DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » The Roller Derby Chronicles (Rolling Thunder, Derby, vintage derby matches)
The Roller Derby Chronicles (Rolling Thunder, Derby, vintage derby matches)
Other // G // November 10, 2009
List Price: $59.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Paul Mavis | posted November 12, 2009 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly

You just knew I was going to like this one. VSC has released The Roller Derby Chronicles, a highly entertaining three-disc set devoted to the history of this wholly American sport. Featuring Rolling Thunder, an all-new documentary on the game's evolution, 1971's celebrated cinema verite documentary, Derby, and hours and hours of vintage game films and tapes from matches spanning the 1950s through the 1970s, the sum total of The Roller Derby Chronicles set is the most thorough examination of the sport I've encountered on disc (it may be the only one, for that matter). So tip the BarcaLounger® back, snag your wooden bowl of Beer Nuts®, crack open a cold brown bottle of Schlitz®, and settle in for some high-powered skating and some head-bustin' jamming.

DISC ONE

Rolling Thunder

Produced this year for Canadian television and directed by Larry Gitnick, Rolling Thunder looks back at the founding of the sport during the Great Depression, all the way up through its heyday and ultimate demise during the 1970s ("demise" is correct because what exists of "roller derby" today has little to do with Seltzer's entity, either in conception or execution). According to Rolling Thunder, roller derby was invented by film promoter Leo Seltzer, who had had earlier success promoting dance marathons that were popular during the late 20s and early 30s. Combining that format of entertainment masquerading as a sporting event, with a sudden roller skating craze in the mid-30s, Seltzer eventually built a touring "roller derby" competition made up of teams that were culled from local skating clubs he organized all over the country. At this point in the derby's evolution, Seltzer emphasized the sporting aspects of roller derby over any staged shenanigans. But soon, it became apparent that roller derby would go the way of other traveling marathon sporting events such as bicycling or dance competitions if it didn't offer something new to the rowdy Depression-era spectators who wanted action. With an assist by celebrated author and roller-derby co-inventor Damon Runyon, who pushed Seltzer into loading up derby competitions with contact moves (such as the always popular smashing into and over the track's rail) and "fights" (not real, but still physically punishing), Seltzer soon had a massive, crowd-pleasing "sport" on his hands.

After much trial and error, Seltzer hit upon a successful game formula. Two teams of five skaters would race each other counterclockwise on a banked track, as appointed "jammers" tried to score points by lapping the other teammates. For each player lapped, the jammer's team got a point. There were eight periods of play, with men and women skaters alternating on the track. Games weren't "fixed," and at this point, Seltzer discouraged the skaters from playing up to the audiences with outsized theatricality. Seltzer eventually franchised his derby out, with as many as six teams under his control touring the country. Although WWII dealt a body blow to the sport, it came back stronger than ever immediately after the war, due in no small part to Seltzer's use of TV airings to build crowds. According to Rolling Thunder, the derby's debut on television (the doc says it was the Dumont network, but other sources say CBS) caused a sensation with audiences, with both TV and in-arena audiences inflating each other into truly impressive numbers (over a five day period, some 80,000 people showed up for derby matches at Madison Square Gardens in 1951). TV would eventually hurt the sport in the 50s when audiences began to dwindle. As more people owned their own set, they quit buying tickets to the live events, opting to stay at home and watch for free...which choked off the sport that made its money not from TV licensing fees (which were relatively paltry), but from gate admissions. This love-hate relationship with television would repeat itself again in the 60s and 70s when Seltzer's derby enjoyed a surprising resurgence. With son Jerry Seltzer at the helm of the organization in 1958, he eventually hit on an idea of syndicating game tapes of the few remaining derby matches that survived out on the West coast, to local TV stations. While syndication fees for the tapes were small, some advertising time was kicked back, as well, and with the successful re-introduction of roller derby to a new generation of TV fans, the national touring teams of the derby could continue again, reaching even bigger crowds at mainline venues. Eventually, several factors conspired to end Seltzer's derby, including the oil embargo of 1973 (it was no longer economically feasible to maintain the touring teams, with profit margins so slim and gas, when not rationed, skyrocketing in price), a decline in the quality of the skating as new, inexperienced skaters were added to the rosters, and overexposure on TV (a fad's a fad). Roller derby lives on today in local organizations, but it isn't a solitary business entity like Seltzer's derby, nor does it reach millions of TV and arena fans as it once did during its golden age.

