Release List Reviews Price Search Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise
DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk TV
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns



DVD SAVANT

David and Lisa


David and Lisa
Image / Castle Hill
1962 / B&W / 1:33 flat full frame / 95 min. / Street Date May 10, 2007 / 24.99
Starring Keir Dullea, Janet Margolin, Howard Da Silva, Neva Patterson, Clifton James, Richard McMurray, Nancy Nutter, Matthew Arden, Coni Hudak, Jaime Sánchez
Cinematography Leonard Hirschfield
Art Direction Paul M. Heller
Film Editor Irving Oshman
Original Music Mark Lawrence
Written by Eleanor Perry from a novel by Dr. Theodore Isaac Rubin
Produced by Paul M. Heller
Directed by Frank Perry

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

David and Lisa was a minor art-house sensation in its time, an independent sleeper showered with praise by the critics. It was the brainchild of Frank and Eleanor Perry, a top creative couple who in the sixties brought out a series of 'East Coast Liberal' pictures. It was exactly what the art crowd was looking for in an American film -- an uplifting story about people dedicated to social issues. David and Lisa is a Romeo & Juliet story with characters who resemble something out of Greek mythology. She speaks only in rhymes, and he cannot bear to be touched.

Synopsis:

Disturbed high schooler David Clemens (Keir Dullea) is delivered to a State psychiatric home by his status-conscious mother (Neva Patterson) but rebels against the friendly efforts of Dr. Swinford (Howard Da Silva). Intelligent but socially volatile, David flies into a rage when touched. He remains stubborn despite the limitless patience of Swinford and his professionally unflappable staff (Clifton James and Nancy Nutter). David repels the other patients in residence -- all except for Lisa Brandt, a schizophrenic who stomps around and communicates only in a childish singsong rhyme. David treats Lisa with care and kindness and when she responds, they connect. But David's parents try to pull him out of the hospital and Lisa becomes jealous when David proves capable of associating with others.

Frank and Eleanor Perry had something special as a team, an intelligent toughness that made their films classic 'liberal cause' pictures. David and Lisa may not be a realistic study of disturbed kids but it has a firm belief in the essential goodness of progressive medicine and social services. Audiences approved of both this picture and John Cassavetes' equally earnest A Child is Waiting, a drama with a much more realistic take on children with mental problems.

The school in David and Lisa is a civilized place, not a nuthouse. The actual maladies of the other inmates are neither debilitating nor unpleasant, and we never find out exactly what most of them are. There's a quick round-up of interesting faces at the beginning. One boy, Simon (Matthey Arden) has a vague emotional disorder, whereas Carlos (Jaime Sanchez of The Wild Bunch in a very early role) seems to have a sex problem, coming on to both Simon and -- in a rather blunt scene for the time -- David's mom. All the kids dress respectably, eat their meals in an orderly fashion and require minimal maintenance. There are no cases of severe mental retardation and unlike today, we don't see any drugs being dispensed. David and Lisa are the toughest cases but their problems seem to be more family-related than mental.

This doesn't keep David and Lisa from being an interesting story as it often has the feel of a stage play opened up for the screen. The speeches are stylized as are the two 'lovers' complimentary ailments -- when they appear to be each other's perfect cure, we start to care very much about them. The ending doesn't disappoint, building to a tense climax and then resolving it with a symbolic scene of tender communication. It's the perfect feel-good liberal climax. If David and Lisa can find their way, can't the rest of us?

Keir Dullea is suitably rigid and antiseptic-looking, fastidious in his attire and eager to offend those who try to help him. He's obsessed with order and the concept of time. Eleanor Perry's screenplay keeps his neuroses tidy and consistent as he designs a clock that will always be accurate because it is controlled by radio (a very real thing now, of course). Mocking his doctor (played with enormous sensitivity by blacklisted actor Howard da Silva), David learns to empathize with others by 'playing psychiatrist' with Lisa. It's an understandably mannered performance that holds together well.

Janet Margolin would later make some good appearances in Woody Allen movies. She's delightful as the immature and mysterious Lisa, a role that could easily come off as idiotic or superficial. Margolin is convincingly adolescent and charming in her enforced baby-talk way of speaking. When David connects with Lisa it's as if someone turns on a switch inside her. Affection and kind attention don't guarantee cures in real life as they do here (did Lisa just need to be loved?) but Margolin makes the fantasy work.

