a nice dry humor and wistfulness to the way the band bembers, accompanied by their manager (Omori again), quietly work together on an artistic swan song.

At the same time, however, Nakamura's magic trick is still a trick: in telling a story that purposefully stays out of focus for much of the runtime, Fish Story becomes a film that is less about the people in it and more about a series of moments or events. Slight focus is given to a few characters, but none of them really register as protagonists, and even the ones that get the closest are abandoned on the verge before the film is onto something else. The film was adapted from a novel by Kotaro Isaka, and it seems possible that a multi-story structure would've worked better in a book, where the reader is allowed more insight into each character than the film is able to encompass.

All things considered, Fish Story is a double-edged sword. Despite a heavy helping of invention and inspiration, I found that the the empty core of the film left something to be desired, and that I may have felt more strongly about what the movie was lacking than what it had to offer. I am reminded of the quote by Gertrude Stein: "There is no there there."

Fish Story is saddled with weak cover art that fails to hint at the lighthearted tone of the film, suggesting...I don't know, a teen drama, with the cast members arranged in a random clump with stock photos of drums and a guitar lazily slapped in front. I'm also not sure what's up with the pull quote comparing it to Irreversible and Memento, either... The artwork is inside a standard cheap DVD case, and there is no insert.

The Video and Audio
Sadly, the presentation by Pathfinder Video is severely lacking. For starters, the film is presented in 1.85:1 non-anamorphic widescreen, and the resulting image is plagued with aliasing, faint blocking/artifacting, especially in dark scenes, and a washed-out color palette that makes blacks look gray. Fine detail is significantly lacking (look at the back shelves of the record shop, which are mess), and there is some interlacing going on as well. Burned-in English subtitles are only the icing on the video cake. Adding insult to injury, this film -- which, mind you, is built around a song -- is presented in Japanese Dolby Digital 2.0, which is fine but audibly lacks the depth and layering that a 5.1 track would've offered. I understand there are sometimes limitations in bringing foreign films to the United States in terms of the elements offered by the distributor, but this still feels like a pretty underwhelming effort given that Fish Story is a new film.

The Extras
None, other than the film's original theatrical trailer.

There are certainly more reasons to recommend Fish Story than not: Nakamura has obvious talent, and the film is constructed very well, offering plenty of stylistic bang for the viewer's buck; the entertainment value of the film is pretty high. Beyond that, however, there is something missing from the film that can't be ignored, some final element to tie it all together, and there's a part of me that wishes I loved the film as opposed to liking it.

Please check out my other DVDTalk DVD, Blu-ray and theatrical reviews and/or follow me on Twitter.
Buy from







E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links