Rolling Thunder, hosted by celebrated track announcer Donald Drewry (he intros all the discs here), comes in at a speedy 48:37, giving a good generalized overview of the sport for those not familiar with the derby's history. Even though time is tight here (owing, no doubt, to having to fit within an hour's worth of TV time, with commercials), some good little tidbits of info are parceled out for fans, including the way TV instantly changed the game (the skaters immediately started to ham it up for the cameras), and how difficult it was for a player out on the road (one player switched to setting up the track - it paid double what he made as a relatively famous player). New interviews with greats such as Mike Garmon, Francine Cochu, Gwen "Skinny Mini" Miller alternate with vintage looks at other superstars of the sport such as Joan Weston ("The Golden Amazon!"), Anne Calvello, and Mr. Roller Derby himself, Charlie O'Connell (why someone didn't give that guy his own sports talk show, I'll never know), with Rolling Thunder utilizing quite a bit of archival material to good advantage. Only towards the end of Rolling Thunder did I wish there was more time on the clock; the demise of the sport in the 70s, and the subsequent perversion of it into a pro-wrestling/circus-like entertainment via the Roller Games organization, are big themes in the sport's history. But they're rushed through here at the end with only a few spare minutes of screen time. Still, for a crash-course in the game and its historical context, Rolling Thunder is well-done.

Derby

Back in 1970, when roller derby was enjoying the absolute height of its second golden age, roller derby owner Jerry Seltzer commissioned this documentary on the sport, enlisting Robert Kaylor to photograph and direct it, I would assume, with the intent of further publicizing Seltzer's business (unfortunately, the two commentary tracks that are available on the stand-alone DVD release of Derby - commentaries that apparently provided a wealth of information on the film and its production - are not included on this set). And you can see some of that footage here, as the filmmaker records derby greats like Ann Calvello and Charlie O'Connell discussing what the game means to them in terms that are quite revealing at times (O'Connell's trip back to the New York City park where he first roller skated as a child is both sweet and sad), while also hitting the banked track with some energetic hand-held footage that shows what punishment these skaters took, even if the "fights" were mock (take a running jump on a hard wood floor and land on your ass...and then do it again and again about ten times in an hour...and then do it almost every night for nine months). We get some glimpses into the relatively hard life the skaters lived out on the road (in comparison to other comparable sports stars of that era): little pay, no glamour, and not even the most basic necessity of a traveling sports team - a bus (the skaters actually drove themselves to the games all over the country).

And all of that is quite interesting in that instantly recognizable grunge cinema verite style of Derby's. The camera stays close and rolls on; the available lighting is bad, the shots grainy, and the subjects are only observed...with commentary supplied later in the editing. The skaters aren't made fun of (nor are they pitied or championed). Events are...recorded in these segments. Where Derby really comes alive is when the documentary obviously abandons its mission - tell the story of 1970 roller derby for its owner and the film's producer, Jerry Seltzer - and becomes something much more in the telling of would-be roller derby skater Mike Snell's story. Fairly early on in the film, we're treated to a blandly depressing locker-room peek at the players, complete with a ref zipping up after taking a leak. Suddenly, there's a knock on the door, and in comes Mike Snell, a 25-year-old employee of the Dayton Tire and Rubber Company. Conversing with a skeptical but polite Charlie O'Connell, Snell makes it clear: he's quitting his job and moving to California to enroll in the roller derby training school for a chance - a chance - at trying out later for one of the teams. Snell has worked on the line for three years; his pay isn't great, but he's supporting his wife Christina, his two young children, his younger brother Butch, his parents...and a veritable bevy of girlfriends on the sly (you could do that with 1970 dollars).

Derby was a big hit with critics when it came out in 1971, many of whom responded to the film's impish fixation on the low-class hijinks of horn-dog Snell. But it struck a sour note with hard-core derby fans who wanted to see more of the game and the famous players and much, much less of Mike Snell and his family. As much as I enjoyed the Snell segments of Derby, I did find myself wanting to get a better understanding of the milieu that held such fascination for a guy like Snell. Much of Derby focuses on Snell's almost blasé certitude that he'll better his life by becoming a derby skater, and it's difficult to argue with that prediction when you see exactly what kind of life he leads. Predating Jerry Springer and Maury Povich by twenty years, the Snell saga involves dead-end factory jobs (Snell shows up for work when he shows up...and who can blame him), crummy, run-down houses, slack-jaw TV gorping as a substitute for wish fulfillment, assorted fringe friends, and the excitement - for both Mike and his wife - of his cheating around (having to confront one of Mike's girlfriends - the film's best scene - Christina at least seems grateful for something different to do that day). Add to that some genuinely strange, hilarious scenes involving Mike's younger brother Butch, who lives down in the basement, reading Playboys and making deceptively wise-ass comments inbetween his avoiding doing the smallest task, and you have a potent little slice of crumbling (both economically and morally) lower-middle class America, circa 1971. However, to make the connection between Mike's actual life, and what he dreams it will be, we should get a better look at his obsession: the derby. And that doesn't happen in Derby. There are a few scenes with derby superstar Charlie O'Connell - thoughtful, telling scenes where he discusses his childhood as well as his anticipated retirement - that are no less compelling than the Mike Snell scenes...but they come and then go as the Snell sequences dominate. O'Connell could easily have been the main subject of Derby, and perhaps viewers would have seen a more layered side of the game had the filmmakers stuck with this giant in the derby. Who can say? As it stands, though, it's ironic that the thoroughly engaging Derby is much more likely to appeal to those viewers who normally wouldn't be caught dead attending a roller derby tournament.