The film's idealized ending implies that David and Lisa are going to be all right, giving the impression that mental illness is an emotional misunderstanding that can be fixed by improved communication. It's even implied that David might continue to study and become a doctor (or is Swinford humoring him?). The odd idea that mental patients are just ordinary people with antisocial quirks surfaced many times in the service of director's larger aims, in "meaningful" films like The Rain People. The convention was so familiar that in 1988's Rain Man it came as a big surprise that Dustin Hoffman's character not only isn't magically cured, but also will never return his brother's affection. In early Liberal Independent films feel-good scenes such as those were a "must" for proper dramatic closure. David and Lisa is worthy and valid as a drama, but unless the patients in Swinford's clinic are only meant to be mildly antisocial, it's a total fantasy.

Eleanor Perry's script follows the progressive trend to blame the parents, especially David's mother. She dresses like Jackie Kennedy and thinks of her son only in terms of her own needs and expectations. David's father is rich but weak, giving in to the domineering mother, another favorite theme of the time. David's disturbance is so family-based that David and Lisa almost seems an offshoot of the Rebel Without a Cause delinquency-apology films, the ones that blame anybody but the kids themselves.

The rest of the patients are potentially interesting but have very little screen time. Besides the prolific Sanchez, only Karen Lynn Gorney continued in films, playing Stephanie Mangano two decades later in Saturday Night Fever. Social worker/psychologist John is played by Clifton James, who of course became famous as Sheriff J.W. Pepper in two James Bond films. At this point he was an East coast actor familiar in liberal independents, especially several by Jack Garfein -- The Strange One and Something Wild with Garfein's wife Carroll Baker. James is so tender and patient in the role you won't believe it's the same actor who did the crude imitation of a Southerner opposite Roger Moore's 007.

After this success the Perrys veered in the direction of Stanley Kramer and the pitfall of even more self-conscious art filmmaking. Their followup Ladybug, Ladybug is a true story about panic in the wake of a false atomic alert at a small New England grade school. It's well-meaning but drags, and its message, War Is Not Healthy For Children and Other Living Things, is far too obvious. The Swimmer was slick but extremely pretentious, a surreal idea given a literal presentation and TV commercial visuals. Last Summer isn't seen much now but provided a nasty kick in 1969 with its tale of amoral teens committing rape and murder years before the nihilistic kicks of The River's Edge. It's marred by more deep message mongering but has breakthrough performances by young Barbara Hershey, Richard Thomas and Bruce Davison. And finally came Diary of a Mad Housewife, an encounter with a worst-case marriage horror scenario so harrowing that it did its feminist cause an injustice. Our only reaction to poor Carrie Snodgress' persecution by her husband Richard Benjamin, is deep despair. Interestingly, the Perry pictures after David and Lisa are all depressing downers, or openly apocalpytic.

After Housewife the Perrys seem to have broken up as a filmmaking team. Although Frank directed some notable titles (among them the cult disaster Mommie Dearest) they never garnered the critical approval given the couple's early pictures. Their first, David and Lisa is perhaps still their best.

Producer/Art Director Paul M. Heller went on to produce a wild selection of films including Enter the Dragon, Withnail and I and My Left Foot. He's anonymous here; on an Anchor Bay or Home Vision Entertainment disc we'd probably learn all about him.


Image's DVD of David and Lisa is a tiny improvement on an earlier Fox Lorber disc. It appears to be the same exact Castle Hill transfer, with a slightly better encoding: less stair-stepping, better detail. But it's still no beauty. The B&W transfer is flat instead of enhanced, with plenty of dead space above and below the original compositions. Audio is light now and then -- I adjusted volume several times. Too bad, as this show deserved better. There are no extras. (Note -- the packaging says HVe on the cover (Home Vision Entertainment), but the disc menus and back credits don't mention that label).


On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, David and Lisa rates:
Movie: Very Good
Video: Good -
Sound: Good -
Supplements: None
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: June 7, 2007





DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2007 Glenn Erickson

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © DVDTalk.com All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

Release List Reviews Price Search Shop SUBSCRIBE Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise