Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Man With a Movie Camera

Kino // Unrated // February 16, 2021
List Price: $29.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Justin Remer | posted February 24, 2021 | E-mail the Author

The Movie and the Audio:

I'm breaking slightly from the standard review form here, because my response to Kino's new Blu-ray of Dziga Vertov's 1929 film Man with a Movie Camera is specific to this edition. If any of you readers have spent time in a film school -- especially a traditional, establishment film school -- you've likely seen at least a clip of Man with a Movie Camera. It is a fundamental text in the history of filmmaking. A documentary that transcends the genre, Man with a Movie Camera uses dozens of experimental techniques that push the film away from narrative conventions and toward the abstraction of poetry and music.

Kino's Blu-ray comes from a British Film Institute presentation of this silent Soviet classic that is set to a musical score by Michael Nyman, best known as a frequent collaborator of Peter Greenaway and the composer for Jane Campion's The Piano. It's an audio/visual marriage made in hell. Nyman's music often ignores the nuances of Vertov and editor Elizaveta Svilova's visual rhythm, trying to override it with a new rhythm and a dissonant atmosphere. Of course, there are moments where the score seems to work with the film. It's natural that sometimes it should. After all, you can play Dark Side of the Moon while watching The Wizard of Oz and sometimes that seems to sync up too.

There's nothing deficient in the LPCM 2.0 stereo audio presentation on the disc, so my low audio score in the sidebar is purely related to my dislike for this music. Nyman's minimalist compositions, when placed against Vertov's visuals of people at work and machinery in action, can't help but feel like a self-conscious knock-off of Philip Glass's score for Koyaaniqatsi. That comparison isn't fair to Nyman, to Glass, or to Dziga Vertov, but I calls 'em like I sees 'em. So, if you watch this version of Man with a Movie Camera, I'd recommend putting something else on as soundtrack. (Hey, maybe Dark Side of the Moon? Couldn't hurt to try, right?)

Also, turn off the subtitles. The optional English SDH track is almost entirely unnecessary, since the film only has some introductory titles that need translating. Nonetheless, the subtitle track keeps you informed of when the music changes mood from, say, "(soft orchestral music)," to "(hurried orchestral music)." It's ridiculously dumb, especially since the music doesn't typically fit the picture!

The pictures in question are structured to play out vaguely like "a day in the life" or to create a "city symphony" like Walther Ruttman's Berlin: Die Sinfonie der GroƟstadt. In Vertov's vision, the movie cameraman is a part of the Moscow ecosystem, distilling the essence of city life -- especially among the working class -- for the sake of later entertaining those who lived it. (The film is bookended by shots of a movie theater audience watching and enjoying the cameraman's labor.) Different sections of the film deal with the city "waking up" (not just the people, but the factory machinery and the city transports), or the general circle of life (images from a wedding, from a funeral, from a hospital birth, all cross-cut to suggest simultaneity), or the visual juxtaposition of different kinds of work (the hands of a seamstress matched to those of a manicurist matched to those of this film's editor Elizaveta Svilova).

The man with the movie camera (really, Vertov's brother Mikhail Kaufman and his colleagues) is the ever-present central figure. There are dozens of shots of the filmmakers laboring to capture the footage you are seeing: most impressively, improvised tracking shots off the sides of streetcars or on a tripod stationed in the back of a convertible. Through the use of tricky double-exposures, Vertov includes images of the cameramen floating like spectral sentinels high above the bustling city, doing their work.

While the film is founded upon a newsreel-style approach to capturing the images, Vertov employs numerous atypical tactics -- double-exposure, split screens, stop-motion animation, slow-motion, freeze-frames, aggressive (sometimes strobe-like) editing -- to create new, purely cinematic effects and meanings divorced from established narrative forms.

It's still a wildly impressive film. Man with a Movie Camera's DNA can be traced through hundreds of documentary, experimental, and art films in the ensuing years, but the effect here still feels unique and fresh.

The Video:
This film was released on Blu-ray six years ago, as part of a Dziga Vertov collection by Flicker Alley. Based on most accounts, that edition has been carefully restored and looks quite good. It's puzzling then why Kino's AVC-encoded 1080p 1.33:1 presentation (which, to be fair, is essentially the BFI's presentation) looks so rough and dirty. The film is consistently plagued by dirt, specks, and scratches, with some minor stains, density issues, and occasional image wobble. It just looks like a flat transfer from a print, with some tweaking done to the contrast. Based on other online reviews, this version is darker than either the BFI's Region B release or the Flicker Alley version.

Special Features:

  • Audio commentary by Adrian Martin - Like all of the bonuses, this is a well-researched combo of history and analysis.

  • The Life and Times of Dziga Vertov (HD, 46:33) - Film scholar Ian Christie provides an extremely thorough account of Dziga Vertov's career in a long talking-head interview. He discusses the development of Vertov's filmmaking process (we don't get many clips here, although some of these films were included in the 2015 Blu-ray set), his competitive relationship with the other Soviet cinema masters, and his gradual alienation from the mainstream film business.

  • Dziga Vertov: Non-Fiction Film Thing (HD, 20:18) - A video essay by David Cairns, who is quite good at this sort of thing, discusses the methodology of Dziga Vertov, both in Man with a Movie Camera and later films like Three Songs of Lenin. The clips used for Man with a Movie Camera are accompanied by an Alloy Orchestra musical score, which isn't perfect either, but seems to suit the style and rhythm of the film more.

Final Thoughts:
Man with a Movie Camera is as dazzling and strange as it was 90+ years ago. Any film buff worth their salt should check this film out. However, this presentation doesn't offer the film in the best light. While this stand-alone edition is cheaper than other Dziga Vertov Blu-ray collections on the market, I still think it's a Rent It at best.

Justin Remer is a filmmaker, oddball musician, and frequent wearer of beards. His new single, Don\\\'t Depend on Me, is now available to stream or download on Bandcamp, Spotify, Amazon, Apple, and wherever else fine music is enjoyed.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Rent It

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews
1. Battle Hymn
2. Dynasty (Blu-ray 3-D)
3. Man Push Cart: Criterion Collection
4. Nosferatu In Venice


Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links