DISC TWO AND THREE

My favorite part of The Roller Derby Chronicles set: game films and tapes. That's right - vintage roller derby is back. I was pretty small, but I have distinct, wonderful memories of going to the derby at our local sports arena back during the game's slow death in the early 70s (was it Seltzer's derby? Maybe....). And the old man knew just how to make the experience complete: he bought the tall cups of popcorn so that when my brothers and I were done eating, we could pop the waxed bottoms out and use the long cups as megaphones...and he let us scream our heads off. Think of the opening of Slap Shot, and you'll get a picture-perfect visual reference for that arena, with the dirty cinderblock walls and trash in all the corners, the loud buzzing of the yellowed florescent lights, the small, pissed-off crowds screaming for something to happen, and the past-it athletes turning round and round on their crappy little make-shift banked track. Jesus, that was a good show. You kind of get that grungy feeling when watching some of the videotaped games from the 70s included here (I particularly like it when the camera tries to stay framed on just the few rows of seats that are occupied), but I really enjoyed the earlier filmed footage from the 50s, with the huge banked track and the powerful skaters who really emphasized form and athleticism over any kind of showboating (listen to the announcers playing up to the fans, 50s-style; one enthusiastic announcer details Charlie O'Connell's stats, adding at the end, "...and he's single!"). Disc Two includes the second half of a 1959 match between the Chicago Westerners and the San Francisco Bay Bombers; the second half of a 1960 match between the New York Chiefs and Bay Bombers; the second half of a 1974 match between the Los Angeles Thunderbirds and the Canadian All Stars; and periods seven and eight of a 1952 match the New York Chiefs and the Jersey Jolters. On Disc Three, two full derby games are included: 1973's New York Chiefs versus the San Francisco Bay Bombers and 1977's Brooklyn Red Devils versus the Bay Bombers. Baby, that is almost 7 hours of vintage roller derby action on those two last discs. Jams are blocked. Fake punches are thrown to the head. Up and over the railing spikes occur with abandon. Fros are mussed. It's...beautifully American in its utter sincerity and total shine-on b.s., and I for one miss it like mad. If they're showing vintage films of roller derby on some cable show, I'm unaware of it, so this is the first time I've seen the game in all its polyester glory in over thirty years...and it was more than worth the wait.

The DVD:

The Video:
Rolling Thunder is presented in a crisp, 1.78:1 anamorphically enhanced widescreen transfer, with excellent color, a sharp image, and no compression issues. Derby is presented in its correct 1.33:1 aspect ratio. Blown up from 16mm, don't expect much more than a lot of grainy, scratched, dark shots, and you won't be disappointed. All the rest of the vintage game footage is presented in the correct 1.33:1 aspect ratio, as well, with the older filmed elements in black and white, and the newer videotaped games in color (that nasty video color from the 70s).

The Audio:
The Dolby Digital English 2.0 stereo soundtrack is fine for Rolling Thunder, but the original elements for the archival footage are obviously compromised (and not by the transferring or the authoring of the disc). Warble, squelchiness, and lots of hiss, but what were you expecting? Digital purity? Serviceable, but no subtitles or close-captions.

The Extras:
There's a terrific reproduction of a 1969 Sports Illustrated article, The Roller Derby, by Frank Deford, included here. Printed on heavy, glossy paper (20 pages) with the original color photos gorgeously reproduced, this is equivalent to the kind of quality mag reprints they do for Criterion releases (it's extremely well-written by Deford, as well). At the back are "track notes," detailing the contents of the three discs, along with complete players listings for all the games - sweet.

Final Thoughts:
The single most complete experience of roller derby you can find on disc. The Roller Derby Chronicles from VSC jams through the history of the derby, giving us everything from a cool cinema verite doc that looks sideways at the phenomenon, to hours and hours of vintage game footage. It's one of my favorite releases this year. If it had just included those two missing commentaries for Derby, it would have received the highest rating we have here at DVDTalk: the DVD Talk Collector Series. Still, a highly recommended buy.


Paul Mavis is an internationally published film and television historian, a member of the Online Film Critics Society, and the author of The Espionage Filmography.

Popular Reviews
1. Fargo: Remastered Edition
2. Star Trek: Enterprise - Season Four
3. Demons
4. Angry Birds Toons - Season 01 Volume 02
5. Double Indemnity - 70th Anniversary Limited Edition
6. Little House on the Prairie - Season One & The Pilot Movie
7. The Dean Martin Celebrity Roasts: Fully Roasted
8. Norma Rae: 35th Anniversary
9. Performance
10. Hill Street Blues: The Complete Series


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use