Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Patton

Fox // PG // May 23, 2006
List Price: $19.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Ian Jane | posted May 17, 2006 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:

One of the most celebrated films of the early 1970s, Franklin J. Schaeffer's Academy Award winning Patton has been released on DVD a couple of times in different versions for different territories but Fox has gone back to the well one last time with this recent two disc set appearing under their Cinema Classics Collection banner. Few films are worth the double or triple dip, but Patton is one of the rare exceptions and thankfully, this disc delivers.

Based on the life and times of General George S. Patton (played by George C. Scott), the movie begins with Patton in charge of a battalion of tanks operating in North Africa. As the evolves, so too does Patton's role in the American military and we see his career grow as he works on campaigns that eventually eat away at the core of the German army and eventually end the Second World War with a victory for the Allied Forces. As the story plays out we learn not only about what made Patton a great man from a historical perspective but we also learn what made him human – his faults, his quirks, and yes, even his weaknesses. He was an extremely stubborn man who often times refused to play by anyone's rules but his own and it was this egotism that, in a very Shakespearian way, eventually cost him his place at the top.

What makes this movie so incredibly good is not the excellent direction or the excellent script but the completely amazing performance from George C. Scott. He famously refused the Academy Award that was bestowed upon him for his work in this movie but, regardless of what he may have thought (he didn't like the Oscars and went on record calling them 'a meat parade'), he was completely worthy of such an honor for as those who have seen the movie will attest, he doesn't so much play Patton as he becomes Patton. Everything from the mannerisms to the speech patterns to the accent to the facial expressions is nailed down tight as can be by Scott in this, the performance he will always be best remembered for. When one watches some of the archival footage supplied in the supplemental material in this set it is made painfully clear just how into the role Scott got, and the evidence is all up there on the screen for everyone to see – history has called this one of the greatest performances ever, and for very good reason, as Scott's work here still lives up to the hype. Schaeffer wisely lets Scott run with the material and from the opening scene, that famous moments where Scott, in character and full uniform, gives a speech taken from various actual speeches that Patton did give throughout his career, we know we're in for a treat.

Aside from Scott's amazing work, however, Patton also benefits from a really interesting supporting cast of actors, some better known than others. First and foremost is Karl Maulden as General Omar Bradley. While Maudlen has shown up in all manner of movies and television shows, from Dario Argentos's Cat O' Nine Tails to The Magical World Of Disney, his turn here is one of his better known performances and his instantly recognizable appearance lends an air of rough, worldliness to Bradley's character and in turn an air of believability as well. Michael Strong and Stephen Young, who play General Hobart Carver and Captain Hansen respectively, are also very good in the film and their interaction with Scott is appropriately tense.

Where Schaeffer's direction really shines, aside from the pacing and knowing when to let his actors go and when to real them in, is during the action scenes. While modern audiences might find the scenes of combat in the film lackluster in that they're not full of rapid editing tricks and slow motion bullet ballet, they are sufficiently exciting and at times very realistic. Though at times it might feel as if the movie pulls back from showing the real horrors of war (the violence is there but the after effects are kept to a minimum) the execution of some of these scenes is not only visually impressive but also logistically interesting as well.

Of course, great performances and impressive battle scenes don't mean much if the movie itself isn't interesting, and thankfully Patton was a quirky enough fellow in real life that we're able to enjoy his story in addition to the acting and the battle scenes. His tendency to strive in the face of the enemy and his unbending will make him fascinating and the fact that the movie does not gloss over his faults (highlighted by a very important scene in which he slaps a soldier – a move which would prove to be very important later on in his career thanks to the extremely negative effects it had on him) or his flaws makes it all the more interesting. The film is not hero worship, nor is it an idealized portrait of a very important historical figure, rather it is simply a fairly factual portrayal of the man behind some of the most important events in the Second World War. The focus is not on the action or on the impact but on the person behind it. One could make the argument that the film glorifies combat and idealizes war by glossing over the details and the after effects (see Oliver Stone's contribution to the supplements for more on that) but in the context of the film, in that it's told from Patton's perspective for the most part, war was a great thing. Telling the story through the eyes of someone who was very much into what he was doing as a soldier does not necessarily translate to the glorification of combat and Scott's performance alludes to that. Patton is not always sympathetic and he's completely obsessed with his work. He might be a little unstable as we see in a few specific scenes, and his mind is not always a healthy place. This doesn't proclaim that war is good, it simply makes for a more interesting, and historically accurate, biographical film.

The DVD

Video:

Patton hits DVD in an excellent brand new 2.20.1 anamorphic widescreen transfer that looks fantastic (previous releases were 2.35.1 but the 70mm prints were supposedly shown projected at 2.20.1 and the framing on this release looks just fine). Sure, there is some grain present in a few spots and if you look really carefully you might even see some mild print damage present in a couple of scenes in the form of the odd speck here and there but other than that, the image looks great. Edge enhancement and aliasing are never problematic and mpeg compression artifacts are virtually non-existent. Color reproduction looks dead on and black levels remain strong and deep throughout the duration of the film. Both foreground and background detail is strong and even during darker moments the image always remains very clean and very clear. Skin tones look lifelike and natural and the picture stays sharp from start to finish.


Sound:

Fox has included four audio options for the feature on the first disc – English Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound, English Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround, Spanish Dolby Digital Mono and French Dolby Digital Mono. Optional subtitles are included in English and Spanish and an English language closed captioning option is provided for the feature itself.

Clarity and balance on both the English language tracks is rock solid. The dialogue and performers come through loud and clear without ever sounding over done or pumped up in the mix. Jerry Goldsmith's excellent score is crystal clear and all but the faintest hints of hiss have been removed from the mix. Bass response is tight and lively when it needs to be but more subdued and toned down when the storyline calls for it, which results in a nice, even mix throughout playback. Sadly, the DTS mix that was found on the PAL release from the UK is not included on this set.

Extras:

The only supplements on the first disc are an introduction from and a commentary track by Francis Ford Coppola, who co-wrote the screenplay for the film and has obviously gone on to become a great director in his own right. The introduction briefly covers how Coppola was given the job of writing the movie, and how he figured it would be a pretty interesting challenge. He explains his take on the character and how he wound up being pulled off the project and it's a nice way of putting the movie into some sort of context before the film starts this introduction runs four minutes and fifty four seconds in length..

Coppola's commentary begins by explaining the opening of the film, which he wrote, and what he was trying to get across with it and how that same opening, which is probably the most famous part of the movie, got him into trouble. He also covers how he wanted the dialogue to be realistic and how he wanted to keep the historical side of the film as accurate as possible, going into detail on little things like the fact that American tanks at the beginning of the Second World War were gasoline powered and not diesel powered. He discusses Patton's obsession with the 'pageantry of war' and why he feels it meant so much to him, and he also talks about North's contributions to the script and how he never actually directly worked with him on the movie. Coppola also details how some of the battle scenes were done, and how the scene where Patton shoots at the enemy planes with his revolver was based on an actual event. He also covers how he needed to emphasize certain aspects of Patton's biography to get his point across and how certain events in his military career carried more importance than others and as such they logically get more focus in the film. It's a good commentary and an informative one – at least the first half of it is - but as the movie hits the ninety minute mark, Coppola runs out of things to say and as such more and more dead air creeps into the track and it turns into less a reflection of Coppola's experiences on the film and more an explanation of certain events that unfold on the screen with a few anecdotes tossed in. That being said, as the movie gets closer to the finale, Coppola finds his inspiration again and the track picks back up.

