Release List Reviews Price Search Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise
DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk TV
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns



DVD SAVANT

Savant Review:

L'Avventura


L'Avventura
The Criterion Collection
1960 / b&w / 1:78 anamorphic 16:9 / 143 (145)m.
Starring Gabriele Ferzetti, Monica Vitti, Lea Massari, Dominique Blanchar, Renzo Ricci, James Addams, Dorothy De Poliolo, Lelio Luttazzi
Cinematography Aldo Scavarda
Art Direction Piero Poletto
Film Editor Eraldo Da Roma
Original Music Giovanni Fusco
Writing credits Michelangelo Antonioni, Elio Bartolini, Tonino Guerra, from a story by Michaelangelo Antonioni
Produced by Cino Del Duca, Raymond Hakim, Robert Hakim, Amato Pennasilico, Luciano Perugia
Directed by Michelangelo Antonioni

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

There are Art movies and there are Art movies, and L'Avventura is Art with a capital A.   Beautifully made in all departments, it's one of the Auteurist Italian classics that can hold its head high ... this is no sexy, commercial romp using its status as 'Art' to intimidate audiences.   L'Avventura is worthy of the title classic.  But it's not an easy read, and although easy to watch, it will probably bore or frustrate anything resembling a 'standard' audience.  And that's just fine.

Synopsis:

Claudia (Monica Vitti) is invited on a posh cruise by her friend Anna (Lea Massari), who is unhappy with her boyfriend Sandro (Gabrielle Ferzetti, of Once Upon a Time in the West).  While casually spending an afternoon on a rocky island, Anna simply disappears, cueing a fruitless search.  The rest of the wealthy boat-guests get back to visiting one another in villas or on the hotel circuit, while Sandro and Claudia keep trying to locate Anna on the mainland - and fall into a complicated, guilty affair at the same time.

Michaelangelo Antonioni (La Notte, Red Desert) is an easy target for film reactionaries.  It's his films that are criticized as being about people standing around doing nothing ... he's the artist whose movies are compared with 'watching paint dry.'  In film school, there were some pictures that just seemed to be too much damn work to even approach, let alone appreciate or enjoy.  Last Year at Marienbad, because I wasn't ready to commit hours of research into Resnais, remains a puzzle for which Savant's honest reaction is, 'Wha?'  And I like to think of myself as open to anything.

On this new Criterion DVD, I had no trouble whatsoever with L'Avventura.  The 'it just happens' approach to plotting, with events and character reactions being frustratingly arbitrary, no longer was a bother.  After years of movies with tight little stories for empty little minds, the freedom of L'Avventura's lack of imposed structure on its events is refreshing.

Like Psycho and The Seventh Victim, L'Avventura involves a missing woman.  But it refuses to become a thriller.  The petulant Anna is here one moment, and gone the next, and the mystery is both unexplainable - and infinitely explainable.   The film doesn't pretend to 'get inside' the characters, who are all blends of readable and unreadable reactions and behaviors.  Several could be quiet, conscience-free killers - but probably not.   There are loose ends that lead nowhere - the hermit on the island, the boatmen who may be hiding something more than their smuggling.  There's even a boat seen cruising in the distance, about the time Anna is noticed missing.  Perhaps Anna just took off, out of shallow pique, and is staying with other friends elsewhere.  Ever lost a dog or cat, and wondered how it could have disappeared into thin air?  Anna could be under a rock five feet away, or, as we naturally suspect, following her searchers as they check from town to town.

L'Avventura seemed more accessible this time around because there wasn't the nagging necessity of saying something 'meaningful' about it, that ruined most of my film-school writing.   The script is often not quite so mysterious.  As a rumination on relationships, it uses the disappearance to upset the applecart of a few lives ... and, lo and behold, once the novelty of her disappearance has passed, we find out that everyone's favorite woman is hardly missed.  Alfred Hitchcock must have bounced off of L'Avventura hard, as it obviously influenced him for his The Birds.  A mysterious unresolved tale of really unexplainable events should be even a bigger 'art' success, right?

One standout scene, where Sandro follows a reporter as he covers a starlet's publicity stunt, provided the key for Savant.  The woman is the exact opposite of 'missing', throwing herself into a fake situation calculated to attract the attention of huge numbers of men.  Her cheap trick of tearing her dress is like the lie Anna tells about the shark: Anna wants to shake things up, wants to feel needed and essential and irreplaceable, needs that the amorous but aloof Sandro doesn't fulfill.  Tonino Guerra's script is structured as a collection of similarly orchestrated bad relationships.  From the indolent Patrizia's (Esmeralda Ruspoli) heartless handling of her gigolo, to the unhappy wife of the pharmacist, nobody seems able to comfortably relate to their chosen companions.  At first we feel sorry for the browbeaten Giulia (Dominique Blanchar), until we see her selfishness and wanton ugliness, grandstanding her surrender to a young artist, using Claudia as an audience.

Under the circumstances, the chemistry between Claudia and Sandro is almost a nuisance.  The hesitancy and pain of their 'fling' (apparently a second Italian definition of 'Avventura') comes not just because the 'ghost' of Anna is always there to remind them of their unfaithfulness to her, but because neither has much faith in their future.  This same situation that added another sickly dimension the The Seventh Victim.  Yet there are no emotional scenes in L'Avventura of the lovers lamenting the fact that they're searching for the one woman who can spoil their new love.  It's as if they've lost belief in such things, as if sophistication has killed their ability to stand behind their own emotions.

A master of using film space, Antonioni's naturalistic compositions are very carefully worked out to enforce a feeling of individual isolation, no matter what the situation.  People roam a rocky hilltop, with distance and rough terrain separating them, or swim in a sea that might swallow them up at any moment.  No sharks, perhaps, but silvery dolphins, yes.  The mood of the characters changes depending on whether they're supported by 'traditional' architecture or oppressed by a blank and empty prefab town on a high ridge.  Sandro 'manages' women but can't relate to them ... he relates better to architecture, and when feeling vulnerable, is capable of meaningless acts of aggression, as shown in the bit where he jealously provokes a fight with a younger architecture-lover, big old dog vs. younger upstart.  The gorgeous visuals of Claudia rolling in ecstasy show her happy in romance and fixated on Sandro, who she obviously distrusts just the same.  Yet the ecstasy is contained within her, merely enjoyed by Sandro instead of being shared.  For Sandro every woman seems to be a fling, some more serious than others, but no woman is more important than his self-image as a ladykiller.  Men, after all, are those threatening aggressive faces that suddenly multiply on the street (almost like crows in The Birds), putting the powerless Claudia in a situation that inverts the starlet's earlier control of the crowd of hopped-up fans.

Yes, the movie does end with the characters settling into a stasis-composition, he in tears, she compassionate to the man who's wronged her, before a background that's half ancient building, and half distant, snow-covered mountains.  It's a slow ending, and can be interpreted to one's wit's end, with the snow representing the coldness between the characters, blah blah.  Or, if you just watch the movie and don't worry about critical analysis, you can feel these same ideas, your mind interpreting them for you.


Criterion's DVD of La'Avventura is a thing of beauty, as can be seen from the before & after restoration demo.  Those shimmering images (great on a widescreen TV) look so much better freed from a storm of flaky dirt.  A second disc contains a long and interesting docu on Antonioni from 1966, so really serious film enthusiasts have an extra reason to be attracted to the disc.  The commentary by Gene Youngblood, an essay by Geoffrey Nowell-Smith, and Antonioni's own statements on the film are also included.  Youngblood's critical-studies analysis of the film is authoritative, and as appropriately esoteric as film criticism gets.  Janus films' original 1961 American trailer shamelessly uses every moment of exploitable activity to make the movie look like an uninhibited romp of decadent Italians, a la La dolce vita.

Reacting to L'Avventura in itself was enough for Savant. ...  It's stylized in a way separate from Hollywood films yet its images communicate better than a literary script.  It's a discriminating movie, but its joys are the same as any other film.  Monica Vitti is a very likeable and very 'alive' presence on-screen, and I'm sure I'll watch it again soon just to enjoy being with her some more.


On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor,
L'Avventura rates:
Movie: Excellent
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: 2 discs, documentary Antonioni: Documents and Testimonials, Audio commentary with Gene Youngblood, Jack Nicholson's personal recollections of the director, Nicholson reading some writings by Antonioni, trailer, restoration demonstration.
Packaging: Double keep case
Reviewed: June 7, 2001



[Savant Links] [Article Index] [Review Index] [About Savant]

DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2007 Glenn Erickson

Go BACK to the Savant Main Page.

Return to Top of Page

Coming Soon

DVD Release List

Special Offers

Columns






Home Release List Coupons Shop Reviews Forum Video Games Price Search Advertise
Copyright 2007 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy , Terms of Use