The rest of the extra features are found on the second disc where things start off with a documentary entitled History Through The Lens: Patton – A Rebel Revisited. This hour and a half long feature length look at the real life Patton and how his life was adopted for the big screen is a very comprehensive and interesting examination of the man behind the film. A lot of what makes this interesting is the interviews with the military officers who have been inspired by Patton, as well as Patton's son, as we get a first hand look at the man that the movie was based on. It's fascinating to hear how a film about Patton was first proposed in the fifties and how the filmmaker's wanted to get Patton's cooperation in making the movie but didn't get it. Instead opted to put the focus on Patton's military career rather than his personal life. They went about doing this by researching a lot of old newsreels and archival material. From here we learn how it was brought back and how Coppola handled the first draft of the screenplay, and from here we go on to learn about Patton's childhood and how he got into the military. Through clips from the movie, old photographs, interviews and other details we learn how the real George Patton was recreated through Scott's performance. This is interesting stuff and its sure to please fans of the film – they even cover his poetry and why he wrote it in the first place, which seems to atypical of a tough man such as Patton.

A second documentary entitled Patton's Ghost Corps focuses on the veterans who served under George Patton during the Second World War in Germany. Their stories are pretty harrowing, the documentary starts off with a few of the interviewees discussing how their men were killed and how Patton was responsible for a lot of unnecessary deaths out on the battlefield because of his bravado and ego. There are a lot of archival pictures and film clips in here to illustrate what the interviewees are talking about as they cover how they got involved in the army and what their experiences were like once they got to Europe. Some stoic narration fills in the blanks, discussing the strategy that we hear about from those who were involved in its execution, as well as the results. There are some really touching stories in here to compliment the more horrifying ones and it's nice to see the men who served under Patton and who made him the man that history sees him as get some credit. This documentary runs just over forty-six minutes in length.

The Making Of Patton is a third documentary that, as the title states, explores the making of the movie. This lengthy fifty minute look at how the film was put together is pretty interesting although there's definitely some cross over here in content with the first History Through The Lens piece. Almost everyone who worked with director Franklin J. Schaeffer on the film is interviewed here, including George C. Scott (this piece was done before he died in 1999) and they all seem to unanimously agree that he was a complete and total gentleman to work with. Oliver Stone shows up here to give us his thoughts on the film and accuse it for being in some part responsible for the bombing of Cambodia, which is an interesting theory if perhaps a little misguided (he claims that Nixon was so influenced by Patton that it resulted in his decision to launch that first attack which in turn resulted in the bombing). Other interviewees in this piece include Richard Zanuck, Jerry Goldsmith, Fred Koenekamp, Franklin J. Schaeffer himself, and the film's producer, Frank McCarthy. The interviews are nicely complimented by some behind the scenes clips as well as a small assortment of camera tests.

Fox has also included two still galleries on this disc. The first gallery is a huge selection of production stills that play out in slide show format with Goldsmith's complete score over top (thirty-six minutes in length). The second gallery features a selection of behind the scenes photographs and it's accompanied by an audio essay entitled The Historical Patton by Charles M. Province of the General George S. Patton Historical Society. Through this fifty-three minute speech (the same one that was on previous releases of the movie on DVD) is very comprehensive if a bit dry. Province does a fine job of explaining how accurate the movie is and in detailing some little bits and pieces about Patton that the film isn't really able to touch on as well. This guy knows his stuff and if you want to know even more about the real life man behind the inspiration for the film, you'll get it here.

Rounding out the supplements on the second disc is the original theatrical trailer for the feature. Both discs include animated menus and chapter selection options. The review copy provided did not contain an insert of any kind though it did have the two discs housed inside a keepcase which in turn was housed inside an attractive slip case – a nice touch.

Final Thoughts:

While the first two domestic releases of the film were nice, this new Fox Cinema Classics Collection two disc special edition release of Patton trumps them (or, in the case of the audio, at least matches them) in pretty much every way possible, especially when one looks at the supplements provided. The movie looks and sounds terrific but the real reason to upgrade (if you have a previous version) is the extras as they are as interesting as they are informative and, dare I say it, educational. Highly recommended!

Ian lives in NYC with his wife where he writes for DVD Talk, runs Rock! Shock! Pop!. He likes NYC a lot, even if it is expensive and loud.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Highly Recommended

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links